DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   Who Really Likes Macy Gray Anyway? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/173260-who-really-likes-macy-gray-anyway.html)

Real Estate Guy 01-10-02 02:41 PM

Who Really Likes Macy Gray Anyway?
 
I keep hearing raves about her, that people love her songs and that she's so gorgeous. AM I MISSING SOMETHING HERE? I think her voice is awful, her hair looks like sh*t, songs are terrible. WHO IN THEIR RIGHT MINDS ARE BUYING HER STUFF? Somebody let me in on this, please.

Aghama 01-10-02 03:22 PM

Well, the critics sure do.

Lateralus 01-10-02 04:24 PM

I feel bad for you Real Estate guy nobody is reading your threads....So I'll be kind and respond....:)

I kinda like her, the only song I know with her is the one by Fat Boy Slim. I love that song!

Applejack 01-10-02 05:06 PM


Originally posted by Lateralus
I feel bad for you Real Estate guy nobody is reading your threads....So I'll be kind and respond....:)

I kinda like her, the only song I know with her is the one by Fat Boy Slim. I love that song!

Maybe nobody is responding, because nobody else here likes her either :p

Anyway, I agree that she has a terrible voice. I don't really hate her that bad though. I reserve that for bands that really suck like Creed.

Goat3001 01-10-02 07:21 PM


Who Really Likes Macy Gray Anyway?
No One :)

demonio 01-10-02 08:01 PM

lol, me and my buddies make fun of her all the time, her voice is so awful.......I'd say the record execs were like "Damn, her voice is the worst I've ever heard......lets give her a try"

lostatmidnight 01-10-02 08:06 PM


Originally posted by Applejack

...I reserve that for bands that really suck like Creed. [/B]
Indeed.

big whoppa 01-10-02 11:33 PM

I like some of the new songs on her second album. They are kind of funky. I didn't care for the song that she had a top ten hit on her debut though.

redhenry 01-11-02 12:45 AM

I'll be the one
 
Ok...it's me. I really think she's great and so off the wall.
Yeah her voice is unusual, but she shits all over Celine Dion, Mariah, Aguilera, Britney and those other scrags.

I think she is a great artist and we need more nutbags like her instead of those whitebread, navel-baring middle class white-girl clones who have to flash their tits or have a breakdown to get noticed.

Rock on, Macy.

Terry

Australia

Ozzy's Bat Head 01-11-02 02:50 AM

I agree 100% with Terry that there needs to be more renegade diversity in the music biz, however, Macy is not it. After the way Macy butchered our National Anthem a few months back, I'm ready to kick her @ss back to the south park karoake lounge she should have never left. The sooner the industry is cleansed of "artists" that don't give a sh*t, the better.

AndyCapps 01-11-02 08:10 AM

She sounds like she smokes two cartons a day. I don't like her, but I like her more than Alicia Keys.

torsat 01-11-02 08:43 AM


Originally posted by Applejack


Maybe nobody is responding, because nobody else here likes her either :p

Anyway, I agree that she has a terrible voice. I don't really hate her that bad though. I reserve that for bands that really suck like Creed.

Maybe I'm not getting something here... I mean, I'm not exactly what you would call a Macy Gray devotee, but I do bear listening to her music. It's not all bad!

Frankly, I do not understand the hostility towards some popular artists on display here, especially towards Creed, referred to as "a band that sucks" in a different thread as well.

I really like Creed!

So would someone please enlighten me on this topic. Or at least bear with me for my apparent lack in taste :-)

Daytripper 01-11-02 08:48 AM

Well that cow Rosie O'Donnell likes her. So she MUST be good! ;)

Precious 01-11-02 09:13 AM

I like her music and she's good live....so there.

Starlover 01-11-02 09:40 AM

Both of Macy Gray's records are good, her voice works within the context of her albums. So--I like her, she's the best of the 'nu-soul' bunch for sure.

ravan 01-11-02 07:52 PM

Well, i dont like her music or looks, but i'm fine with her being around :)

Snake Plissken 01-14-02 09:28 AM

I like her raspy, gravelled-to-s**t voice and big black booty.

Brent L 02-20-07 04:17 PM

I just saw this on the main Yahoo page, and it made me ask the same question that the OP posted with this thread. I was going to post a thread just like this, but found this one using search instead.

So yeah, I now ask this question, over five years later - who really likes Macy Gray anyway?

The only reason I can figure out that anyone likes her music in any way, is because it gives hope to musicians and vocalists around the world. If she can make it, anyone can.

She is, without a doubt, my least favorite (serious) singer that I've ever heard in my entire life. For what it's worth, James Blunt is the male singer that I hate in the same way. *cringe*

digitalfreaknyc 02-20-07 04:55 PM

She and that other group "Nails On A Chalkboard" are my absolute favorite.

redhenry 02-20-07 05:40 PM

I still think she's fantastic.

I don't give a shit what she looks like - I am interested in whether she can entertain me - and she does. I think she is way different and can see why people don't like her but then again I can't stand Timberlake, Aguilera, Spears, boring clone after boring clone yet they are huge but hey, that's life.

ROCK ON, MACY!!!!! I STILL LOVES YA!!!!!!

Terry (Australia)

movieking 02-20-07 05:50 PM

She looks better than she used to. I taped a HD concert of hers last month, but I ended up deleting it after watching it for a couple of minutes.

aphasias 02-20-07 05:59 PM

i liked her first album, but couldnt stand the second and havnt bothered with anything since.

tommy28 02-20-07 06:40 PM

I like her and have 36 of her songs on my ipod;)

dhmac 02-20-07 07:35 PM


Originally Posted by digitalfreaknyc
She and that other group "Nails On A Chalkboard" are my absolute favorite.

No, I prefer listening to Car Alarm or The Fran Drescher Experience. Macy Gray just doesn't have the same "bite" as these bands.

DJLinus 02-20-07 07:41 PM

She was awesome in Spider-Man. :)


Originally Posted by BrentLumkin
She is, without a doubt, my least favorite (serious) singer that I've ever heard in my entire life. For what it's worth, James Blunt is the male singer that I hate in the same way. *cringe*

I've got a new one: after listening to clips of her latest album (and guest appearences on Flogging Molly and Elvis Costello CDs that I own), I can safely say that Lucinda Williams is by far my least favorite singer. She sounds like she's drunk! Hard to imagine someone would replace Stevie Nicks on the top spot of my list, but sure enough...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:47 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.