DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   2018 Oscar Nominations (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/642775-2018-oscar-nominations.html)

Coral 01-23-18 08:54 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Hazel Motes (Post 13252640)
Last minute The Disaster Artist fill in's.

That might be for Best Director, but there are only 9 films nominated for BP... so they didn't have to substitute TDA for any other film - they could've just had 8 nominations instead.
I think TDA just got dropped and they left everything else as is.

In any case, I think it's stupid to drop TDA/Franco just because of the allegations. Whether Franco is guilty or not - the work stands on its own merits.

Perkinsun Dzees 01-23-18 08:55 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Predictions:

Best Picture:
Three Billboards

Lead Actor:
Gary Oldman

Lead Actress:
Frances McDormand (Possible upset: Margot Robbie)

Supporting Actor:
Sam Rockwell (Possible upset: Willem Dafoe)

Supporting Actress:
Alison Janney (Possible upset: Laurie Metcalf)

Director:
Guillermo Del Toro (Possible upset: Greta Gerwig)

Animated Feature:
Coco

Cinematography:
Blade Runner 2049, Roger Deakins

Makeup and Hair:
Darkest Hour

Adapted Screenplay:
The Disaster Artist, Scott Neustadter & Michael H. Weber (Possible upset: Logan)

Original Screenplay:
Lady Bird, Greta Gerwig

Film Editing:
Dunkirk, Lee Smith

Original Score:
The Shape of Water, Alexandre Desplat

Original Song:
'This Is Me" from The Greatest Showman, Benj Pasek, Justin Paul

TheHive08 01-23-18 08:57 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
I know there's a lot of Three Billboards dislike on this forum, but damn I hope Sam Rockwell wins an Oscar. Love he's getting all of this recognition.

AaronHernandez 01-23-18 09:03 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Hazel Motes (Post 13252640)
Last minute The Disaster Artist fill in's.

Disaster Artist didn't get nominated by the Directors at DGA or Bafta which voted well before his scandal came out. Anderson probably leapfrogged the 3 Billboards or Blade Runner Director.

wendersfan 01-23-18 09:07 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by TheHive08 (Post 13252675)
I know there's a lot of Three Billboards dislike on this forum, but damn I hope Sam Rockwell wins an Oscar. Love he's getting all of this recognition.

Given that The Florida Project was probably the best (English language) movie of the year, but only got one nomination (for Willem Dafoe), I disagree with you 100%.

kefrank 01-23-18 09:17 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
I'm impressed to see Logan nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay. I'm curious if there have been other Adapted Screenplay nominations for "superhero comic" movies.

Throwing Copper 01-23-18 09:22 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by RichC2 (Post 13252618)
No directing nomination for Three Billboards (I agree with this) makes me wonder how far it'll get.


Absolute bullshit. One of the best films of the year that was nominated for damn near everything else that anyone cares about, and no directing nod. Laughable. :thmbsdwn:

RichC2 01-23-18 09:24 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
To each their own. I liked the screenplay and acting, but didn't really care for a lot of the directing choices -- some aspects just came off as too stage-y and bothered me in an otherwise involving film.

Throwing Copper 01-23-18 09:25 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Coral (Post 13252636)
Not that I put much stock in the Oscars, but it's nice to see PTA getting so many Phantom Thread nominations.

Yes. Loved Phantom Thread getting SIX nominations. Who in the world saw that coming?

I think Vicky Krieps should have been nominated for her acting role, though.

Throwing Copper 01-23-18 09:28 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by wendersfan (Post 13252680)
Given that The Florida Project was probably the best (English language) movie of the year, but only got one nomination (for Willem Dafoe), I disagree with you 100%.

I know it is a little and not well known movie, and nobody saw it. But how does an incredible movie like The Florida Project NOT get nominated for Best Picture when there can be up to 10 movies?

Ridiculous. Everyone that sees it says how good it is.

Coral 01-23-18 09:30 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Just noticed that Roger Deakins got yet another Cinematography nod for Blade Runner.

He's up against Dunkirk, so I guess he'll be 0-14 now. :lol:

Throwing Copper 01-23-18 09:32 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
I've never seen anything that the current IT GIRL, Tiffany Haddish, has done. But could they at least get someone who can read and speak properly to announced the damn awards?

That was painful to sit through. About halfway through, you just expected her to flub every other name, which should have been rehearsed in the first place. Thank God the King of CGI was there to balance it out.

bluetoast 01-23-18 09:33 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Whatever, she had a few good jokes, that was fine.

Orbi-Wan Techno 01-23-18 09:33 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Glad to see that Baby Driver is at least being recognized in the Sound categories.

RichC2 01-23-18 09:34 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Orbi-Wan Techno (Post 13252708)
Glad to see that Baby Driver is at least being recognized in the Sound categories.

Film Editing is one of the major categories, so it has that too.

Dan 01-23-18 09:39 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by TomOpus (Post 13252601)
I think this is the first year (since they expanded the number) that I saw over half of the Best Picture nominees.

Same; there's only two I haven't seen yet, and they're both movies I'm actually interested in seeing, so that's actually a decent list.

But BR2049 should have been on there. I kind of expected that it wouldn't, so I'm not surprised... I'm just disappointed.

story 01-23-18 09:40 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
The real winner is Movie Pass. Wouldn't have seen so many of these nominated films, if not for that. Plus, will see even more with some of them getting a limited pre-release in Oscar season.

Bummed Logan wasn't up for Best Picture. That would've been something.

dex14 01-23-18 09:41 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Throwing Copper (Post 13252704)
I know it is a little and not well known movie, and nobody saw it. But how does an incredible movie like The Florida Project NOT get nominated for Best Picture when there can be up to 10 movies?

Ridiculous. Everyone that sees it says how good it is.

People still have to vote for it.

Why So Blu? 01-23-18 10:01 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Shape of Water is gonna win it all! It's time to complete the Mexican Directors trilogy -- Cuaron and Iņarritu already have Oscars, so it's time for GDT to join the club.

Ash Ketchum 01-23-18 10:07 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
First year that both Pokémon and Power Rangers were eligible for Oscars and...nothing. :sad:

https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4662/...7aefabea1c.jpg

https://farm5.staticflickr.com/4708/...83b4126e45.jpg

inri222 01-23-18 10:10 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Why So Blu? (Post 13252738)
Shape of Water is gonna win it all! It's time to complete the Mexican Directors trilogy -- Cuaron and Iņarritu already have Oscars, so it's time for GDT to join the club.

GDT doesn't deserve it until he films a movie in the south pole and has Ron Perlman eat a raw polar bear liver. :sarcasm:

EinCB 01-23-18 10:13 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Haven't seen it yet, but surprised Detroit didn't get anything.

dex14 01-23-18 10:14 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by EinCB (Post 13252750)
Haven't seen it yet, but surprised Detroit didn't get anything.

Whoever is responsible for releasing that in the summer should be fired. That for sure would've been a contender if positioned correctly.

inri222 01-23-18 10:15 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 13252753)
That for sure would've been a contender if positioned correctly.

Yes it would. I thought it was way better than the super overrated Zero Dark Thirty.

RichC2 01-23-18 10:18 AM

Re: 2018 Oscar Nominations
 
Yep, bad timing crushed that one.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:45 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.