DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Best Planet of the Apes Sequel (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/540510-best-planet-apes-sequel.html)

chris_sc77 09-27-08 04:28 PM

I liked the Burton remake as well. It was competent and entertaining. Not a great film like the original but it didn't try to be. The ending made no sense except to set up a sequel that we will never see.

The best sequel is Escape from.....

hasslein 09-28-08 12:03 AM

I thought it was so funny that Fox included a card in the dvd release explaining the ending of the Burton film. I didn't think it was that difficult to understand. A lot of people complain about the ending, but that was the only part of the film that worked for me. (And the opening credit sequence) The original couldn't have been topped, so the nod to the book was the best possible way to go. Other than making a sequel, which is the path that should have been taken IMHO.

clckworang 09-28-08 03:19 AM

It would be between Escape and Conquest for me. I like how much more bleak and violent Conquest is, though I admit Escape might be a better film. I guess I'll vote Conquest.

wm lopez 09-28-08 06:25 PM


Originally Posted by hasslein (Post 8968360)
I thought it was so funny that Fox included a card in the dvd release explaining the ending of the Burton film. I didn't think it was that difficult to understand. A lot of people complain about the ending, but that was the only part of the film that worked for me. (And the opening credit sequence) The original couldn't have been topped, so the nod to the book was the best possible way to go. Other than making a sequel, which is the path that should have been taken IMHO.

What did the card say?
And what was the ending in the book?

hasslein 09-28-08 08:51 PM

The Card is titled
TIME DOES NOT TRAVEL IN A STRAIGHT LINE THROUGH AN ELECTROMAGNETIC STORM

An illustration of this idea is underneath then ten plot points are listed.
Spoiler:
1. Pericles leaves Oberon to investigate electromagnetic Storm
2. Minutes Later Leo leaves the Oberon in search of Pericles
3.A Short time after, Oberon searches for Leo and Pericles
4. Pericles returns to Oberon crash site in Alpha pod shortly after Leo
5. Leo crash lands Delta Pod on Ape planet
6. Oberon crashes thousands of years before Leo arrives and apes take over planet
7. Leo leaves Ape planet in Alpha pod in an attempt to return home
8.Is it possible someone or something left the Ape planet in Delta pod after Leo?
9. Leo returns to earth
10. Is it possible someone or something arrives on Earth many years before Leo?


The end of the novel in a nutshell-

Spoiler:
The astronaut escapes the planet and returns to Earth. When he arrives, an ape awaits him in the landing area. Earth has been taken over by apes as well.

Sean O'Hara 09-28-08 09:57 PM


Originally Posted by hasslein (Post 8969887)
The end of the novel in a nutshell-

Spoiler:
The astronaut escapes the planet and returns to Earth. When he arrives, an ape awaits him in the landing area. Earth has been taken over by apes as well.

You forgot the double twist at the end.

Spoiler:
The book begins with a framing story about a couple on vacation aboard a space yacht, who find a mysterious bottle floating in space with a manuscript inside. At the end of the book, we return to the couple, who have a good laugh after reading the story -- imagine, humans building spaceships! What a preposterous joke!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:44 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.