View Poll Results: Who is more influential in music history?
Madonna
10
50.00%
Michael Jackson
10
50.00%
Voters: 20. You may not vote on this poll
Madonna or Michael Jackson?
06-06-05 | 11:51 AM
#1
Thread Starter
Banned
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 15,957
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC
Madonna or Michael Jackson?
Who was the more important force in music history? Just curious. Always have this debate with a best friend and want to know how others feel and why.
06-06-05 | 02:40 PM
#2
DVD Talk Legend
I didn't vote because I honestly think it is a toss-up. Both have had a ton of hits but has either really influenced the talent of today as like...say, The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, etc. influenced their following generation? Did either start a new kind of music or take the current music to a new/different level? No.
Sure people say that Madonna brought sex to music but that was started quite a bit before she came along due to disco music. She just made it cool for 12 year old girls to wear lace and try to wear their bras as outerwear...but that is more an influence on fashion/pop culture than music. I would say the Jackson 5 had the most musical influence since they set the tone for all boy-groups to follow but that is not really Michael Jackson doing that.
Michael Jackson has had his share of influence on pop-culture and fashion as well, but true musical influence?
Define "important force."
Tough question.
Sure people say that Madonna brought sex to music but that was started quite a bit before she came along due to disco music. She just made it cool for 12 year old girls to wear lace and try to wear their bras as outerwear...but that is more an influence on fashion/pop culture than music. I would say the Jackson 5 had the most musical influence since they set the tone for all boy-groups to follow but that is not really Michael Jackson doing that.
Michael Jackson has had his share of influence on pop-culture and fashion as well, but true musical influence?
Define "important force."
Tough question.
Last edited by Spiderbite; 06-06-05 at 02:43 PM.
06-06-05 | 02:48 PM
#3
DVD Talk Godfather
I voted Madonna simply because she is the queen of reinventing herself and staying (somewhat) relevant. Michael Jackson, by all accounts, has not done anything of any significant commercial or critical magnitude since Dangerous. Compare that to, say, Madonna's output in the past ten years. I personally think her best single ever is the William Orbit-produced "Beautiful Stranger" and that has come recently.
If you want to talk about influences outside of music, then Jackson wins, as he's perhaps the best example for A Fall From Grace since Hughes.
If you want to talk about influences outside of music, then Jackson wins, as he's perhaps the best example for A Fall From Grace since Hughes.
06-06-05 | 10:33 PM
#6
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by foofighters7
Prince
the correct answer lies above ^^^
06-07-05 | 08:13 AM
#7
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Michael Jackson is a force to reckon with, but I vote Madonna. I love her transformations, I love her growth, she's constantly pushing the envelop, pushing her self. Even when she makes a so-so album, it's not boring.
If you throw Prince in the mix that would be a hard one.
If you throw Prince in the mix that would be a hard one.
06-07-05 | 11:51 AM
#8
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 558
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's close... but I'd have to lean towards MJ. Just look at all the young stars and up-and-comers today to see his "influence" all over them. Usher, Justin Timberlake, etc. You can probably look at just about any male R&B/pop singer and feel MJ's influence.
Madonna is up there too, no doubt. Tough call.
Madonna is up there too, no doubt. Tough call.
