View Poll Results: Do you enjoy watching foreign films with subtitles?
Voters: 81. You may not vote on this poll
Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
#26
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I don't mind watching movies with subtitles unless I'm using the movie for background noise or something.
I do have an affinity for old B&W Samurai films, Seven Samurai, Rashomon, Harakiri, etc. There's just something about those kinds of movies that are better with subtitles (and B&W!).
The one type of movie that I absolutely can't stand though is French New Wave movie goes from the 60s. It's not so mgood that the subtitles but I just find everything about them annoying and/or pretentious.
I do have an affinity for old B&W Samurai films, Seven Samurai, Rashomon, Harakiri, etc. There's just something about those kinds of movies that are better with subtitles (and B&W!).
The one type of movie that I absolutely can't stand though is French New Wave movie goes from the 60s. It's not so mgood that the subtitles but I just find everything about them annoying and/or pretentious.
Last edited by GoldenJCJ; 08-09-17 at 08:25 AM.
#27
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I did prefer watching animated films dubbed.....Until someone decided to have Liam Neeson provide the voice for a certain character in Ponyo---A character-voice that appeared to be much more suited for the likes of Johnny Galecki or Crispen Glover.
#28
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I much prefer watching a movie in its original language with subtitles rather than an English dubbed version.
You just can't beat those older Hong Kong movies and their witty subtitles:
"Don't trust those cunny."
A Better Tomorrow
"I know it, he is not an idiot, he is sexual detour."
Black Panther Warriors
"Show be a fat one tomorrow."
Peking Opera Blues
You just can't beat those older Hong Kong movies and their witty subtitles:
"Don't trust those cunny."
A Better Tomorrow
"I know it, he is not an idiot, he is sexual detour."
Black Panther Warriors
"Show be a fat one tomorrow."
Peking Opera Blues
#29
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,463
Received 920 Likes
on
776 Posts
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
how can anyone who is a fan of film, not like foreign films with subs?? there are so so so many gems. some of my favorites of all-time are foreign...
#30
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
Well, when it comes to HK films a lot of the original dubs weren't even the actors themselves even though it is the original soundtrack. A lot of their films were dubbed in Mandarin because it was considered more "higher class" than the "street language" Cantonese. It wasn't until the later 70's that all changed. I understand Cantonese but I did prefer listening to a movie in Mandarin and reading the subs.
#31
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
It doesn't bother me at all. Occasionally, they do a terrible job with the contrast so they arevhard to read, but generally I don't really notice that I'm reading subtitles as I get drawn into the movie.
#32
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I hate having to read subtitles (and they take your eyes off of the action), but dubs take away the inflection/emotion of the actors' performances. 8 1/2 is a great film, but it's just got so much damn dialogue I can hardly keep up sometimes - I need to learn Italian!
Ironically The Double Life of Veronique and Harakiri are in my all-time top ten.
#33
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
#34
#35
#37
#38
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
Agree 100%. I prefer watching movies in the native language. Only exception, sometimes, is anime especially if the English voice work is good.
#39
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I read fast, so subtitles aren't an issue. I think the Star Wars were a perfect gateway for getting me accustomed to the notion of subtitles in movies. I don't think I ever really thought about them; as far back as I can remember subtitles have just been part of the movie going experience.
#40
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
No, I don't enjoy watching movies that way but I have to put up with it. I picked "Sometimes" because the "no" options didn't really apply.
#41
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I find myself turning on subtitles for films when I can't hear the person speaking or if there's something I don't quite catch. I normally don't watch entire films that way unless it's that way for the entire duration.
#42
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I find myself doing that more often, which I'm pretty sure means my hearing is going as I'm getting older. Either that or they need to stop casting so many mush-mouth actors.
#43
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
I wouldn't say I enjoy it but I tolerate it and would rather do subtitles than dubs. Alas, I rarely watch foreign movies and maybe I'd watch more if I did enjoy reading the subtitles.
#44
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
It also helps a lot with thick non-American English accents (British/Scottish/Irish/etc..) accents.
#45
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
Yea. I have to be in the mood though. Like anything else.
I find a lot of old films challenging too. Different times. Different pacing. But I'll still sit down and watch. And usually happy that I took the time. That's the thing with old movies ... if you're still watching them in 2017, then they really endured.
Was it Robert Altman that said something like, 'the lifespan of a movie is 10 years'?
I find a lot of old films challenging too. Different times. Different pacing. But I'll still sit down and watch. And usually happy that I took the time. That's the thing with old movies ... if you're still watching them in 2017, then they really endured.
Was it Robert Altman that said something like, 'the lifespan of a movie is 10 years'?
#46
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
For me it seems like the audio mix on so many things just isn't the greatest. I find a lot of films it's hard to hear the dialogue but then if I have my volume turned up the minute there's an effect noise or music it blasts. That irritates the hell out of me.
#47
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
#48
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,675
Received 1,021 Likes
on
843 Posts
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
Sometimes I try to watch a subtitled movie while working and realize what a bad idea that is.
#49
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
And sometimes the subtitles could be a revelation. For instance, most people think Jim Caviezel is the main narrator in The Thin Red Line. But it's actually the minor Private who "Wants to own an automobile".
#50
Re: Be Honest, do you enjoy watching foreign movies with subtitles?
Well, when it comes to HK films a lot of the original dubs weren't even the actors themselves even though it is the original soundtrack. A lot of their films were dubbed in Mandarin because it was considered more "higher class" than the "street language" Cantonese. It wasn't until the later 70's that all changed. I understand Cantonese but I did prefer listening to a movie in Mandarin and reading the subs.