DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   2016 Oscar Nominations (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/630415-2016-oscar-nominations.html)

Mabuse 01-14-16 11:06 AM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
I fail to see how Bridge of Spies is an original screenplay.

Decker 01-14-16 11:12 AM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Mabuse (Post 12696096)
I fail to see how Bridge of Spies is an original screenplay.

It's like this : When people get together and write a screenplay and it's not based on an existing book, play or screenplay, it's an original screenplay even if it's based on factual events even if it's enhanced by research of existing sources.

Technically, Everest (criminally completely ignored by the Academy) had an original screenplay even though it felt like a direct adaptation of Into Thin Air.

Giles 01-14-16 11:34 AM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 12696108)
It's like this : When people get together and write a screenplay and it's not based on an existing book, play or screenplay, it's an original screenplay even if it's based on factual events even if it's enhanced by research of existing sources.

Technically, Everest (criminally completely ignored by the Academy) had an original screenplay even though it felt like a direct adaptation of Into Thin Air.

now that soundmix and design was ten times more effective and stunning than that Star Wars movie.

inri222 01-14-16 01:37 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
I'm surprised Johnny Depp and Joel Edgerton weren't nominated for Black Mass.

EddieMoney 01-14-16 01:39 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Speaking of Edgerton, I thought "The Gift" was a film worthy of a few nominations.

Coral 01-14-16 01:47 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Glad TH8 got shut out in most categories. It really wasn't that good a film.

Double_Oh_7 01-14-16 01:49 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by dex14 (Post 12695978)
I agree that it is. But what/who should've been nominated?

Creed, Michael B. Jordan, Ryan Coogler...

RichC2 01-14-16 01:50 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Beasts of No Nation is about all I can think of, I liked Creed, but I didn't hold it in as high regard as some people seem to.

EddieMoney 01-14-16 02:03 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by inri222 (Post 12696281)
I'm surprised Johnny Depp and Joel Edgerton weren't nominated for Black Mass.

And that is his punishment for "Mortdecai."

And all those awful pirate films.

inri222 01-14-16 02:30 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by EddieMoney (Post 12696319)
And that is his punishment for "Mortdecai."

And all those awful pirate films.

Don't forget The Lone Ranger & Transcendence, haven't seen them but from what I've heard...

EddieMoney 01-14-16 02:35 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by inri222 (Post 12696354)
Don't forget The Lone Ranger & Transcendence, haven't seen them but from what I've heard...

No, I'd much rather forget them.

I guess I'm also not a huge Leo fan. I like him okay, but whenever he is on screen, I am always very conscious of the fact that he's "acting." Someone like Del Toro (who should have been nominated) always seems to just disappear into his roles.

RichC2 01-14-16 02:41 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
I don't get the push for Leo to get an Oscar, he's usually good but rarely exceptional in his roles. As others have pointed out, Tom Hardy was actually superior in The Revenant.

EddieMoney 01-14-16 02:51 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Slow West, Bone Tomahawk, and Mississippi Grind were all worthy films as well.

Ah well. It's just a famous person circle jerk anyway.

inri222 01-14-16 03:10 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by EddieMoney (Post 12696362)
I guess I'm also not a huge Leo fan. I like him okay, but whenever he is on screen, I am always very conscious of the fact that he's "acting." Someone like Del Toro (who should have been nominated) always seems to just disappear into his roles.

:up:


Originally Posted by RichC2 (Post 12696373)
I don't get the push for Leo to get an Oscar, he's usually good but rarely exceptional in his roles. As others have pointed out, Tom Hardy was actually superior in The Revenant.

:up:

EddieMoney 01-14-16 03:11 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by RichC2 (Post 12696373)
I don't get the push for Leo to get an Oscar, he's usually good but rarely exceptional in his roles. As others have pointed out, Tom Hardy was actually superior in The Revenant.

Well, Tom Hardy is a far superior actor, so makes sense. :)

inri222 01-14-16 03:12 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by EddieMoney (Post 12696414)
Well, Tom Hardy is a far superior actor, so makes sense. :)

https://media.giphy.com/media/eIYNPI83bk2lO/giphy.gif

EddieMoney 01-14-16 03:16 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Oh, and I'm sure inri222 has heard this before, but I wish someone would nominate Ben Mendelsohn for something. Christ, he is in multiple great films every year, and could have easily been nominated for "Mississippi Grind" this year.

Doomed to forever be known as "that one guy." Fucking shame.

inri222 01-14-16 03:24 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by EddieMoney (Post 12696421)
Oh, and I'm sure inri222 has heard this before, but I wish someone would nominate Ben Mendelsohn for something. Christ, he is in multiple great films every year, and could have easily been nominated for "Mississippi Grind" this year.

Doomed to forever be known as "that one guy." Fucking shame.

Starred Up, Lost River, Killing Them Softly, Slow West, The Place Beyond the Pines. That guy can do no wrong. Not a young pretty boy so he'll mostly be used as a character actor by Hollywood.

Defiant1 01-14-16 03:31 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Thrush (Post 12696071)
Has an action movie ever gotten this much love from the Oscars? Usually thats a genre where no matter how good, they are basically ignored come Oscar time.

Star Wars, Avatar, LOTR: ROTK, Gravity, Gladiator, & Raiders of the Lost Ark.

Some of these may not be considered "pure" action movies, but they all fit the definition of what an action movie is - a genre of film where heroes are thrust into a series of challenges, typically physical, which they must overcome and defeat the villain. You could even throw in the second half of Titanic in there based on that.

GuessWho 01-14-16 03:37 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Mabuse (Post 12696096)
I fail to see how Bridge of Spies is an original screenplay.

Why? Because it was real life?

The King's Speech, Milk, Gandhi, Chariots of Fire and Patton all WON this award.

Hazel Motes 01-14-16 03:52 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
The real take home thing for me from those nominations is that its 2016 and both John Williams and Ennio Morricone are nominated for Best Original score. Thats fucking awesome. I love that those 2 guys are going head to head.

Mabuse 01-14-16 03:59 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by GuessWho (Post 12696442)
Why? Because it was real life?

The King's Speech, Milk, Gandhi, Chariots of Fire and Patton all WON this award.

I say it because I believed it to be adapted from the book Strangers on the Bridge. Now I've read that the screenwriters claim not to have worked from that account, but that seems fishy.

Maz Kanata 01-14-16 04:29 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Defiant1 (Post 12696435)
Star Wars, Avatar, LOTR: ROTK, Gravity, Gladiator, & Raiders of the Lost Ark.

Some of these may not be considered "pure" action movies, but they all fit the definition of what an action movie is - a genre of film where heroes are thrust into a series of challenges, typically physical, which they must overcome and defeat the villain. You could even throw in the second half of Titanic in there based on that.

Also The Fugitive.

Decker 01-14-16 04:37 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Mabuse (Post 12696468)
I say it because I believed it to be adapted from the book Strangers on the Bridge. Now I've read that the screenwriters claim not to have worked from that account, but that seems fishy.

Yeah, who are these upstart screenwriters they nominated anyway? Joel & Ethan Coen? Never heard of them. Probably just a couple of plagiarizing hacks hoping to make a name for themselves by stealing another's work. I wouldn't trust them.

OldBoy 01-14-16 05:07 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
<strike>can someone find me a printable 2016 Oscar ballot? i can't seem to find something/anything for this year yet...</strike>

JeffTheAlpaca 01-14-16 05:12 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Paul Dano did deserve it for Love and Mercy

If Mad Max Fury Road wins I am boycotting.

I know it has a lot of fans but I thought it was boring and a bunch of chicks talking in a jeep or all terrain vehicle.

Max Max winning best picture would be th equivalent of Channing Tatum winning an Oscar.

OldBoy 01-14-16 05:14 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by JeffTheAlpaca (Post 12696559)
Paul Dano did deserve it for Love and Mercy

If Mad Max Fury Road wins I am boycotting.

I know it has a lot of fans but I thought it was boring and a bunch of chicks talking in a jeep or all terrain vehicle.

Max Max winning best picture would be th equivalent of Channing Tatum winning an Oscar.

it's not going to win anything outstanding, but still is cool that its got 10 major nods. a movie like this doesn't come along that often and can't wait to revist in 3D.

Decker 01-14-16 05:22 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Sylvester Stallone became the sixth actor to be twice nominated for playing the same role in different movies. Can you name the other five (I only knew the first four)?

Answers (in Reverse Chronological order)
Spoiler:
Cate Blanchett - Queen Elizabeth I (Elizabeth & The Golden Age)
Paul Newman - Fast Eddie Felson (The Hustler and Color of Money)
Al Pacino - Michael Corlione (Godfather 1 & 2)
Peter O'Toole - Henry II (Beckett & Lion In Winter)
Bing Crosby - Father O'Malley (Going My Way & Bells of St Mary)

TomOpus 01-14-16 05:29 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by JeffTheAlpaca (Post 12696559)
If Mad Max Fury Road wins I am boycotting.

Boycotting what?

OldBoy 01-14-16 05:30 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by TomOpus (Post 12696566)
Boycotting what?

:lol:

Why So Blu? 01-14-16 05:34 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
:lol:

auto 01-14-16 05:53 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
rotfl

Coral 01-14-16 06:02 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Looks like Roger Deakins will be going 0 for 13. Poor bastard :lol:

Ash Ketchum 01-14-16 06:48 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by HN (Post 12696057)
Peter Fonda
Honorary / Lifetime Achievement - 1980
Winner - Best Actor (On Golden Pond) - 1981

Must have been that winning streak of FIGHTING MAD, FUTUREWORLD, OUTLAW BLUES and HIGH-BALLIN' that cinched it.

http://i.digiguide.tv/up/1304/145449...6785269.51.jpg

TimeSkip 01-14-16 06:56 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Guess Room got the Directing nomination over The Martian. Surprising.

Decker 01-14-16 06:59 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by TimeSkip (Post 12696616)
Guess Room got the Directing nomination over The Martian. Surprising.

I'm pretty upset about that -- except that it swings the sentimental vote 100% to Miller, which I am TOTALLY on board with.

GoldenJCJ 01-14-16 07:30 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 12696618)
I'm pretty upset about that -- except that it swings the sentimental vote 100% to Miller, which I am TOTALLY on board with.

No way does George Miller win, even for sentimentality. That leaves Alejandro Iñarrítu and Lenny Abrahamson as the only real options and Abrahamson as the dark horse.

I see Iñarrítu winning the Best Director and in turn The Revenant winning BP.

Decker 01-14-16 07:46 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 

Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ (Post 12696639)
No way does George Miller win, even for sentimentality. That leaves Alejandro Iñarrítu and Lenny Abrahamson as the only real options and Abrahamson as the dark horse.

I see Iñarrítu winning the Best Director and in turn The Revenant winning BP.

I'm sorry, but what exactly is THAT based on? He's won literally dozens of critics' awards for Fury Road so far and he's nominated for the DGA award. Sure, Inarritu might win a second Oscar back-to-back, but since that is an incredibly rare feat (and not everyone love Revenant), it's hardly a certainty. And Abrahanson is the longest of long shots in that category.

GoldenJCJ 01-14-16 07:49 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
Just my opinion.

I also think Adam McKay is the long shot of that category.

Decker 01-14-16 07:59 PM

Re: 2016 Oscar Nominations
 
The longest shot is the one who didn't get nominated for a DGA award. There has NEVER been a Best Director Oscar winner who wasn't at least nominated for the DGA award (there have only been seven times since its' inception in 1948 where the DGA winner didn't also win the Oscar -- and a couple of times it was because the DGA winner wasn't nominated for an Oscar like Affleck with Argo and Ron Howard with Apollo 13).
Abrahamson is the only nominee this year who was not also nominated for the DGA award.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:22 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.