The CD Thread
 

I was talking with a friend the other day about music, and I was shocked to find out that she also buys albums on CD still. I know I'm in the minority here, but who else out there prefers to buy their music on CD?

Obviously if it's just a few songs I'm looking for I'll download them digitally. But if it's an entire album I want, I just can't justify spending the $9.99 - $14.99 for a bunch of digital files, especially when I can buy the CD for around the same price (sometimes cheaper). I like to look at the artwork / packaging, etc. I can rip the CD right onto my computer and load the album onto my phone that way.

What are your thoughts on buying albums on CD?

Re: The CD Thread
 

When I started buying vinyl again about a year ago I stopped buying CDs cold turkey (own about 1500-2000). With everything on Spotify at my fingertips I just can't justify it.

The only exception I can think of was Dylan's complete Basement Tapes last year.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I still only buy music on cd. And I buy a lot of it.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I generally still buy on CD. Mostly to have a physical backup of the music I put on my MP3 player. But sometimes it's easier to grab a CD or two to pop in the car CD player, than it is to make an MP3 CD, or hook up my MP3 player.

Re: The CD Thread
 

If I'm paying money for music, I want a physical,copy.

Though I find myself mostly uninterested in buying music these days, as I find the stuff I already have sufficient. Most new music falls into the dategory of "listen to it once, sits on my shelf collecting dust" and "your old stuff was better" from artists I like.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Same

Re: The CD Thread
 

I still buy 95% of my music on cd. My car doesn't have hookups for an mp3 player or anything like that, but it does have a cd player. When I first got the car 6 years ago, I binged on cds, getting caught up on stuff I'd overlooked. Now, I have slowed down quite a bit, just buying the occasional title. I have gotten sick of the space they they take up though, and recently moved them all from jewel cases into a couple of very large binders.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I rarely buy CDs anymore, as I have pretty much zero interest in new music and have complete discographies of a lot of my favorite artists. I will buy digitally when it's just a "45", and mostly just pop music of my youth. The only album I've received digitally is that U2 album that Apple dumped in our laps last year, and it's largely unplayed.

I have been thinking about getting into Vinyl, mainly because it could be fun to go and root out old records. Any new purchases would be nice packages of longtime favorites.

Re: The CD Thread
 

No, only the occasional used disc for my collection, but for listening it's Pandora or borrowing CDs from the library.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I sometimes buy CD's from Amazon because of their auto rip feature. You get the the CD+MP3 version for just a couple buck more than the MP3 version alone. So sure, why not.

Still, they feel like a waste of space. I can't believe that 10 years ago I used to carry around a 100 CD binder & have to swap out whatever I felt like listening. Nowadays I have 3xx that many albums on a stick the size of my pinky fingernail, permanently plugged into my car stereo.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I still buy CDs, but very few. These days I only get maybe 3-4 a year, as opposed to 3-4 a month. I've got a boatload of music already, and I don't have as much fun finding new music as I used to.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Bingo... I'm the same way.

I still buy CDs... and I go through spurts. I'll buy 3 or 4 a year, and then I'll buy that much in a month or so. Basically it's when I'm in the mood.

I've bought around 15 CDs/SACDs in the last couple months though through Amazon resellers for cheap - whether it's "like new" or unopened. I love the idea of paying $3-$5 for a CD and with the exception of new releases from only a handful of artists.

I'd rather have a big CD/SACD collection than a BD collection. Music is much more random and I can go through so many different artists/CDs in one evening - making the collection feel much more worth it. I don't get the same feeling with movies.

Eventually I'll want to get a high-end music server so I can play the ripped FLAC files off it and not have to fumble with discs and such - but I'll still be buying the CDs.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Sometimes they're even less than the MP3 version. Especially on older catalog titles.

I preordered the Yes Atlantic Studios Albums box set and Amazon emailed me telling me the autorip download was available almost two weeks before it shipped. Not much incentive to even take the plastic off at that point.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I stopped buying CDs a year or two ago. I'm actually in the process of getting rid of all my CDs right now. I realized that they're all ripped into my computer and just sit on the shelf collecting dust anyway. I have way too much clutter in my life, so that was an obvious place to start.

Currently, I use Spotify or buy an album on iTunes or Amazon if I really want to own it. For physical copies, I just buy vinyl now.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I only buy CDs and will continue to only buy CDs until they pull them from the market. Why purchase MP3s when you can hear the same music for free on YouTube most of the time?

The day is approaching, however, when the labels stop fully servicing the CD market. Target has a new media re-design coming that cuts CDs down to one measly rack of newish releases. It's going to get more and more difficult to buy CDs at retail.

I actually think music stores might make a small comeback, now that the big chains are getting out of CD sales.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I buy maybe about 5 CDs a year these days. Most of the ones I've been buying lately are greatest hits of various classic rock/r&b/country/pop bands to round out my collection with.

I buy MP3's from Amazons for one hit songs by various new artists I hear on the radio stations (mostly the college type of radio station that play stuff the other radio stations don't) (after going thru song samples on Amazon). If I only like the one song by them, I'll buy it, amass a few others and then burn a CD compilation of them all together.

Re: The CD Thread
 

CD's for me (and used only) - old habits die hard. I don't purchase downloads. Although if I need one song that I'd personally never purchase I have sources. I still stand by my opinion that the recording industry fucked themselves big time by not adjusting the price of CD's in the 90's and obviously the 2000's. The same thing is happening to the movie industry with ticket prices and physical copies.

All the hipster kids I work with 20-30 year olds don't even go to the movies let alone buy DVD/Blu Rays. It's amazing to see it - they all have rips of the movies and then they don't even keep physical copies. They'll end up deleting their copy because they feel it will always be available somehow to download again from wherever they get it from. So strange, the difference in generations.

Re: The CD Thread
 

That's what our last remaining REAL record store has been hoping.

That can't be said enough times! I've been buying CD for **30 YEARS** now, and the reason given for why they were a few bucks more than records or cassettes was that they cost more to manufacture, but eventually the prices would come down. Instead they went UP starting in 1993! Then they started raising the prices on OLDER titles as well! $18.99 list for a regular-edition single disc album is absolutely ridiculous (that was the typical list price when Tower Records went out of business a few years ago- don't know if it's still that way currently).

I've lost most of my enthusiasm for buying CDs, but downloads HAVEN'T replaced that- if there's music I want, I still buy it on CD. I'll admit Spotify has contributed a bit to me buying less music (I use the free version with commercials) but if there's something I REALLY like I'll go buy it, as Spotify could start charging or take any songs offline at any time. Plus CDs just SOUND better!

Re: The CD Thread
 

I don't buy as much music as I used to but generally speaking when I do I want a physical copy and CDs are still easiest. I buy the occasional vinyl copy of an album too but usually I reserve that for an artist or album I really like. I've really cut back on buying music though and probably bought under ten albums last year. Haven't gotten one this year and the only thing even on my radar is the soundtrack to Kurt Cobain: Montage of Heck whenever it releases.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I'll still buy the occasional CD if it's the only option available and/or I'm feeling impulsive.
Otherwise, I stick to streaming music for checking out new/old stuff. If it's not there, I'll probably skip it entirely. :shrug:
If it's something I feel compelled to own, I'll opt for vinyl if it's an option. I like when the vinyl comes with a CD that I can throw in my car for a few months, but hate when a code for MP3s is included, since I have absolutely zero interest in maintaining a "MP3 library" of my own anymore.
I worked at a major record store up here for a few years, so I have a collection of 800+ CDs... I just... don't want to deal with them if I don't have to.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I buy about 30% on CD still. Mostly just favorite artists. I also tend to try and buy through the band's website to get promo bonuses or autographs.

Any new bands I try out I tend to just go digital.

Because pulling up YouTube videos while you're driving isn't the best idea?

:up: The record industry fucked themselves and deserved it.

Re: The CD Thread
 

The record industry definitely kept prices as high as possible on albums until they had to start competing with free Internet downloads. It used to be a miracle to see a new-release CD sell under $10.

I still do, but I'm one of those weirdo physical media holdouts. As I can put it straight into it iTunes anyway, I find it pretty convenient. But I'm such a small minority that I'm kind of surprised that CDs are even still around.

To be honest, no matter how low they dropped the prices, I don't think that they could compete with the digital market.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I still buy CDs but I'm more selective than ever because I feel overwhelmed by my collection sometimes. I'll rip a copy to a CD-R for my car and that's usually my main method of listening to music but physical copies sound way better than MP3s.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I buy new releases on CD, and if it's from Amazon, I just use the autorip to put it into itunes as I do the most of my listening on mobile devices anyway. Then I can get the CD on slow prime shipping for another digital buck, which I spend on MP3 singles or cheap catalog albums. I believe it's legally questionable to then sell the CDs so I hold onto those.

Youtube is great for sampling music or listening to random stuff, but it doesn't replace putting tracks on my mobile device.

I sometimes use Pandora but haven't really dug into Spotify.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I still like to buy CDs if it's an artist or album I really like. If it's just a single or random song that I like I'll just purchase it as an MP3 through Amazon.

One thing that pissed me off about Amazon though is that if you bought songs or an album through them, and for whatever reason that artist or company takes the album off of Amazon, it's also gone from your cloud. I didn't download them to my computer and now I'm pissed that I couldn't download load them again. I bought the songs but now they're gone. It's more reliable for me to own a physical copy than a digital one that Amazon can take away whenever they want.

I also like buying a CD because buying it, opening up the booklet and looking at the art and concept for the album is more satisfying.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I can't recall the last cd I bought new (probably something around the 2004 time) but I bought used cds up until about 2008. However, being in on the go a lot due to work, I just can't go without my 160 gig ipod. It's nice having all my music right at my fingertips. The other major reason I stopped buying cds was frequent moves (pain in the ass to care and ship those things) and obnoxious prices. Bandcamp has become my new favorite place to buy music.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I almost bought a CD last year.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I don't buy as much music as I used to but if I do I always buy the CD first.

The only exceptions: The digital album is greatly decreased in comparison to the CD or I have some Amazon digital bucks to burn.

The rest of the time is CD only. But I stream music much more nowadays due to Spotify so I don't buy many albums anymore.

Re: The CD Thread
 

My cd purchasing is not what it used to be. However there are a couple of 80s heavy metal websites or blogs that I visit from time to time that keep me interested in the music world. Occasionally something will get put on the main page artist/band that I have not heard of am I'm like who in the hell are these guys I need to track the cd down.The hunt is on!! (I'm not sure but I don't think I need a special permit for this)

Re: The CD Thread
 

For what it's worth:
- If you buy the CD and rip it yourself, then sell/destroy/give away the CD, yeah... it's legally questionable.
- If you're buying the CD from Amazon, and they include the autorip option, there's nothing illegal about selling/destroying/giving away the CD.

Think of it like a bundle of two products that are not actually tied together by any legal means. It's like buying the latest movie on Blu-ray. You'll get a Blu-ray, a DVD, and a Digital Copy. Technically, it's just a bundle of three separate products, and you're within your rights to sell off the DVD and Digital Copy if you don't want them. But if you JUST get a Blu-ray, and you go and make your own DVD or Digital Copy, you can't sell those. You also shouldn't "legally" sell the original Blu-ray if you're just going to keep your personally ripped copies.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Yep, the autorip system seems like fair game to me. It's a gift to myself when I buy someone else a CD! :lol:

Re: The CD Thread
 

I guess you guys concerned about what happens to the physical CD after you rip it don't use the library. Biggest issue with the library is the limited availability. They never get many titles, and even on the ones they do, it can be quite a wait to check out the more better/popular titles.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Yeah, that feature has been really nice. Even CDs I bought years ago to give away as gifts back then now show up in my own Amazon MP3 Music collection, so a win-win.

And the fact that legal ownership rights issues for music online are still not fully settled due to its relative newness, so something bought that way could some day have its rights taken away despite someone having paid for it. But that legal issue was long ago settled for physical media which means buying music on CD, Vinyl, DVD, Blu-ray, etc. has a built-in legal guarantee of ownership rights for the buyer.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Amazon't auto rip applies to vinyl purchases, too, in case you guys didn't know.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I also have a car that is too old to have an AUX jack, but too new to have a cassette player to use as an adapter. I've also shelled out too much money on those FM radio transmitters - they never work!

I used to have some CDs in a binder but when it was closed the label side of the CD would rub on the label side of the CD on the opposite side of the page, scratching it and permanently damaging it. Now I just burn a copy (usually with the international bonus tracks), or I bring the CD in the car with me in its jewel case.

Target's downsizing of their CDs really shocked me to be totally honest, I think mostly because it seems like many people mostly buy their CDs from there, especially with some artists making "Target exclusive" versions of their albums.

I was also shocked at Target's revamp because in what I want to say was 2011, they re-designed their CD selection to carry a lot less. Then about a year or so ago they revamped again and I hated it at first but after a while I didn't mind it. Now they've done it again and it's like it almost doesn't exist.

It's funny, when I went last week and saw it I overheard a woman asking an employee where all their CDs were and he explained that that was all they'd be carrying. She didn't seem too happy about it.

I remember Walmart downsized their CD selection a few years ago and I got used to it because they still have a decent selection.

Looks like I'll be doing most of my CD shopping at Best Buy for new releases now (unless of course there's a Target exclusive), even though I really am not a huge fan of the place. I'm a Reward Zone member so I may as well take advantage of that.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Sooner or later, Target will get out of the business of selling music. They probably would have already pulled it if they didn't think it would cause a small backlash.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I think my last CD was the Django Unchained soundtrack. I bought it on Amazon because it was $10 and the digital download was $12, despite the fact that buying the CD got me the download.

Re: The CD Thread
 

I think it's more likely that they will just start carry exclusives or just new releases/top sellers in a temporary display during the holiday shopping season.

Re: The CD Thread
 

Yeah I think eventually the media sections of the big box retailers are going to be phased out completely or if anything like mentioned above be reduced drastically and maybe only get the newest releases in small quantities or have things out at certain times of the year like holidays. I hate to say it as someone who purchases physical copies of anything but it seems to be the current trend to go digital and people just aren't buying as much in physical format. People like us are very few anymore. I'm just hoping some of the online retailers don't phase out media products too and we're left with no choice but digital to buy.