View Poll Results: You can have only one for the rest of your life.
Star Wars
15
36.59%
Star Trek
13
31.71%
DC
5
12.20%
Marvel
8
19.51%
Voters: 41. You may not vote on this poll
Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
So this is in Movie Talk, but it applies to everything: movies, TV shows, books, comics.
Of the four intellectual properties listed, if you could only engage with one for the rest of your life, which would you choose?
So whatever you don't pick, means you can never watch or read any past or future artistic work from those three IPs.
Of the four intellectual properties listed, if you could only engage with one for the rest of your life, which would you choose?
So whatever you don't pick, means you can never watch or read any past or future artistic work from those three IPs.
#2
Premium Member
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Grazing in a field somewhere...
Posts: 23,644
Received 700 Likes
on
466 Posts
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
I've stuck with Star Trek for somewhere around 43 seasons of TV and 13 movies.
I still look forward to more, so...
I still look forward to more, so...
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (09-17-22)
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
I’ve liked Star Trek the longest so I’d probably say that. Star Wars would be a close second.
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (09-17-22)
#4
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
I’ve never really cared for Star Trek, the DC movies have all been a major disappointment so I could do without them, I’m super burned out on Marvel movies and could use a long break anyway, so I guess it’s Star Wars.
…But since we’re playing this hypothetical game, I get access to the original original trilogy!
…But since we’re playing this hypothetical game, I get access to the original original trilogy!
#5
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
Star Trek Wars
I don't care for super hero films so I don't care about Marvel or DC. I only like the theatrical cuts of the original Star Wars trilogy and Star Trek The TOS and it's six movies for those two franchises. I guess I would choose Star Wars.
I don't care for super hero films so I don't care about Marvel or DC. I only like the theatrical cuts of the original Star Wars trilogy and Star Trek The TOS and it's six movies for those two franchises. I guess I would choose Star Wars.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
Probably Marvel... because it has given me the most entertaining content in terms of quantity.
But Star Wars has the holy trilogy which is in my blood since I was 3.
hmm
But Star Wars has the holy trilogy which is in my blood since I was 3.
hmm
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
DC fan since I was 5 years old, and I'll stay that way for life. For the comics alone, that would be enough; I still have my first comics from almost 50 years ago.
But then I discovered Batman (1966) reruns. And Superfriends. And the Wonder Woman TV show.
And the 1978 SUPERMAN movie, which is still my favorite comic book movie of all time and nothing comes close.
80s DC comics were my wheelhouse. Everything starting with The New Teen Titans in 1980 through the rise of Vertigo with Black Orchid, Hellblazer, Sandman, and Animal Man by 1989. I still read DC up until around 2012, when I dipped out of all monthly comics, and while there were ups and downs I still loved the company, the characters, their universes, and its history.
Then we had the 1989 Batman movie, Batman: The Animated Series, Superman: The Animated Series, Justice League Unlimited, Smallville, Arrow, Flash, Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, Young Justice...
And yeah. I enjoy the DCEU too. Some movies more than others. But I'd argue the Peacemaker show is better than anything Disney+ has offered so far (although the first season of Daredevil trumps all).
so yeah, this would be my ranking:
1) DC
2) Marvel
3) Star Trek
4) Star Wars
But then I discovered Batman (1966) reruns. And Superfriends. And the Wonder Woman TV show.
And the 1978 SUPERMAN movie, which is still my favorite comic book movie of all time and nothing comes close.
80s DC comics were my wheelhouse. Everything starting with The New Teen Titans in 1980 through the rise of Vertigo with Black Orchid, Hellblazer, Sandman, and Animal Man by 1989. I still read DC up until around 2012, when I dipped out of all monthly comics, and while there were ups and downs I still loved the company, the characters, their universes, and its history.
Then we had the 1989 Batman movie, Batman: The Animated Series, Superman: The Animated Series, Justice League Unlimited, Smallville, Arrow, Flash, Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, Young Justice...
And yeah. I enjoy the DCEU too. Some movies more than others. But I'd argue the Peacemaker show is better than anything Disney+ has offered so far (although the first season of Daredevil trumps all).
so yeah, this would be my ranking:
1) DC
2) Marvel
3) Star Trek
4) Star Wars
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (09-17-22)
#8
Member
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
Pre disney Star Wars
#10
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,461
Received 920 Likes
on
776 Posts
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
all great franchises and i adore the OT, but Marvel movies, generally most of them, have been watched more times than OT at this point. just such high replayability imo over SW.
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (09-17-22)
#11
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
Easy choice for me - Star Wars
Besides the films, I use to read the books, played the CCG, collected and played with action figures, etc. Definitely the franchise I’ve focused on the most.
Besides the films, I use to read the books, played the CCG, collected and played with action figures, etc. Definitely the franchise I’ve focused on the most.
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (09-18-22)
#13
Moderator
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (09-18-22)
#14
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
If the current Marvel movie universe had the same faithful adaption movies of The Uncanny X-Men comic books stories and action, without a doubt that would be my pick.
So for now Star Trek.
So for now Star Trek.
The following users liked this post:
PhantomStranger (09-18-22)
#17
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
I would probably have to say Marvel even though the MCU specifically is quite low on the priority list. But I'd be pretty sad if I had to give up 60 years of Marvel comics. Throw in Spider-Man 2 and the X-Men movies and I'd have a hard time going with DC or Star Wars even though Batman:TAS and The Empire Strikes Back are two of my very favorite things in this life. Star Trek is fine, but I've never been more than a casual fan at best.
The sad thing is if this question were only about what is "to come", then I'd probably just pass on the whole lot. Again, I'm pretty agnostic on Star Trek, but the rest can go in a hole and die for all I care. Or at least go away for a long time until there's a real reason to come out again.
The sad thing is if this question were only about what is "to come", then I'd probably just pass on the whole lot. Again, I'm pretty agnostic on Star Trek, but the rest can go in a hole and die for all I care. Or at least go away for a long time until there's a real reason to come out again.
#18
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Star Wars, Star Trek, DC, or Marvel? --There can be only one.
Star Trek. It's the only one of these properties where I love and relate so much with that world that I would totally give everything up to live in that world. I love all four but not to the degree of Star Trek.