Music Talk Discuss music in all its forms: CD, MP3, DVD-A, SACD and of course live

Do you pay attention to reviews?

Old 12-26-02, 05:09 PM
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Bay Village, Ohio
Posts: 61
Do you pay attention to reviews?

After spending some time at reading reviews of various CDs, many of which I own (easy day at work), I thought it might be fun to pose the question on this board: Do you pay any attention to CD reviews? I think the question is most relevant in regard to music CDs even though there are reviews for everything, because music tends to be very personal and very subjective.

Although I have, on occasion, used their customer reviews to try and judge if a box set or other big ticket item purchase is in order, by and large I find them useless. For every "greatest CD in the history of the universe" review there is a "total derivative garbage" counterpart. Ultimately, I end up more confused than when I started and still end up making what amounts to a blind buy.

Maybe my tastes are just too specialized or too odd. Does anyone out there in DVDtalk land have good luck with customer reviews? Let the opinions begin!
Hondo is offline  
Old 12-26-02, 06:28 PM
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 671
I agree, most of the reviews end up either in the "greatest" or "garbage" camps, which make a nuanced discussion of a CD harder. I use the reviews as another data point in selecting CDs but they're clearly not the thing I base any selections on. I do find that there usually are at least one or two reviews that are nuanced enough for my needs (e.g., "this is a good album; the artist's fans will love it, but newbies should start with a different album"). Almost as important as their review of the album is any indication of the reviewer's other interests. If they name-check other, more recognizable artists or albums, either positively or negatively, that's usually helpful to me.
SAShepherd is offline  
Old 12-26-02, 10:26 PM
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Feel Good Inc
Posts: 1,390
what ive figured out is... if they are willing to take the time to write a amazon review... either they really hate the item.. or they really love it.. theres no in between usually...
SpacemanSpiff is offline  
Old 12-27-02, 07:33 AM
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Atlanta
Posts: 7,935
I'm not sure how swayed I am by the reviews, but I find it interesting reading.
atlantamoi is offline  
Old 12-27-02, 09:37 AM
DVD Talk Godfather
The Bus's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: New York
Posts: 54,866
I trust AMG [] more than anything, especially S. T. Erlewine who seems to review all the bands I like.
The Bus is offline  
Old 12-27-02, 10:02 AM
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Bay Village, Ohio
Posts: 61
Originally posted by The Bus
I trust AMG [] more than anything, especially S. T. Erlewine who seems to review all the bands I like.
That seems to be the ticket. You need to find someone that has similar tastes. Even then, it's still not 100% agreement, but the signal to noise ratio is much better.

I'll take a look at allmusic. Thanks for the link.
Hondo is offline  
Old 12-27-02, 03:45 PM
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 190 and other reviews... *is* a good resource. I've been using it for years. It's still my first stop to check out new stuff, but there are more and more reviewers that read kind'a like amazon.commers. btw... the Erlewine's founded the amg in its original book incarnation. They're on volume ... 3, I think, in print form but the website usually features reviews within a week or two of a release if not a few weeks before release.

Sometimes I check out They also have movie and DVD sections. They list blurbs from many print reviews and also leave room for fans to write their own remarks. An overall good resource and probably my second stop after AMG.

As to, I *do* check their site quite often for TOTALLY blind items since I've read plenty of daft professional reviews. But before checking out what's being said there I re-sort the responses by "helpfulness" votes. It helps some.

Another good source'd be Robert Christgau at He's probably one of the best, most eclectic music-lovin' reviewers out there. His books are also well worth investigating.

Best o'luck.

Oh, and in the spirit of
new discs by:
Badly Drawn Boy *****
George Harrison *****
Bob Dylan *****
Amelie OST *****

Everything else gets ZERO stars, naturally

Last edited by MaudlinHarold; 12-27-02 at 04:03 PM.
MaudlinHarold is offline  
Old 12-27-02, 04:16 PM
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Atlanta
Posts: 7,935
Everything else gets zero stars? I think is simply an amazing site. But I often disagree with their picks.
atlantamoi is offline  
Old 12-27-02, 07:57 PM
Cool New Member
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Hong Kong
Posts: 36
But sometimes these reviews contain some very useful information, e.g., I read from there first to know the recent Ozzy Osbourne re-masters contain re-recorded drums/bass.
metal is offline  
Old 12-28-02, 03:37 PM
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 190
Atlanta, of course everything else gets ZERO stars. If I haven't heard it then it must suck, don'cha know. Taste is black and white, no shades of grey.

Jeez... you're too complicated

As to the reviews having some useful info (I assume metal was referring to, of course... there's always a few ounces ofwheat buried in the tonage of chaff. (Okay, I'm exaggerating)... but amazon is at best one tool, and one I never use to make my FINAL decision.

Oh, and a good place to dig out some obscure info is at Although their print edition is more thorough; also they tend to focus more on older stuff or "rock critic-friendly" music.
MaudlinHarold is offline  
Old 12-30-02, 10:09 AM
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: 29 Neibolt Street, Derry, Maine.
Posts: 51
Honestly? No. I trust my own impressions and observations. Usually, before purchasing an album, I'll download a few songs to get a feel for it, and then look over a review or two. Since my tastes are somewhat esoteric, I generally ignore most reviews; not to say that I don't respect their opinions, though, as I do, I just rarely agree with them.

Last edited by Lord Crumb; 01-04-03 at 01:43 AM.
Lord Crumb is offline  
Old 12-30-02, 01:08 PM
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Sugar Land, TX
Posts: 14,352
I usually like the ones that give a track by track review of each song from the people who obviously know something about the previous work of the band.
cdollaz is offline  
Old 01-01-03, 04:54 AM
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Ginwen's Avatar
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Kent, WA
Posts: 7,242
I pay some little bit of attention to the stars, but not so much the written reviews, unless they give me some basis of comparison (like telling some other related likes/dislikes, so I can compare my own opinions).

Mostly, the reviews are very lacking in actual information.
Ginwen is offline  
Old 01-01-03, 03:02 PM
Geofferson's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: The Village Green
Posts: 39,189
Nope - never bother paying attention to them.
Geofferson is offline  
Old 01-02-03, 01:33 PM
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: The L.A.
Posts: 18,122
I like allmusic as well. Better than Amazon or any customer reviews in my opinion.
DodgingCars is offline  

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

Thread Tools
Search this Thread

Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service

Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.