What is your favorite afi ablum and why?

i made a thread on afi before. i ordered the afi vinyl boxset today from nitrorecords.com they repressed it yay.

my fav afi album is answer taht and stay fashionable

I liked the first three, but Black Sails was about pirates and after that they just started sounding too ghey... and then I saw them live a second time and he started looking like Trent Reznor from 1991 and I knew it was all over.