View Poll Results: Who has the better team of characters?
wishbone
39
53.42%
Osiris3657
34
46.58%
Voters: 73. You may not vote on this poll
DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
#1
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
Hello voter! Please vote for the team of characters that you like better. It's all personal preference. If one character on the list ruins a team for you and you select the other team based on that alone, so be it (although it would be preferred that you look at the team as a whole )
We would love to hear feedback and why you chose one team over another. Feel free to comment, ask questions, criticize, etc.
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999)
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962)
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954)
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941)
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967)
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009)
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005)
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994)
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998)
We would love to hear feedback and why you chose one team over another. Feel free to comment, ask questions, criticize, etc.
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999)
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962)
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954)
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941)
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967)
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009)
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005)
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994)
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998)
#3
Moderator
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden + (love this guy, perhaps picked too early though)
2. Atticus Finch + (my son is named after this character)
3. Kikuchiyo + (I could watch this performance over and over)
4. Charles Foster Kane + (classic)
5. Jeff Spicoli + (hilarious and memorable)
6. John Shaft + (Jackson played a different character!)
7. Pinhead + (memorable villain)
8. Kirk Lazarus + (I couldn't stop laughing)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson + (great anti-hero)
10. Alan Swann - (I thought this movie was DOA)
Total Pluses: 9
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name + (but I'm not convinced this is one character)
2. Patrick Bateman + (brought the novel to life)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman + (just a great character)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs + (best part of an otherwise mediocre film)
5. William Wallace - (didn't care for this film, or this character)
6. Marv + (Rourke was great)
7. Dr. Alan Grant - ( why this dullard over Ian Malcolm?)
8. Stansfield + (great villain)
9. Agent Smith + (liked this character immensely)
10. Captain John H. Miller - (another somewhat dull performance)
Total Pluses: 7
Winner: wishbone
1. Tyler Durden + (love this guy, perhaps picked too early though)
2. Atticus Finch + (my son is named after this character)
3. Kikuchiyo + (I could watch this performance over and over)
4. Charles Foster Kane + (classic)
5. Jeff Spicoli + (hilarious and memorable)
6. John Shaft + (Jackson played a different character!)
7. Pinhead + (memorable villain)
8. Kirk Lazarus + (I couldn't stop laughing)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson + (great anti-hero)
10. Alan Swann - (I thought this movie was DOA)
Total Pluses: 9
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name + (but I'm not convinced this is one character)
2. Patrick Bateman + (brought the novel to life)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman + (just a great character)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs + (best part of an otherwise mediocre film)
5. William Wallace - (didn't care for this film, or this character)
6. Marv + (Rourke was great)
7. Dr. Alan Grant - ( why this dullard over Ian Malcolm?)
8. Stansfield + (great villain)
9. Agent Smith + (liked this character immensely)
10. Captain John H. Miller - (another somewhat dull performance)
Total Pluses: 7
Winner: wishbone
#4
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
yea there are people who argue that the Man with no Name is a different character, but what sold it for me was in The Good The Bad and The Ugly, Lee Van Cleef's character Angeleyes clearly recognizes Blondie from For A Few Dollars More
Alan Grant made me (and probably millions of other kids) want to be an archeologist. Iconic character in my eyes. I loved Ian Malcolm though.
Alan Grant made me (and probably millions of other kids) want to be an archeologist. Iconic character in my eyes. I loved Ian Malcolm though.
#5
Banned by request
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
But doesn't The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly take place before For A Few Dollars More? The Leone trilogy is pretty clearly three separate films, but Eastwood's character (despite having different names in all three) is identified as a singular character.
Edit: Even Lee Van Cleef's character is different in the second two films. In FAFDM he's Col. Mortimer. In TGTBATU he's Angel Eyes, but his real name is Sentenza.
Edit: Even Lee Van Cleef's character is different in the second two films. In FAFDM he's Col. Mortimer. In TGTBATU he's Angel Eyes, but his real name is Sentenza.
Last edited by Supermallet; 05-02-10 at 01:51 PM.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
Osiris3657
#8
Moderator
#13
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
Gave it to Osiris. Can't go wrong with Rorschach and Alan Grant.
#16
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Southern California
Posts: 3,416
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999) 6/10
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962) 8/10
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954) 8/10
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941) 6/10
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982) 10/10
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000) 7.5/10
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005) 9/10
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008) 7/10
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967) 7.5/10
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982) (N/A)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66) 10/10
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000) 7.5/10
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986) 9.5/10
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009) 7.5/10
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995) 7.5/10
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005) 6/10
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present) 6/10
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994) 7/10
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003) 7.5/10
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998) 8.5/10
wishbone - 7.7
Osiris3657 - 7.7
Very tough - two excellent lists. Tie breaker was based on my favorite out of all the above, which was Spicoli.
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999) 6/10
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962) 8/10
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954) 8/10
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941) 6/10
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982) 10/10
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000) 7.5/10
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005) 9/10
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008) 7/10
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967) 7.5/10
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982) (N/A)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66) 10/10
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000) 7.5/10
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986) 9.5/10
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009) 7.5/10
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995) 7.5/10
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005) 6/10
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present) 6/10
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994) 7/10
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003) 7.5/10
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998) 8.5/10
wishbone - 7.7
Osiris3657 - 7.7
Very tough - two excellent lists. Tie breaker was based on my favorite out of all the above, which was Spicoli.
#18
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
Another non-contest, Osiris3657 wins 9 of 10 match-ups.
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999)
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962)
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954)
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941)
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967)
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009)
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005)
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994)
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998)
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999)
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962)
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954)
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941)
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967)
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009)
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005)
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994)
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998)
#19
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
Wishbone...for referencing SEVEN SAMURAI, CITIZEN KANE, and SHAFT.
(Although I would have picked the lead character in SEVEN SAMURAI, the one played by Takashi Shimura, and not the Mifune character.)
(Although I would have picked the lead character in SEVEN SAMURAI, the one played by Takashi Shimura, and not the Mifune character.)
#20
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
bale in american psycho was enough for this close battle.. that being said I didn't care much for either of these rosters.
#21
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
wishbone
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009)
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994)
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
wishbone - 5
Osiris3657 - 6
Some nice heat in these lists. Dead even tie at face value. The man with no name and Stansfield characters are two my favorites and I found both Rorschach and Agent Smith were easily the most watchable characters from each of their respective films ...so I give the slight nod to Osiris.
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009)
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994)
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
wishbone - 5
Osiris3657 - 6
Some nice heat in these lists. Dead even tie at face value. The man with no name and Stansfield characters are two my favorites and I found both Rorschach and Agent Smith were easily the most watchable characters from each of their respective films ...so I give the slight nod to Osiris.
#24
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#25
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: DVDTalk Draft Round 1 (wishbone vs Osiris3657)
wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999)
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962)
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954) One of my all-time fave actors
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941) I didn't really enjoy watching CK
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967) Paul Newman
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986) FMJ is overrated for me.
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009) Rorschach probably the most loved character in Watchmen, but i never liked Watchmen, sorry.
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005)
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994) Id prefer Leon himself
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998)
So i guess i go with wishbone
1. Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt, Fight Club, 1999)
2. Atticus Finch (Gregory Peck, To Kill a Mockingbird, 1962)
3. Kikuchiyo (Toshirô Mifune, Shichinin no samurai, 1954) One of my all-time fave actors
4. Charles Foster Kane (Orson Welles, Citizen Kane, 1941) I didn't really enjoy watching CK
5. Jeff Spicoli (Sean Penn, Fast Times at Ridgemont High, 1982)
6. John Shaft (Richard Roundtree & Samuel L. Jackson, Shaft franchise, 1971-2000)
7. Pinhead (Doug Bradley, Hellraiser franchise, 1987-2005)
8. Kirk Lazarus (Robert Downey Jr., Tropic Thunder, 2008)
9. "Cool Hand" Luke Jackson (Paul Newman, Cool Hand Luke, 1967) Paul Newman
10. Alan Swann (Peter O'Toole, My Favorite Year, 1982)
Osiris3657
1. The Man With No Name (Clint Eastwood, Dollars Trilogy, 1964-66)
2. Patrick Bateman (Christian Bale, American Psycho, 2000)
3. Gunnery Sergeant Hartman (R. Lee Ermey, Full Metal Jacket, 1986) FMJ is overrated for me.
4. Rorschach/Walter Kovacs (Jackie Earle Haley, Watchmen, 2009) Rorschach probably the most loved character in Watchmen, but i never liked Watchmen, sorry.
5. William Wallace (Mel Gibson, Braveheart, 1995)
6. Marv (Mickey Rourke, Sin City, 2005)
7. Dr. Alan Grant (Sam Neill, Jurassic Park franchise, 1993-present)
8. Stansfield (Gary Oldman, Leon, 1994) Id prefer Leon himself
9. Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving, Matrix trilogy, 1999-2003)
10. Captain John H. Miller (Tom Hanks, Saving Private Ryan, 1998)
So i guess i go with wishbone