View Poll Results: Who edges out who?
Jessica Chastain
42
38.53%
Jennifer Lawrence
67
61.47%
Voters: 109. You may not vote on this poll
Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
#151
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
I can't even remember if I commented in this thread, but from an acting point of view, they're about dead even. From a physical point of view, neither appeal to me. Chastain is a skinny, pasty white redhead with freckles and Lawrence has an odd face. There's something about it that just throws me off.
#152
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
I agree with you on SLP.... cliched up the whazoo romantic comedy. But I can't call it Russel's worse when the shitfest known as I Heart Huckabees exists. What a mess that piece of shit was.
#154
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
Just saw "The House at the End of the Street". It's watchable primarily because of Jennifer Lawrence and it's not like her character was written all that well, either. I have yet to see one of her films where she doesn't demand attention each and every moment she's onscreen.
#156
Banned by request
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
This thread reminded me how disappointing ZDT was.
Also, Jennifer Lawrence stole American Hustle, and the last Chastain performance that impressed me was...well, none of them.
Also, Jennifer Lawrence stole American Hustle, and the last Chastain performance that impressed me was...well, none of them.
#158
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
Saying that I think Lawrence is more exciting for her roles. Except for Hunger Games, which doesn't do much for her acting. Never saw that horror film she did. And I'd blame the scripting for her character in First Class. Wonder wtf Mystique will be like in DoFP cuz FC didn't do well with her at times.
#159
Banned by request
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
ZDT was absurdly overrated, IMO. Chastain's character had no arc. The raid on the compound was well directed, but that's the only positive thing I have to say about the film.
#161
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
She will in about 10 years when her star starts to dim a little. They ALL do. Anyone remember God telling Renee Russo to do a nude scene?
By the way about a year later and Lawrence is hotter AND a better actress.
#162
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,448
Received 913 Likes
on
773 Posts
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
what kind of arc were you looking for with an agent who is dedicated to one mission for 10 years? it can't be a lovestory/capture the enemy pic...
#163
Banned by request
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
Any kind of arc. There was no indication she had any kind of life outside of her job for 10 years. Talk about boring.
#164
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
They could have added a Taliban informant that she sleeps with to get information but realizes she is in love with and that they are star crossed lovers and even though he is a terrorist she is able to turn him into an asset.
#165
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I thought that was the whole point: there wasn't much to her outside of what she did, it was an all-consuming obsession which blocked out everything else in her life.
#166
Banned by request
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
Why should I give a shit, then? I'm not saying add a love interest. I'm saying show some change from point A to point B. She did this for 10 years and it didn't change her in any way? It's just lazy filmmaking.
#167
Inane Thread Master, 2018 TOTY
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Are any of us really anywhere?
Posts: 49,448
Received 913 Likes
on
773 Posts
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
i think han nailed it. she was obsessed and had no room for everything/anything else. that was the point and not lazy, but probably a little more accurate. this was loosely based on true story anyway. i knew what it was going in and was pretty much riveted. if you knew going in what it was about, why see it and subsequently put it down?
#168
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
He knew the film was about the hunt for Bin Laden, I think he saying that he found her character one-dimensional and wanted to see more of her life outside of the hunt to see how it destroyed her life and made one so single-minded. I've heard the same criticism thrown at Raging Bull, about how the one-dimensional central character ultimately made the film feel repetitive. Probably the closest thing you get in ZDT is her initial unease at the torture before she becomes so obsessive. I think of ZDT as a sort of Information Age-type thriller about how to sift through endless amounts of data in the post-globalization type age where everything is so fragmented.
#169
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
I think the final scene of ZDT tells you everything you need to know about Chastain's character and how the hunt for Bin Laden affected her. I think it's a great scene and pretty indicative of the fine work that Chastain is capable of. I also thought she was great in Take Shelter and Tree of Life.
#170
Banned by request
Re: Jessica Chastain vs Jennifer Lawrence
i think han nailed it. she was obsessed and had no room for everything/anything else. that was the point and not lazy, but probably a little more accurate. this was loosely based on true story anyway. i knew what it was going in and was pretty much riveted. if you knew going in what it was about, why see it and subsequently put it down?