View Poll Results: Mad Max 2 (The Road Warrior) vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
Mad Max 2




28
57.14%
Mad Max: Fury Road




20
40.82%
Both are unimpressive




1
2.04%
Voters: 49. You may not vote on this poll
Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
#51
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
The beginning portion of FR had plenty of sped up scenes when Max is trying to escape the tower. I actually have one friend who stopped watching after those first 5 minutes, because it took him out of the film completely with the speed up.
#52
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
Yeah, the opening foot chase was jarring as hell.
#53
Member
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
Yes and no.
It connects to the prequel comics that Miller plotted/wrote that came out earlier this year. Of course, if you're not aware of them (as most of the general public is not) then one would not know. I'd say it retains the "spirit" of the earlier works while creating a newer world. It's fine.
It connects to the prequel comics that Miller plotted/wrote that came out earlier this year. Of course, if you're not aware of them (as most of the general public is not) then one would not know. I'd say it retains the "spirit" of the earlier works while creating a newer world. It's fine.
#54
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
You couldn't accept that this guy went through some shit that haunts him today? Even w/o the comics...which I do want to read at some point.... I got that Max fucked up bad before Fury Road started. The whats and whys didn't matter. Miller did fine with giving us some history on Max. Nor do I think the film implies that you need to know more beyond that. The comics are just added world building but not essential to the film.
#55
Member
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
You couldn't accept that this guy went through some shit that haunts him today? Even w/o the comics...which I do want to read at some point.... I got that Max fucked up bad before Fury Road started. The whats and whys didn't matter. Miller did fine with giving us some history on Max.
#56
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
If can't buy it then that's not the problem of the film.
#58
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
I heavily doubt Miller did that to sell some comics. It's just added filler. Not essential.
What is your issue exactly w/ not accepting that Max fucked up? Remember. We don't see a lot of world building in these films. Shit. MM1 and MM2 have a wild event happen between them. We got the same thing w/ Fury Road. We jump in Max's life. Points in his timeline. We don't immediately follow the man event to event. We don't need to.
What is your issue exactly w/ not accepting that Max fucked up? Remember. We don't see a lot of world building in these films. Shit. MM1 and MM2 have a wild event happen between them. We got the same thing w/ Fury Road. We jump in Max's life. Points in his timeline. We don't immediately follow the man event to event. We don't need to.
#59
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I basically figured out from from context clues that the little girl was someone Max had failed to save and was therefore haunting him (literally). One of the things I liked about the film was how it didn't spoon-feed the audience that, you get all kinds of hints about a larger mythology that Miller obviously thought out, but the movie doesn't tell you about directly and just hints about. If you've never seen any of the previous films, you get all of the exposition about the world-nuclear war, no gas, apocalypse-I'm the first sixty seconds, and then it's off and running.
#60
Member
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
None of the other movies have stupid flashback scenes/sequences to explain why Max is the way he is. It's not like anyone seeing this movie hasn't seen the other Mad Max movies at least at some point unless they're teenagers or whatever.
The movie just doesn't fit with the previous MM movies. It's trying way too hard and just isn't as good with the characters as the earlier films. And Max isn't central to the plot, like he was in all of the other movies. Just watched Mad Max 2 and Beyond Thunderdome, and still think they work better than this slicker looking, higher budgeted but ultimately pointless exercise in what an updated Mad Max movie would be I guess, but based on the worldwide take we won't be seeing anymore of these. It's fine for what it is, but isn't even close to being the best in the series.
The movie just doesn't fit with the previous MM movies. It's trying way too hard and just isn't as good with the characters as the earlier films. And Max isn't central to the plot, like he was in all of the other movies. Just watched Mad Max 2 and Beyond Thunderdome, and still think they work better than this slicker looking, higher budgeted but ultimately pointless exercise in what an updated Mad Max movie would be I guess, but based on the worldwide take we won't be seeing anymore of these. It's fine for what it is, but isn't even close to being the best in the series.
#61
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
Just watched Mad Max 2 and Beyond Thunderdome, and still think they work better than this slicker looking, higher budgeted but ultimately pointless exercise in what an updated Mad Max movie would be I guess, but based on the worldwide take we won't be seeing anymore of these.
#63
DVD Talk Legend
#65
Member
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
Not the plot, but he was central nonetheless. Max was definitely the driving force of both of those films. He was in nearly every scene and we identified with his character, despite being an outsider. In Fury Road, we don't get much from Max in that sense. He's designated to being a driver for crying out loud. Until the last 20 minutes of the movie, his character is just a supporting one, and even then he's only good for coming up with the idea of going back. Plus the main villain is pretty weak, even if his suit thing and face mask were kind of cool. It's not a good thing when Furiosa and Nux steal the show from the title character.
#66
Member
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
I beg to differ. I never got a sense of the society and who and what the villains were doing outside of Immortan Joe will his cult. The other groups pop as merely obstacles for the numerous chases sequences. Only near the end of the movie did it finally slow down enough for me to care about anything going on in the movie, so in that respect the movie started to feel like a Mad Max movie, but it was disappointing to see how long it took to get there. Max's role until the end was being a blood bag (still didn't understand how the villains figured that out; still a stupid plot device) and getaway driver for the most part.
#67
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
I beg to differ. I never got a sense of the society and who and what the villains were doing outside of Immortan Joe will his cult. The other groups pop as merely obstacles for the numerous chases sequences. Only near the end of the movie did it finally slow down enough for me to care about anything going on in the movie, so in that respect the movie started to feel like a Mad Max movie, but it was disappointing to see how long it took to get there. Max's role until the end was being a blood bag (still didn't understand how the villains figured that out; still a stupid plot device) and getaway driver for the most part.
#69
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max 2 vs. Mad Max: Fury Road
Weird, to each their own.