DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/655901-who-greatest-sci-fi-villain-all-time.html)

Sonic 07-28-22 07:43 PM

Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
Of all the sci-fi films out there who is the greatest villain that if he/she really existed in our reality today, would strike fear in every heart? Btw Godzilla is a contender.

My pick would be Darth Vader. 👍

Kurt D 07-28-22 07:43 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
yo mama

Sonic 07-28-22 07:53 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Kurt D (Post 14139478)
yo mama

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...8238de6938.gif

Toddarino 07-28-22 07:57 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...d09ce242b.jpeg

JeffTheAlpaca 07-28-22 08:07 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
I assume it has to be Darth Vader since they made 3 movies with him and another 3 explaining his back story and then he appears in a big scene in Rogue 1.

He also had his own theme music and it gets played at sporting events too.



Decker 07-28-22 08:29 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
Ming the Merciless!
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...9179d93ecd.png

J/K. It's Darth Vader.

GoldenJCJ 07-28-22 08:54 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
Supreme Leader Snoke, obviously.

story 07-28-22 08:58 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ (Post 14139522)
Supreme Leader Snoke, obviously.

Well, he WOULD'VE BEEN but Rian Johnson blah blah blah I can't just let anything go blah blah!!1!

Michael Corvin 07-28-22 09:00 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by JeffTheAlpaca (Post 14139493)
I assume it has to be Darth Vader since they made 3 movies with him and another 3 explaining his back story and then he appears in a big scene in Rogue 1.

He also had his own theme music and it gets played at sporting events too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u7HF4JG1pOg

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQB2NXfJev0

And a 7 season animated series about him and turning up in Obi-Wan.

Kurt D 07-28-22 09:03 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
The OP beyond the title unfortunately goes into the 'strike fear into people's hearts' qualification. Most people would probably ask Darth Vader for his autograph. I'm going with the Xenopmorph. (Or sonic's mama.)

The Cow 07-28-22 09:12 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Kurt D (Post 14139529)
The OP beyond the title unfortunately goes into the 'strike fear into people's hearts' qualification. Most people would probably ask Darth Vader for his autograph. I'm going with the Xenopmorph. (Or sonic's mama.)

Yeah, if Vader ran for office, he would get a lot of votes.

Maybe Predators. Or yo mama.

stvn1974 07-28-22 09:38 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
If it was only the OT I would agree with Darth Vader. But now you find out he is just a whiney brat who was easily manipulated.

Josh-da-man 07-28-22 10:01 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
Kathleen Kennedy.

Though Chris Chibnall would be a close runner up.

Decker 07-28-22 10:06 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Kurt D (Post 14139529)
The OP beyond the title unfortunately goes into the 'strike fear into people's hearts' qualification. Most people would probably ask Darth Vader for his autograph. I'm going with the Xenopmorph. (Or sonic's mama.)

Sorry, As much as I love Alien (which is more than Star Wars : A New Hope, BTW) that's not the right choice here. I don't even consider the Xenopmorph a villain, let alone the greatest one. A villain has to harbor malicious intent. . This creature is just hungry and pursuing its nature. The villains of Alien are the company and Ash for letting it in.
It's a hell of an antagonist though.

GoldenJCJ 07-28-22 10:16 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
14 posts in and no one has complained that Star Wars isn’t technically “Sci-fi” yet? We’re all slipping.

Kurt D 07-28-22 10:28 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 14139545)
Sorry, As much as I love Alien (which is more than Star Wars : A New Hope, BTW) that's not the right choice here. I don't even consider the Xenopmorph a villain, let alone the greatest one. A villain has to harbor malicious intent. . This creature is just hungry and pursuing its nature. The villains of Alien are the company and Ash for letting it in.
It's a hell of an antagonist though.

But yet
Ash: "Its structural perfection is matched only by its hostility." so ... kinda?

I would call wasps, hornets and yellowjackets villains! :lol:

Bluelitespecial 07-28-22 10:44 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
Would Clarence Bodikker (Kurtwood Smith) from Robocop count? I always think of it as a sci-fi action movie.

milo bloom 07-28-22 10:55 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 14139545)
Sorry, As much as I love Alien (which is more than Star Wars : A New Hope, BTW) that's not the right choice here. I don't even consider the Xenopmorph a villain, let alone the greatest one. A villain has to harbor malicious intent. . This creature is just hungry and pursuing its nature. The villains of Alien are the company and Ash for letting it in.
It's a hell of an antagonist though.

Yeah, Burke is an absolute tool of evil. Isn’t there a story about Paul Reiser’s mom cheering when the xenomorph gets him?

clckworang 07-28-22 10:56 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
When I first read the thread title, I thought yo mama.

But I think I could also go with Frankenstein/Frankenstein's monster.

Edit to add: And I guess that depends on how you define villain. The more I think about it, the more I'm talking myself out of that answer. Neither is really a villain.

clckworang 07-28-22 11:15 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
Would Batty from Blade Runner qualify?

Decker 07-28-22 11:40 PM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Kurt D (Post 14139559)
But yet
Ash: "Its structural perfection is matched only by its hostility." so ... kinda?

I mean sure, if you want to take the word of the film's main villain.

Kurt D 07-29-22 12:01 AM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 14139573)
I mean sure, if you want to take the word of the film's main villain.

:mad:

Toddarino 07-29-22 12:03 AM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 

Originally Posted by clckworang (Post 14139572)
Would Batty from Blade Runner qualify?

I considered that, but I had sympathy for him. I don’t think you can feel that way about a true villain.

Eric F 07-29-22 12:10 AM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
God in the Ten Commandments.

TomOpus 07-29-22 12:20 AM

Re: Who is the greatest sci-fi villain of all time?
 
I'll pick one for being relentless and shape-shifting. And Robert Patrick's focused determination.
https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...e6966af6c7.jpg


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:48 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.