Artists where almost every song sounds different
#27
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
I have to say The Beta Band does a good job of making just about every song they have sound different from each other. On The Three E.P.'s album, there are not two songs that even seem to be in the same damn genre.
#28
Member
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 190
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just thinking about my own collection, with all its limitations...
Beatles -- during their career they took stabs at just about every pop convention I can think of (often with great success, sometimes not).
Bob Dylan -- Folk, Rock, Gospel (though I don't like his), Blues, Rockabilly, Country... he's done a lot. You have to overcome his voice maybe to hear it, but no solo artist has tried so many ways to sabotage his own career via re-invention.
Beck -- you can always here it's him, but without burying his own personality he has extended himself through so many genres that its easy to dismiss him as more chameleon than sincere artist.
Wilco -- started as alternative country, but over four albums they've reinvented their sound pretty thoroughly.
Steve Earle -- within one album he'll go from country to hard rock to folk to bluegrass to punk to pop and back again.
Nods also to Badly Drawn Boy (though he doesn't have a deep enough catalogue yet and in some ways he feels to me like a reincarnation of the currently-dour Beck), Neil Young & Beta Band. I agree that U2 often sound the same within an album and that they definitely have a sound, but I also remember being thrown for a loop when Achtung Baby came out and they began deconstructing themselves.
EDIT: And how could I have forgotten Elvis Costello? He's tried everything short of rap and metal.
Beatles -- during their career they took stabs at just about every pop convention I can think of (often with great success, sometimes not).
Bob Dylan -- Folk, Rock, Gospel (though I don't like his), Blues, Rockabilly, Country... he's done a lot. You have to overcome his voice maybe to hear it, but no solo artist has tried so many ways to sabotage his own career via re-invention.
Beck -- you can always here it's him, but without burying his own personality he has extended himself through so many genres that its easy to dismiss him as more chameleon than sincere artist.
Wilco -- started as alternative country, but over four albums they've reinvented their sound pretty thoroughly.
Steve Earle -- within one album he'll go from country to hard rock to folk to bluegrass to punk to pop and back again.
Nods also to Badly Drawn Boy (though he doesn't have a deep enough catalogue yet and in some ways he feels to me like a reincarnation of the currently-dour Beck), Neil Young & Beta Band. I agree that U2 often sound the same within an album and that they definitely have a sound, but I also remember being thrown for a loop when Achtung Baby came out and they began deconstructing themselves.
EDIT: And how could I have forgotten Elvis Costello? He's tried everything short of rap and metal.
Last edited by MaudlinHarold; 01-04-03 at 07:06 PM.
#29
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally posted by MaudlinHarold
Just thinking about my own collection, with all its limitations...
Beck -- you can always here it's him, but without burying his own personality he has extended himself through so many genres that its easy to dismiss him as more chameleon than sincere artist.
Nods also to Badly Drawn Boy (though he doesn't have a deep enough catalogue yet and in some ways he feels to me like a reincarnation of the currently-dour Beck), Neil Young & Beta Band. I agree that U2 often sound the same within an album and that they definitely have a sound, but I also remember being thrown for a loop when Achtung Baby came out and they began deconstructing themselves.
Just thinking about my own collection, with all its limitations...
Beck -- you can always here it's him, but without burying his own personality he has extended himself through so many genres that its easy to dismiss him as more chameleon than sincere artist.
Nods also to Badly Drawn Boy (though he doesn't have a deep enough catalogue yet and in some ways he feels to me like a reincarnation of the currently-dour Beck), Neil Young & Beta Band. I agree that U2 often sound the same within an album and that they definitely have a sound, but I also remember being thrown for a loop when Achtung Baby came out and they began deconstructing themselves.

Some excellent points made. Glad to see someone with a varied musical taste on here.

As much as he is one of my most favorite of recent artists, I'd have to disagree with you on Badly Drawn Boy. His songs pretty much all sound the same (hence, Hour of the Bewilderbeast blends in so well). Sure, there's the occasional 'A Better Way' (his B-side from Silent Sigh CDS1) but overall most of his stuff sounds the same (read: all great).
Beck has been recently dour due to a long-time breakup (and we benefit from one of his best albums) but the sound can be seen progressing from One Foot in the Grave >> Mutations >> Sea Change, much as the same way his "party albums" all have similar sound: Mellow Gold >> Odelay! >> Midnite Vultures. That said, although there's two similar veins, Beck's stuff is so varied that the songs sound very different.
#31
New Member
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 19
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: CA
Billy Joel deserves a mention. Compare Piano Man to We Didn't Start the Fire to Big Shot to My Life to Uptown Girl to New York State of Mind to To Make You Feel My Love to Miss Saigon to Still Rock and Roll to Me....
#32
DVD Talk God
The Deftones
#36
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 3,797
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hong Kong
I'd also say The Smashing Pumpkins. Heck, most of their singles don't even sound alike! (Cherub Rock, Today, Disarm, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, 1979, Tonight Tonight, 33, Ava Adore).
#39
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 31,740
Received 2,832 Likes
on
1,876 Posts
From: Greenville, South Cackalack
Though I wouldn't say almost every song sounds different, They Might Be Giants hop genres more than any band I can think of offhand. I'll probably be lynched for saying this, but Cherry Poppin' Daddies aren't too far behind -- their albums are a lot more eclectic than their swing reputation would suggest.
#42
Member
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Bay Village, Ohio
As I seem to be one of the resident old guys, I'll chime in on a few older bands.
I second The Clash
Bauhaus
The Mekons
Brian Eno
King Crimson
And perhaps to a lesser extent:
Wire
Killing Joke
Ministry
Edit: I can't believe I didn't think of Elvis Costello either. Also, now that I think about it, Joe Jackson.
I second The Clash
Bauhaus
The Mekons
Brian Eno
King Crimson
And perhaps to a lesser extent:
Wire
Killing Joke
Ministry
Edit: I can't believe I didn't think of Elvis Costello either. Also, now that I think about it, Joe Jackson.
Last edited by Hondo; 01-08-03 at 01:18 PM.
#43
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I can see Bowie; he changes personas and styles rather often.
My input would have to be the Butthole Surfers, at least pre-Independent Worm Saloon, when they apparently realized what 'tune' means. Their last one is actually amazingly musical.
TMBG, yes.....maybe the Dead Milkmen also....and Ween..I don't like them much, but at least the album I heard, was very different.
Einstuerzende Neubauten...Strategies against Architecture II has such wide range of, well, sound...although my personal 'favorite' is Haus der Luege, which is slightly more musical...
My input would have to be the Butthole Surfers, at least pre-Independent Worm Saloon, when they apparently realized what 'tune' means. Their last one is actually amazingly musical.
TMBG, yes.....maybe the Dead Milkmen also....and Ween..I don't like them much, but at least the album I heard, was very different.
Einstuerzende Neubauten...Strategies against Architecture II has such wide range of, well, sound...although my personal 'favorite' is Haus der Luege, which is slightly more musical...
#44
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 65,314
Received 2,705 Likes
on
1,603 Posts
From: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
CAMEO




