Most overrated modern comedies?
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Most overrated modern comedies?
In your opinion?
Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle
Forgetting Sarah Marshall
Get Him to the Greek (the rotten tomatoes rating is especially shocking)
22 Jump Street
Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle
Forgetting Sarah Marshall
Get Him to the Greek (the rotten tomatoes rating is especially shocking)
22 Jump Street
#2
Banned by request
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
Ha, I like all of those. Not the classiest of comedies, but I think they're all pretty funny.
Never understood the love for every Adam Sandler comedy, especially Happy Gilmore. Also any of those Broken Lizard movies.
Never understood the love for every Adam Sandler comedy, especially Happy Gilmore. Also any of those Broken Lizard movies.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
Anything starring Melissa McCarthy or Rebel Wilson. I have mixed feelings on Apatow films too. I actually love The 40 Year Old Virgin and Forgetting Sarah Marshall but those are about all I like from him. Seth Rogen I also have mixed feelings on as an actor in general. Sometimes I think he's pretty great but other times I just find him annoying.
Last edited by Mike86; 12-29-14 at 08:34 PM.
#6
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
IMO, The Hangover, yes the first one. It's ok, but I didn't think it deserved anywhere near the praise that it got.
#7
DVD Talk God
#8
#9
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
Strong agreement on Happy Gimore and 40 year old virgin. Also hated Billy Madison.
I did like Wedding Singer and Anger Management.
Also never understood all the love for Ace Ventura.
I did like Wedding Singer and Anger Management.
Also never understood all the love for Ace Ventura.
#10
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
I didn't fully understand the good ratings for This Is The End or Neighbors, though I enjoyed The Interview. I also didn't get Get Him to the Greek, it had a couple funny scenes and was otherwise kind of a waste, and I loved Forgetting Sarah Marshall.
My Big Fat Greek Wedding bored me to tears as well.
My Big Fat Greek Wedding bored me to tears as well.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
I really liked This Is The End. I thought it was funny due to all the main actors playing exagerrated versions of themselves and just because of how goofy it was. Just a really fun film to me. Neighbors wasn't terrible but was just sort of so-so. I personally don't really view Juno as a full on comedy. I mean there are some funny elements to it but its more of a dramedy in my opinion. I do tend to agree about Wes Anderson films too. Some of them are really great but often times I find that his films are a bit too quirky for their own good and I wind up not liking them because of that. Again though a lot of his films I don't really know if I'd view as true comedies but more films that have some comedic elements.
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
American Pie
I remember seeing this in the theater and it was so bad that having people laughing in the theater (which usually elevates a comedy) made no difference for me. For a "comedy" it wasn't just unfunny, it was mostly boring as only 1 out of the 4 main characters that the movie focused on seemed even marginally funny. The other 3 main characters were dull as dishwater.
(I didn't see any of the sequels, so their suckiness is not something polluting my brain.)
I remember seeing this in the theater and it was so bad that having people laughing in the theater (which usually elevates a comedy) made no difference for me. For a "comedy" it wasn't just unfunny, it was mostly boring as only 1 out of the 4 main characters that the movie focused on seemed even marginally funny. The other 3 main characters were dull as dishwater.
(I didn't see any of the sequels, so their suckiness is not something polluting my brain.)
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
Aside from quite a few already mentioned, I don't get the love for Step Brothers. Terrible movie.
#15
Senior Member
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
Bridesmaids
Step Brothers
Don't get the love for either one.
Step Brothers
Don't get the love for either one.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
What people find funny is so subjective, that I know this thread will end up containing every comedy I love made in the past 20 years.
All I will say is that any comedy that has that no talent piece of shit Adam Sandler in it, is overrated.
All I will say is that any comedy that has that no talent piece of shit Adam Sandler in it, is overrated.
#17
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
True, it is very subjective. I hated The Heat and Big Fat Greek Wedding but both were extremely successful movies. I loved Hangover, I Love You Man, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Wedding Crashers, etc; but those seem to find equal amounts of hate around these parts.
I actually don't mind Adam Sandler movies as long as they try to make them funny. I feel like some of his movies, like Blended, don't even try to be funny anymore. I enjoy his older movies that seem to get a lot of hate (don't love them, but I do enjoy Happy Gilmore more than I care to admit).
I actually don't mind Adam Sandler movies as long as they try to make them funny. I feel like some of his movies, like Blended, don't even try to be funny anymore. I enjoy his older movies that seem to get a lot of hate (don't love them, but I do enjoy Happy Gilmore more than I care to admit).
#22
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
I 100% agree with both Napoleon Dynamite and Step Brothers. Those movies are simply bad. Not quirky. Not quotable. Bad.
#23
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,636
Received 1,016 Likes
on
840 Posts
Re: Most overrated modern comedies?
I was also surprised by Wedding Crashers, except for
Spoiler:
#24
DVD Talk Legend