Anyone have TOTAL GUITAR magazine's Top 100 guitarists of all-time?
#26
DVD Talk Legend
I just remembered... where the hell is Michael Schenker? Have people really forgotten UFO/Scorpions/MSG?
Considering he's the hero of probably half the metal guitarists on this list I can't imagine him being left off. He'd easily make my top 10. Now i'm pissed about the bad taste again
Considering he's the hero of probably half the metal guitarists on this list I can't imagine him being left off. He'd easily make my top 10. Now i'm pissed about the bad taste again
#29
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Arch City
Posts: 8,210
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One thing folks here should know: Speed does not equate with greatness. There is so much more to playing the guitar than being fast. So many of the guys in the top 20 of this list are guys that came up in the 80's when guitar playing suddenly became like the old west: the faster you were, the better you were. Good thing that theory only lasted a few years...
The greatest guitarist I've ever heard (without question) is Roy Buchanan. Where's he? In a Rolling Stone article back in the early 80's they asked Eddie Van Halen what it was like to be the greatest guitarist in the world and he said, "I don't know - you'd have to ask Roy Buchanan."
Another guy that I think musicians and critics alike would put in the top 5 let alone the top 100, is Vernon Reid... where's he?
This list is truly silly.
The greatest guitarist I've ever heard (without question) is Roy Buchanan. Where's he? In a Rolling Stone article back in the early 80's they asked Eddie Van Halen what it was like to be the greatest guitarist in the world and he said, "I don't know - you'd have to ask Roy Buchanan."
Another guy that I think musicians and critics alike would put in the top 5 let alone the top 100, is Vernon Reid... where's he?
This list is truly silly.
Last edited by BoatDrinks; 08-08-02 at 05:58 PM.
#31
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Sure almost all will disagree with me here, but any list of the best guitar players that doesn't include Jerry Garcia (and I'm not even a big Deadhead) or Trey Anastasio is a complete joke in my opinion. Two of the most technically skilled and passionate guitar players I've ever heard, and they're nowhere to be found...
#32
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Gdrlv
Sure almost all will disagree with me here, but any list of the best guitar players that doesn't include Jerry Garcia (and I'm not even a big Deadhead) or Trey Anastasio is a complete joke in my opinion. Two of the most technically skilled and passionate guitar players I've ever heard, and they're nowhere to be found...
Sure almost all will disagree with me here, but any list of the best guitar players that doesn't include Jerry Garcia (and I'm not even a big Deadhead) or Trey Anastasio is a complete joke in my opinion. Two of the most technically skilled and passionate guitar players I've ever heard, and they're nowhere to be found...
#33
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Germany
Posts: 1,042
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Mordred
Well I'd have to say that Page is a much better guitarist than Hendrix who gets my vote for most overrated (though certainly one of the most innovative).
Well I'd have to say that Page is a much better guitarist than Hendrix who gets my vote for most overrated (though certainly one of the most innovative).
#34
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Underfoot...
Posts: 4,260
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by BoatDrinks
...Another guy that I think musicians and critics alike would put in the top 5 let alone the top 100, is Vernon Reid... where's he?
This list is truly silly.
...Another guy that I think musicians and critics alike would put in the top 5 let alone the top 100, is Vernon Reid... where's he?
This list is truly silly.
#35
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by demonio
I can't believe what I'm reading, do you honestly believe this? I'm a fan of Zep more than anybody but Page is nowhere even close to Hendrix......Myself being a guitar player gets pissed off everytime someone says Hendrix is overrated. When the man invented an entire style all his own that still cannot be simulated today by anyone. If you've ever seen alot of guitarists in your day you'd know exactly how great he was. Beyond the top few guitarists I dissagree on the majority of the list, its sad to see Kurt Cobain and James Hetfield ahead of Zakk Wylde, and Slash so high up when Zakk is better than him.........but not like the list really means alot though, HOWEVER it would mean even less if Jimi didn't top the greatest axemen of all times.
I can't believe what I'm reading, do you honestly believe this? I'm a fan of Zep more than anybody but Page is nowhere even close to Hendrix......Myself being a guitar player gets pissed off everytime someone says Hendrix is overrated. When the man invented an entire style all his own that still cannot be simulated today by anyone. If you've ever seen alot of guitarists in your day you'd know exactly how great he was. Beyond the top few guitarists I dissagree on the majority of the list, its sad to see Kurt Cobain and James Hetfield ahead of Zakk Wylde, and Slash so high up when Zakk is better than him.........but not like the list really means alot though, HOWEVER it would mean even less if Jimi didn't top the greatest axemen of all times.
It's my opinion that Hendrix is considered by many non-musicians as the greatest guitarist ever because they've been told it's true so many times. What I say is pretty much heresy, but I'm not afraid to admit that Hendrix just doesn't do it for me. I have several of his albums and I listen to them regularly, but greatest guitarist? Not even close.
Yes, I've played guitar for about 9 years now (got started late ). Yes I've seen a lot of great guitarists and heard hundreds more. I'm big into blues, hard rock, metal, neo-classical, etc. I agree that Kurt Cobain and Slash shouldn't be near the top of the list at all... rhythm guitarists probably shouldn't qualify either so there's no way Hetfield should be top 20. Yes Zakk Wylde ought to be top 10, the man is incredible.
It's my belief that guitarists like Rhoads, Cobain and (to a lesser extent) Hendrix all benefitted from dying young. They got put upon a pedestal and their worthiness is heightened in people's minds. They didn't have 10 years with no hit singles for people to forget about them. Would Robin Trower have made this list if he'd died when he was 32? Maybe, but he certainly won't today.
Mordred
#36
DVD Talk Special Edition
Dying young is not how Hendrix earned the respect and accolades from countless others, but rather it was his *gasp* guitar playing. And the "Little Wing" comparison is unfair, just because Hendrix never had an 8-minute version. You don't think he could've pulled it off if he wanted to? And look at "Voodoo Child". SRV's version just does not top Hendrix's.
But I don't wanna turn this into a Hendrix vs. SRV debate, 'cause they're both fantastic musicians. I've been playing guitar for around 15 years, so I take these things a bit more seriously then I probably should.
-edit to add-
And what, there wasn't any room on that list for the Pixies' Joey Santiago?
But I don't wanna turn this into a Hendrix vs. SRV debate, 'cause they're both fantastic musicians. I've been playing guitar for around 15 years, so I take these things a bit more seriously then I probably should.
-edit to add-
And what, there wasn't any room on that list for the Pixies' Joey Santiago?
Last edited by Andalusia; 08-09-02 at 12:50 PM.
#37
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by Andalusia
And what, there wasn't any room on that list for the Pixies' Joey Santiago?
And what, there wasn't any room on that list for the Pixies' Joey Santiago?
#38
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Andalusia
Dying young is not how Hendrix earned the respect and accolades from countless others, but rather it was his *gasp* guitar playing.
Dying young is not how Hendrix earned the respect and accolades from countless others, but rather it was his *gasp* guitar playing.
Lets face it, dying young certainly benefits musicians and makes them larger than life. Can you think of many moderately popular musicians who died in their prime who aren't looked on by the general public as near super heroes? Some of them deserve the accolades, and some don't, but they all get a great boost from dying. I remember walking into used CD stores back before Cobain died and seeing rows of Nirvana CDs... often 5-10 of each. After he died, they got bought up quick. Dying is a plus in peoples minds. No one wants to criticise the tragically deceased.
Mordred
#39
DVD Talk Special Edition
This has to be the worst "top 100/10/50/whatever" list I've ever seen!
Where are Brian Setzer, Eddie Cochran, Link Wray and the best guitarist of all time, DICK DALE?
Last edited by Burnt Alive; 08-09-02 at 08:07 PM.
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Germany
Posts: 1,042
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think the bottomline here is this list should have had alot more thought into it overall, I think the top spot is correct, however theres alot of room for improvement........alot of people on the list can't play forsheet
#42
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Formerly known as "cwwallace"/29.92°, -95.09°
Posts: 2,074
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No thanks... That list features a lot of "show-offs" that I consider to be overrated. Loud and fast doesn't necessarily mean good. Many fine guitarists get no credit for being subtle and tasteful. What is the criteria for this list? Chet Akins is on there, so should all country artists be considered? Seriously. Vince Gill, Willie Nelson, Jerry Garcia, and David Grisman should all be on that list. Gary Louris and Ry Cooder as well.
Last edited by CapRockBrewingCo.; 08-10-02 at 12:18 AM.
#45
Member
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Minneapolis
Posts: 130
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by lordzeppelin
Yeah...Kurt Cobain is better than SRV...sure. F this list.
Yeah...Kurt Cobain is better than SRV...sure. F this list.
/ modiman.
#48
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 230
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Bushdog
Two guys from Sum 41 on the list?
Two guys from Sum 41 on the list?
On a sidenote, i agree that Mike Mcready from Pearl Jam should be way higher and where the fukc is Warren Haynes from allman brothers/gov't mule.