I had a free subscription to Blender a year ago and the thing I liked most about it was a section in each issue that picked a classic rock song and gave you the history, possible meanings, and a line by line review. I'd love to find a website that does something similar for individual songs or whole albums. Anyone have any links to share? I'm especially interested in interpretations/reviews of Radiohead, Sigur Ros, Tom Waits, The Smashing Pumpkins, and Bjork, but I'm pretty much open to anything.

Stylus Magazine does a weekly feature called "Seconds: Perfect Moments in Pop." As far as I know, they don't analyze so much as react. Here is the most recent entry, on Sigur Ros' "Staralfur," actually.

Excellent! Staralfur is my favourite Sigur Ros song. Duly appreciated.