DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   Shakira sucks! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/166114-shakira-sucks.html)

Gallant Pig 12-15-01 03:13 AM

This Thread Sucks
 

Originally posted by huzefa


Just to clarify, I've only heard her english songs. Most people in here seem to think that her Colombian(?) stuff is better, and I'll go along with that. But what's been done to her music once she got to the states is not my cup of tea.

Unfortunately, however, your thread is titled "Shakira Sucks" and you damn her on her English album. It would have made more sense to have your title as "Shakira's US Album Sucks", right?

AtlDVD 12-15-01 08:49 AM

You guys havent figured out how the mainstream music industry works-

You find some lamo singer/band that looks good, spend $250k to $1 Million promoting them - and lo and behold they become a star.

The record label sells a lot - the band makes little since the high promo costs - and then the record label doesnt promote their next release and instead finds the next big thing.

Let's lists bands that that has worked for:

Sum 41
Alien Ant Farm
System of a Down
Jessica Simpson
etc. etc.

Yancey 12-17-01 10:18 AM


Originally posted by AtlDVD
You guys havent figured out how the mainstream music industry works-

You find some lamo singer/band that looks good, spend $250k to $1 Million promoting them - and lo and behold they become a star.

The record label sells a lot - the band makes little since the high promo costs - and then the record label doesnt promote their next release and instead finds the next big thing.

Let's lists bands that that has worked for:

Sum 41
Alien Ant Farm
System of a Down
Jessica Simpson
etc. etc.

Apparently I don't know how it works considering System of a Down has now had two albums go platinum.

And who exactly in Alien Ant Farm looks good?!?!?!?

AndyCapps 12-17-01 04:05 PM

I'm actually intrigued by her single. I think she's got a shot at sticking around. I think the lyrics don't make a lot of sense because they were translated into English. I guess Gloria Estefan did the translation.

Of course, I also thought these guys would stick around:

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/07...1.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

So what do I know?

Jason 12-18-01 03:00 PM


Originally posted by Yancey


Apparently I don't know how it works considering System of a Down has now had two albums go platinum.

And who exactly in Alien Ant Farm looks good?!?!?!?

I think by 'looks good' he meant 'looks stylish in a way we would like to promote'.

Wag The Frog 12-19-01 04:15 PM

I don't know much about her music but she can sure shake her ass with the best of 'em.

AndyCapps 12-20-01 02:15 PM

I saw something about her on TV last night. I actually think she looks better with the blonde hair . My wife agreed. I only listen to the radio during the 15 minute car ride to work, the 10 minute car ride for lunch, and another 15 minute car ride to home. I hear the song 2-3 times a day.

Alyoshka 12-20-01 02:51 PM

Apparently I don't listen to the radio with enough frequency. I was hoping this thread would help me figure out who she is, but I still am clueless. From how it sounds I won't be rushing out to find one of her English language songs.

POWERBOMB 12-20-01 11:14 PM

The song groes on you if you hear it enough times. It's kinda catchy, especially with her limited english speaking skills.

huzefa 12-21-01 06:43 PM

Re: This Thread Sucks
 

Originally posted by Gallant Pig


Unfortunately, however, your thread is titled "Shakira Sucks" and you damn her on her English album. It would have made more sense to have your title as "Shakira's US Album Sucks", right?

I didn't know she had other songs in another language when I started the thread. So i think my saying Shakira sucks! was fine at the time. Now if you want me to change it, I'll think about it.

Gallant Pig 12-21-01 09:35 PM

Re: Re: This Thread Sucks
 

Originally posted by huzefa


I didn't know she had other songs in another language when I started the thread. So i think my saying Shakira sucks! was fine at the time. Now if you want me to change it, I'll think about it.

Why not delete it? It stinks of trolling flamebait anyway.

What kind of music do you like? Maybe I'll make a thread about how much your favorite bands suck. You see, music is subjective, even moreso than movies. By posting that a certain singer or band sucks is just asking for trouble, and I highly doubt that's why Geoff started this forum in the first place.

uberjoe 12-21-01 09:37 PM

Re: Re: Re: This Thread Sucks
 

Originally posted by Gallant Pig


Why not delete it? It stinks of trolling flamebait anyway.

What kind of music do you like? Maybe I'll make a thread about how much your favorite bands suck. You see, music is subjective, even moreso than movies. By posting that a certain singer or band sucks is just asking for trouble, and I highly doubt that's why Geoff started this forum in the first place.

Or you could practice self control and ignore the thread.

Gallant Pig 12-21-01 09:51 PM

Re: Re: Re: Re: This Thread Sucks
 

Originally posted by uberjoe


Or you could practice self control and ignore the thread.

To be honest, I didn't really care until it was insinuated Shakira was famous because she was "latin" (which is a serious misnomer anyway). I found that pretty offensive. I apologize if I sounded harsh.

Heat 01-12-02 01:45 AM

You know, I still haven't heard any of Shakira's English language songs.

I did just just see a new video of her singing a song called, I believe, "Me Creo" (a Spanish language song). She has dyed brunette hair now. She is a very attractive looking lady, when she has black or brunette hair. As a blonde, with those black eyes of hers (they aren't even brown, they are black), she looks like a skanky whore (the opinion of my wife and I, the least she could have done was to wear contacts to lighten her eyes (Shakira, not my wife)).

Anyway, I still haven't heard an English language song of hers, but I can say that she is a very good Spanish language singer. If you are intereste in a Spanish album of hers, pick up "Donde Estan Los Ladrones?".

Daytripper 01-14-02 08:13 AM

Re: Re: Re: Re: This Thread Sucks
 

Originally posted by uberjoe


Or you could practice self control and ignore the thread.

That's hardly the point uberjoe. It was the way this person started the thread. Say something that juvenile, you can expect fall out.

Snake Plissken 01-14-02 09:40 AM

http://www.absolutely.net/shakira/shak8.jpg

http://www.absolutely.net/shakira/shak76.jpg

http://www.absolutely.net/shakira/shak78.jpg

gerrythedon 10-29-02 02:02 AM

ANYBODY who is writing "IGNORANT" comments towards SHAKIRA without KNOWING anything about her CAREER in MUSIC can F_CK OFF!!!!

palebluedot 10-29-02 06:21 AM


Originally posted by gerrythedon
ANYBODY who is writing "IGNORANT" comments towards SHAKIRA without KNOWING anything about her CAREER in MUSIC can F_CK OFF!!!!

Eh...nevermind...too easy.

Take it easy there buddy, thy are just opinions. Yes,the fact that she does suck is an opinion, even if it isn't substantiated. Basically she looks and sounds just like every other one of those Britney's out there. Cardboard music, same basic lyrics that have been sung over and over (how many boy songs can there be?), and a general malaise of corporate sponsered "music". Her "talent" seems to be looking good and shaking her a$$ in leather pants. That's great but lets not confuse that with great music, or great talent. She is here for purely entertainment purposes, which isn't necessarily a bad thing but just not my thing.

atlantamoi 10-29-02 06:37 AM


Basically she looks and sounds just like every other one of those Britney's out there.
I'm not a Shakira fan or buyer of her music, but you are wrong on this account. They don't do the same kind of music and Shakira's past recordings are much more interesting.

gerrythedon 10-29-02 03:23 PM


Originally posted by palebluedot
Eh...nevermind...too easy.

Take it easy there buddy, thy are just opinions. Yes,the fact that she does suck is an opinion, even if it isn't substantiated. Basically she looks and sounds just like every other one of those Britney's out there. Cardboard music, same basic lyrics that have been sung over and over (how many boy songs can there be?), and a general malaise of corporate sponsered "music". Her "talent" seems to be looking good and shaking her a$$ in leather pants. That's great but lets not confuse that with great music, or great talent. She is here for purely entertainment purposes, which isn't necessarily a bad thing but just not my thing.


Opinions should be able to be backed up Facts...not IGNORANT B.S...alrighty...Opinions are COOL w/ me but, Think about what is said...tha's all

MJKTool 10-29-02 04:17 PM


Originally posted by gerrythedon
Opinions should be able to be backed up Facts...not IGNORANT B.S...alrighty...Opinions are COOL w/ me but, Think about what is said...tha's all
I think she SUCKS because she cant sing live worth SHYIT!
There you go a FACT. She SUCKS live

benedict 10-29-02 04:31 PM

I think this thread should have been left to die back in January. Look what happened in the meantime to the guy who posted last way back then.

<b>gerrythedon</b>, you are skirting close to the edge with your posting style (not particularly talking about this thread) and crossing it with your censor-defeating posts here and elsewhere. No more of that, thank you.


Benedict
Moderator, Music Talk


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:09 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.