Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
01-30-12, 05:39 PM
#51
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Posts: 52,604
Received 1,014 Likes
on
838 Posts
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
United 93 had Paul Greengrass involved, studio backing, a legitimate and proven crew, and Gregg Henry. However, due to the nature of the film, a lot of the cast were people playing themselves. With the exception of the people on United Flight 93 for obvious reasons. 
[However, actors who were in the film like Cheyenne Jackson and Olivia Thirlby now have solid careers.]
[However, actors who were in the film like Cheyenne Jackson and Olivia Thirlby now have solid careers.]
).
01-30-12, 06:09 PM
#52
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
01-31-12, 02:52 AM
#54
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 1999
Posts: 1,935
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
I havn't seen this propaganda piece (and I never will) but I have seen the trailers numerous times. I am just gonna say that my prediction is that this is going to be horrible and that you be able to see that in the reviews and you will also notice in the reviews how negatively this portrays the "villains" .
ALso a good way to judge the quality of something is to look for signs of any talent involved. This has no established crew who have dont any great work in the past.
ALso a good way to judge the quality of something is to look for signs of any talent involved. This has no established crew who have dont any great work in the past.
It's not like Hollywood will put out movies that aren't accurate if established is involved, case in point:
The Patriot
02-05-12, 10:24 PM
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
The only thing he hasn't done yet is say movies stink if they are under 2 hours and not rated R
I vote or what.
Last edited by whotony; 02-06-12 at 12:17 AM.
02-05-12, 11:12 PM
#57
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
People are saying those things because they think he is a poster that was banned last year. This guys screen name is almost exactly the same and many of his lists are too.
The only thing he hasn't done yet is say movies stink if they are under 2 hours and not rated R
I vote or what.
The only thing he hasn't done yet is say movies stink if they are under 2 hours and not rated R
I vote or what.
02-05-12, 11:18 PM
#58
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
02-05-12, 11:44 PM
#59
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
02-06-12, 10:45 AM
#61
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
I saw the trailer and I have to confess it does look like a recruiting film for the Navy Seals. The Navy's doing a lot of advertising anyway these days.
02-06-12, 11:18 AM
#62
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
Yeah it definitely looks like a recruiting film but so was The Hurt Locker. When people think of "propaganda" films they think of John Wayne but only because those were so blatant. These films coming out nowadays are too, they're just more subtle about it.
02-06-12, 12:21 PM
#63
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
That said, I get the marketing angle here, but when I pay $$$ to see a movie, I prefer actors. I have a feeling the acting level here won't be much better than a soap opera or one of those Kirk Cameron religous films.
02-07-12, 02:51 PM
#64
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
I keep thinking this is the Modern Warfare/Battlefield movie we never asked for.
Also, if these guys are on active duty, isn't it going to make secret missions more difficult?
Also, if these guys are on active duty, isn't it going to make secret missions more difficult?
02-07-12, 04:37 PM
#67
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
So any movie that depicts US soldiers in anything other than a negative way is simply a propaganda/recruiting film?
What's wrong with a movie that actually has US soldiers being the good guys? Why does every war movie have to be a downer that depicts US soliders as the bad guys?
I mean Christ, just within the last year, SEAL Team 6 accomplished 2 missions (that we know about) that I can't believe could be thought of as anything but good. So, what's wrong with depicting our US soldiers as heroes for once? There have been so many negative war movies in the last decade, so what's wrong with a positive one for a change? I miss the 80's.
What's wrong with a movie that actually has US soldiers being the good guys? Why does every war movie have to be a downer that depicts US soliders as the bad guys?
I mean Christ, just within the last year, SEAL Team 6 accomplished 2 missions (that we know about) that I can't believe could be thought of as anything but good. So, what's wrong with depicting our US soldiers as heroes for once? There have been so many negative war movies in the last decade, so what's wrong with a positive one for a change? I miss the 80's.
02-07-12, 04:47 PM
#68
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
So any movie that depicts US soldiers in anything other than a negative way is simply a propaganda/recruiting film?
What's wrong with a movie that actually has US soldiers being the good guys? Why does every war movie have to be a downer that depicts US soliders as the bad guys?
I mean Christ, just within the last year, SEAL Team 6 accomplished 2 missions (that we know about) that I can't believe could be thought of as anything but good. So, what's wrong with depicting our US soldiers as heroes for once? There have been so many negative war movies in the last decade, so what's wrong with a positive one for a change? I miss the 80's.
What's wrong with a movie that actually has US soldiers being the good guys? Why does every war movie have to be a downer that depicts US soliders as the bad guys?
I mean Christ, just within the last year, SEAL Team 6 accomplished 2 missions (that we know about) that I can't believe could be thought of as anything but good. So, what's wrong with depicting our US soldiers as heroes for once? There have been so many negative war movies in the last decade, so what's wrong with a positive one for a change? I miss the 80's.
If they'd wanted to make it entertaining...
02-07-12, 05:11 PM
#69
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
I don't get the "recruiting" vibe from this. I do get a weird "Christian conservative right" from it. So yes, it seems like propoganda of some sort.
02-07-12, 05:53 PM
#70
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
The film is neither jingoistic nor aimed at recruitment/propaganda. It is about what these specific professional soldiers do. You could swap out the SEALs in this film with other special ops forces (Green Berets, Delta Force, British SAS, Israeli Defense Force, etc) and you would see a lot of the same stuff. This film just happens to highlight the SEALs.
02-07-12, 05:59 PM
#71
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
So any movie that depicts US soldiers in anything other than a negative way is simply a propaganda/recruiting film?
What's wrong with a movie that actually has US soldiers being the good guys? Why does every war movie have to be a downer that depicts US soliders as the bad guys?
I mean Christ, just within the last year, SEAL Team 6 accomplished 2 missions (that we know about) that I can't believe could be thought of as anything but good. So, what's wrong with depicting our US soldiers as heroes for once? There have been so many negative war movies in the last decade, so what's wrong with a positive one for a change? I miss the 80's.
What's wrong with a movie that actually has US soldiers being the good guys? Why does every war movie have to be a downer that depicts US soliders as the bad guys?
I mean Christ, just within the last year, SEAL Team 6 accomplished 2 missions (that we know about) that I can't believe could be thought of as anything but good. So, what's wrong with depicting our US soldiers as heroes for once? There have been so many negative war movies in the last decade, so what's wrong with a positive one for a change? I miss the 80's.
Originally Posted by madcougar
I do get a weird "Christian conservative right" from it. So yes, it seems like propoganda of some sort.
Since when did being pro-military become "Christian conservative right"? (Top Gun is the most Christian film ever, if that's the case.) I don't get a Christian vibe at all from this one and I've seen numerous trailers.
02-07-12, 07:14 PM
#73
DVD Talk Limited Edition
02-07-12, 07:38 PM
#74
Re: Act of Valor -- 2/17/12 -- (starring active duty Navy SEALs)
Really? I thought THE HURT LOCKER came off as anti-war. Maybe that was just the way I viewed it.
That said, I get the marketing angle here, but when I pay $$$ to see a movie, I prefer actors. I have a feeling the acting level here won't be much better than a soap opera or one of those Kirk Cameron religous films.
That said, I get the marketing angle here, but when I pay $$$ to see a movie, I prefer actors. I have a feeling the acting level here won't be much better than a soap opera or one of those Kirk Cameron religous films.
