Who do you consider a "Visionary" Director?
#28
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
David Lean. Reading "The Bridge over the River Kwai," "The Seven Pillars of Wisdom," "Doctor Zhivago," etc., it's enticing to imagine them as films; Lean actually made them. And who else would clothe numerous extras in period-specific undergarments for the sake of authenticity?
#30
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nashville, Tennessee
Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt
Are you sure you want to go with that definition? Because then you HAVE to put George Lucas on your list.
Again, are you sure?
Again, are you sure?

Guillermo Del Toro, as others have mentioned, is a perfect current example.
#31
DVD Talk Legend
I'd say George Luscas is more a visionary for ILM more than anything else, but certainly not as an overall director. Because of that, I wouldn't include his name on a list of "visionary directors".
#33
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 18,946
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
From: 75 clicks above the Do Lung bridge...
Tony Scott.
'True Romance' was a new kind of movie really, and I consider it the best film Tarantino was involved in, Tony made Tarantino's script into a great film. 'Man On Fire' was unlike anything before it. 'Domino' took it all the way.
I'm surprised no one mentioned him.
'True Romance' was a new kind of movie really, and I consider it the best film Tarantino was involved in, Tony made Tarantino's script into a great film. 'Man On Fire' was unlike anything before it. 'Domino' took it all the way.
I'm surprised no one mentioned him.
#34
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Dr Mabuse
Tony Scott.
'True Romance' was a new kind of movie really, and I consider it the best film Tarantino was involved in, Tony made Tarantino's script into a great film. 'Man On Fire' was unlike anything before it. 'Domino' took it all the way.
I'm surprised no one mentioned him.
'True Romance' was a new kind of movie really, and I consider it the best film Tarantino was involved in, Tony made Tarantino's script into a great film. 'Man On Fire' was unlike anything before it. 'Domino' took it all the way.
I'm surprised no one mentioned him.
#35
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Mar 1999
Posts: 2,147
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Seattle, WA
Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt
Are you sure you want to go with that definition? Because then you HAVE to put George Lucas on your list.
Again, are you sure?
Again, are you sure?

#36
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nashville, Tennessee
Originally Posted by valkyrie
Crap. You're right. Sigh...can I at least make it the "old" Lucas, and not the "I'll milk my trilogy for boatloads of cash and be a jerk in the process" Lucas of new?
#37
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by fumanstan
I noticed on the back of the Dark City Blu-ray it calls Alex Proyas one. And in the Watchmen trailer it calls Zach Snyder the "visionary director of 300." Seems like a label media slaps on anyone with a unique look or style. I'm pretty sure guys like Fincher and Guillermo Del Toro have been called that as well.
As far as living directors who could be called visionary, I'd have to go with Fincher, Lynch, Del Toro and Aronofsky.
#38
DVD Talk Legend
Joe Ripple
#43
DVD Talk Special Edition
This whole "visionary" craze is pretentious. I remember when the word "visionary" would be used to describe truly great men who were changing the world. I also remember when you would say in a trailer "from the director of..." and that would be enough.
I didn't even like 300, but I appreciate that any trailer that reads "from the director of 300" is already a hit. Snyder, Del Toro, and Alex Proyas are very good directors, but the ad guys need to cool it with the words, it's making me think these guys are pretentious fops. If no one ever slapped the word "visionary" on anything Spielberg or Scorcese did, maybe they should just leave that word alone.
I didn't even like 300, but I appreciate that any trailer that reads "from the director of 300" is already a hit. Snyder, Del Toro, and Alex Proyas are very good directors, but the ad guys need to cool it with the words, it's making me think these guys are pretentious fops. If no one ever slapped the word "visionary" on anything Spielberg or Scorcese did, maybe they should just leave that word alone.
#44
DVD Talk Legend
All mentioned before, but for my money:
Dreyer
Bresson
Tarr
Ozu
Godard
Eisenstein
Lynch
Marker
I'd also add Murnau, Bauer, Maddin, Bergman, Greenaway, Svankmajer, Lang, Melies and Starewicz.
Dreyer
Bresson
Tarr
Ozu
Godard
Eisenstein
Lynch
Marker
I'd also add Murnau, Bauer, Maddin, Bergman, Greenaway, Svankmajer, Lang, Melies and Starewicz.
#45
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by stonecountry
The only really decent big movie he ever directed was the first Star Wars though. THX-1138 is pretty decent for an indie arthouse film, even if it is somewhat pretentious. Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi weren't directed by Lucas.
#46
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,588
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nashville, Tennessee
Originally Posted by MinLShaw
I'm usually the first to mount an assault against the undeserved worshipping Lucas receives, but I can't find a thing wrong with American Graffiti. Great sense of pacing, while still telling a story that's identifiable and enjoyable (something he's forgotten about in recent years). And I've never seen another film that used its soundtrack half as well.




