What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
And by that I mean a period move that has strange or unique elements from the then-current year it was made in regards to acting (and maybe casting choices), filmmaking trends, or use of music, that would now be distracting in a period piece.
#2
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
A lot of 80's Period Drama it's hard to go all in causes the Scores are very distinctly Vangelis,Tangerine Dream,Moroderesque and synth heavy in a way that feels unique to that decade. Whereas something like the Titanic,Shawshank or Piano Score in the 90's you can slide into those worlds cause the Score's are timeless and fit the mood of the movie and feel like they could just have easily been composed in 1940 as 1990 or 2017.
#4
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Every 1950s or '60s western or war movie that had teen idols in them, like Frankie Avalon (THE ALAMO), Fabian (NORTH TO ALASKA), Bobby Darin (HELL IS FOR HEROES), etc. Just takes me right out of the movie. James Darren is very good in GUNMAN'S WALK, though. There's a scene in THE LONGEST DAY, where you've got Paul Anka, Fabian and Tommy Sands (Nancy Sinatra's then-husband) as Rangers who've just successfully climbed and taken Pointe du Hoc. It was just such a sop to the young audience in 1962. I remember liking that scene as a kid, though.
Yet I would leave Elvis out of this equation because I thought he was excellent in the two westerns he did, LOVE ME TENDER and FLAMING STAR.
Fabian, Paul Anka, Tommy Sands in THE LONGEST DAY:
Yet I would leave Elvis out of this equation because I thought he was excellent in the two westerns he did, LOVE ME TENDER and FLAMING STAR.
Fabian, Paul Anka, Tommy Sands in THE LONGEST DAY:
![](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/cb/28/8f/cb288f7b115133e6aea6fabba02f51d3.jpg)
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
A lot of 80's Period Drama it's hard to go all in causes the Scores are very distinctly Vangelis,Tangerine Dream,Moroderesque and synth heavy in a way that feels unique to that decade. Whereas something like the Titanic,Shawshank or Piano Score in the 90's you can slide into those worlds cause the Score's are timeless and fit the mood of the movie and feel like they could just have easily been composed in 1940 as 1990 or 2017.
#7
DVD Talk Hero
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Godfather III looked like it was taking place in 1990 instead of 1979.
I remember watching a Vietnam War movie that filmed in the 80s (Hamburger Hill?) and the soldiers had spiky gelled 80s hair.
I remember watching a Vietnam War movie that filmed in the 80s (Hamburger Hill?) and the soldiers had spiky gelled 80s hair.
#8
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Every 1950s or '60s western or war movie that had teen idols in them, like Frankie Avalon (THE ALAMO), Fabian (NORTH TO ALASKA), Bobby Darin (HELL IS FOR HEROES), etc. Just takes me right out of the movie. James Darren is very good in GUNMAN'S WALK, though. There's a scene in THE LONGEST DAY, where you've got Paul Anka, Fabian and Tommy Sands (Nancy Sinatra's then-husband) as Rangers who've just successfully climbed and taken Pointe du Hoc. It was just such a sop to the young audience in 1962. I remember liking that scene as a kid, though.
Yet I would leave Elvis out of this equation because I thought he was excellent in the two westerns he did, LOVE ME TENDER and FLAMING STAR.
Fabian, Paul Anka, Tommy Sands in THE LONGEST DAY:
![](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/cb/28/8f/cb288f7b115133e6aea6fabba02f51d3.jpg)
Yet I would leave Elvis out of this equation because I thought he was excellent in the two westerns he did, LOVE ME TENDER and FLAMING STAR.
Fabian, Paul Anka, Tommy Sands in THE LONGEST DAY:
![](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/cb/28/8f/cb288f7b115133e6aea6fabba02f51d3.jpg)
John Wayne for the old folks, young newcomer the young folks.
TV shows were even worse. The one instance where it worked well was the Beverly Hillbillies. When the Clampetts encounted beatniks, hippies and rock and roll it was a riot.
This may qualify more as a cliché than the thread subject, but the male/female scientist team ups in 1950s sci-fi movies. I get a laugh in every time I watch Revenge of The Creature. After Lori Nelson is taken captive by the creature the newscaster, "Still no sign of the pretty young scientist".
#9
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,602
Received 1,975 Likes
on
1,207 Posts
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Lot's of 90's RomComs have same corny ass scores/music. When i see those films the scores immediately scream 90's to me.
#10
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 53,121
Received 1,093 Likes
on
899 Posts
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Definitely the synth scores, including Blade Runner, which probably sounded futuristic at the time but now sounds dated.
#11
Moderator
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Not everyone is understanding the thread title. OP is looking for PERIOD movies that have become dated.
My pick is “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid”
My pick is “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid”
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Easy Rider.
#13
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#14
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
![](http://d34gx5qo4rcf53.cloudfront.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/27203357/Carrie-1976-Sissy-Spacek-menstruation.png)
#16
Banned
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Conducting miss-aisle drills and listening to their rock n roll
Posts: 20,052
Received 168 Likes
on
126 Posts
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
![Jaw Drop](/images/smilies/jawdrop.gif)
Blade Runner's whole sound mix, including the score, is amazing. There are times you can't tell if what you are hearing is a sound effect in the scene or part of the score. It's so layered.
#17
Banned
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Conducting miss-aisle drills and listening to their rock n roll
Posts: 20,052
Received 168 Likes
on
126 Posts
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Oh people also felt the moments of violence were gratuitous. When it was explained that they're supposed to be, very few cared.
I disagree with all of those people, but they are a vast majority. So it would seem that many things about that film are now dated with audiences. I still love it.
Now go home and...sleep well.
Last edited by Mabuse; 09-27-17 at 09:11 PM.
#18
DVD Talk Hero
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
When I watched The Sting a couple of years ago, it was a disappointment. I thought it was flatly lit, the acting was hammy, that Scott Joplin theme hadn't aged well, and they used the same grinding-gears sound effect for every single car. But the underlying scam is still great.
#19
Banned
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Conducting miss-aisle drills and listening to their rock n roll
Posts: 20,052
Received 168 Likes
on
126 Posts
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Regarding the Longest Day: I've always been aware that it was full of pop stars, but I first watched the film in 1991, and having been born in 1978 I don't recognize who they are. They are forgotten to me. I recognize Wayne and Fonda and Burton and all the big stars, but the pop stars don't bump me because to me they are like extras. And none of them give a bad performance.
#20
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Shortly before tho IMDb message boards shut down I stumbled into the Untouchables forum and was very surprised to see the comments were nearly universally negative. People saying the score was dreadful, even when it was pointed out who the composer was. People saying the Al Capone theme sounded like carnival music and the triumphant portions too triumphant. They said the overall tone was too earnest. People saying the baby carriage was absurd, then others pointed out that it's an homage to Potemkin, but that didn't change any minds. It was really wild to me because I've always seen it as a big, crowd pleasing movie; it was a big hit in '87.
Oh people also felt the moments of violence were gratuitous. When it was explained that they're supposed to be, very few cared.
I disagree with all of those people, but they are a vast majority. So it would seem that many things about that film are now dated with audiences. I still love it.
Now go home and...sleep well.
Oh people also felt the moments of violence were gratuitous. When it was explained that they're supposed to be, very few cared.
I disagree with all of those people, but they are a vast majority. So it would seem that many things about that film are now dated with audiences. I still love it.
Now go home and...sleep well.
For the OP's question; I was looking at Last Temptation Of Christ recently, and it just looks like a bunch of New York actors hamming their way through the desert. Jesus Christ Superstar seems more like a proper period movie than that.
#21
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
I also enjoyed Morricone's score for The Untouchables. I also like the film itself but consider it one of DePalma's least interesting movies. It's all very skillfully done, but just feels like DePalma was trying to be a Hollywood player at this point and went all out to make a boxoffice blockbuster, painting the good guys and bad guys in very broad strokes while reining in the darker, more provocative obsessions that pepper his other films.
For the most part, the movie comes across as rather impersonal and artificial with the most DePalma-ish elements being the baby carriage setpiece and when the guy stalks Connery in his apartment. Mamet's script is also one of his least interesting and, yes, the ending courtroom scene is quite ludicrous.
For the most part, the movie comes across as rather impersonal and artificial with the most DePalma-ish elements being the baby carriage setpiece and when the guy stalks Connery in his apartment. Mamet's script is also one of his least interesting and, yes, the ending courtroom scene is quite ludicrous.
#22
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Shortly before tho IMDb message boards shut down I stumbled into the Untouchables forum and was very surprised to see the comments were nearly universally negative. People saying the score was dreadful, even when it was pointed out who the composer was. People saying the Al Capone theme sounded like carnival music and the triumphant portions too triumphant. They said the overall tone was too earnest. People saying the baby carriage was absurd, then others pointed out that it's an homage to Potemkin, but that didn't change any minds. It was really wild to me because I've always seen it as a big, crowd pleasing movie; it was a big hit in '87.
Oh people also felt the moments of violence were gratuitous. When it was explained that they're supposed to be, very few cared.
I disagree with all of those people, but they are a vast majority. So it would seem that many things about that film are now dated with audiences. I still love it.
Now go home and...sleep well.
Oh people also felt the moments of violence were gratuitous. When it was explained that they're supposed to be, very few cared.
I disagree with all of those people, but they are a vast majority. So it would seem that many things about that film are now dated with audiences. I still love it.
Now go home and...sleep well.
#23
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
Regarding the Longest Day: I've always been aware that it was full of pop stars, but I first watched the film in 1991, and having been born in 1978 I don't recognize who they are. They are forgotten to me. I recognize Wayne and Fonda and Burton and all the big stars, but the pop stars don't bump me because to me they are like extras. And none of them give a bad performance.
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Re: What are some period movies that seem dated to you?
To me, it's not so much Matthew Broderick but the Alan Parsons score. I get that they wanted to be hip at the time but the score never did really fit the movie, and now it seems really dated because of that score. If they were to eliminate the AP score and fill the void with serious orchestral music, I think Ladyhawke would be goddamned near a masterpiece of a period fantasy.