What changes would you make to a movie?
#226
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
I would get rid of the whole "Aragorn falls over the cliff and makes a dramatic return" sequence from The Two Towers. It wasn't in the book, was unnecessary, and just slows down a storyline that takes long enough to get going anyhow.
#228
DVD Talk Legend
#230
Member
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
Get rid of Paul Gleason's character from Die Hard and it would be so much better a movie. His character is so stupid that he almost derails the movie.
#231
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: What changes would you make to a movie?
#232
DVD Talk Hero
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
I would change a plot element in Seven. And I'd also remove the damn number 7 from the title. I hate numbers supposing to represent letters.
I'd like for Somerset and Mills to find John Doe some way other than checking "controversial books" checked out of libraries. It seemed so ham-handed to me. I imagined John Doe owning his own copies of those books, purchased at second-hand stores, dog-eared and full of notes.
I'd like for Somerset and Mills to find John Doe some way other than checking "controversial books" checked out of libraries. It seemed so ham-handed to me. I imagined John Doe owning his own copies of those books, purchased at second-hand stores, dog-eared and full of notes.
#234
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
I would change when Ingrid Bergman refers to Dooley Wilson as "boy" in Casablanca.
#235
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,129
Received 1,722 Likes
on
1,412 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
#236
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
In The Village, I'd get rid of
Everything else in that movie works so well for me, but that ending almost completely ruins it (and is completely predictable).
Spoiler:
#237
Banned
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
From: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
It's a great movie but it's not lean. Predator is lean. DH isn't.
#238
DVD Talk Legend
#239
Banned
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 20,052
Received 169 Likes
on
127 Posts
From: Conducting miss-aisle drills and listening to their rock n roll
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
Sorry, but you are just wrong. Your examples of Argyle and Johnson don't hold up to any real scrutiny. All those characters have very little screen time and play roles essential to the unfolding of the plot.
#241
DVD Talk Legend
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
I wish it had been Adam Sandler as Sgt. Donotwitz instead of Eli "Toolbag" Roth in Inglourious Basterds.
#242
Moderator
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
#243
#244
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
I have been thinking about "idiot" plots some recently (if someone in the film doesn't act like an idiot, there's no plot) and saw an example recently ...
I like Atlantic City (1980) a lot, and watched it a few days ago. I noticed a plot element that I thought could have been handled much better. A character is killed by mobsters. It's important for the plot for the character to die, but stupid for the gangsters to kill him, since they then have to search for what he stole from them (they didn't even try to question him). This could have been changed; the mobsters catch him, try to question him, but he pulls a hidden gun or knife and they're forced to kill him in self-defense. Same result but no stupid.
It's not really that big a deal, and I'm sure the filmmakers felt that viewers would be caught up in the story and not notice this, but it bugged me.
Also the one I mention every time, cast someone else besides Richard B. Shull in Cockfighter (Rance Howard, among others, would have been much more appropriate). Otherwise a perfect (and distinctive) movie.
I like Atlantic City (1980) a lot, and watched it a few days ago. I noticed a plot element that I thought could have been handled much better. A character is killed by mobsters. It's important for the plot for the character to die, but stupid for the gangsters to kill him, since they then have to search for what he stole from them (they didn't even try to question him). This could have been changed; the mobsters catch him, try to question him, but he pulls a hidden gun or knife and they're forced to kill him in self-defense. Same result but no stupid.
It's not really that big a deal, and I'm sure the filmmakers felt that viewers would be caught up in the story and not notice this, but it bugged me.
Also the one I mention every time, cast someone else besides Richard B. Shull in Cockfighter (Rance Howard, among others, would have been much more appropriate). Otherwise a perfect (and distinctive) movie.
Last edited by obscurelabel; 09-08-15 at 09:55 AM.
#245
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
I have said it before but Warren Beatty would not lose who he was at the end of Heaven Can Wait. Bothers me on a fundamental level.
#246
DVD Talk Special Edition
#247
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?
#248
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 542
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Nova Catacumba Exhibition Center on Estrella De Tiago, an Asteroid orbiting the Moon.
Re: What changes would you make to a movie?
A Night To Remember When the Titanic is launched, after the lady christens her and says "May God bless her and all who sail in her" you hear the rumble of thunder.
#249
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: If you could make one change to a movie you love?

You must abide by what is written.
Sorry, but the rules in this one were laid out very clearly. He had to lose who he was (well, maybe besides a faint memory and his spirit) when he took over the body of Tom Jarrett. Joe Pendleton only knew who he was as Leo Farnsworth because it was a temporary arrangement, brought about by extraordinary circumstances.
A better complaint is why didn't they know exactly when Joe Pendleton was actually going to die since that precise information is on the clipboard of the guy who shuttles spirits onto the waiting Concord.
Yeah, I might have overthought this, but it was my all-time favorite movie growing up.
#250
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: What changes would you make to a movie?
Four moments + one audio element in The Hills Have Eyes remake being altered would make a much better film.
I am a big fan of the remake and think it's largely effective, but these moments really drop it down a peg since it takes me out of the movie. There might be some other more subtle tweaks I'd do to some of the violent scenes
, but overall, the stuff listed are the major issues I have with the remake.
Spoiler:
I am a big fan of the remake and think it's largely effective, but these moments really drop it down a peg since it takes me out of the movie. There might be some other more subtle tweaks I'd do to some of the violent scenes
Spoiler:




