OldBoy

so i have been watching bits and pieces of "Hairspray" (2007) on HBO for like 2 weeks now. i mean i really love everything about this movie and can't get enough.

it got me thinking of the original John Waters movie. i know it has quite a following as well and wondering if it might be worth picking up seeing as how much i love the remake.

is it as good? same catchy songs and wonderul performances? perhaps better? perhaps worse?

what is your take having seen both?

DeputyDave

Didn't like either. I'm actually a big musical fan and was expecting to like the 2007 version based on the buzz but I would rather watch an overweight trannie eat dog feces.

davidh777

Love the new one. Then saw the old one and didn't like it, but I'm not a Waters fan.

EdTheRipper

I've seen both and prefer the new version.

cranberries fan

I like them both I have the music video from the original John Waters movie that's not on the DvD and it's a blast.

RoboDad

Never liked the original, but love the new version (even bought it on Blu-ray, where the visuals really pop).

Giantrobo

BOTH are great films!

But I'll give the 2007 version a slight advantage.

Zen Peckinpah

Divine > John Travolta*

Saw part of the '07 version recently and I love the 1988 one, but I might watch this if only to see how it compares.

* - Divine is much more organic and realistic in the Edna role, and far funnier from what I've seen.

riley_dude

I feel the same. Loved the original John Waters movie and did see the play and even liked that but the movie was not very good, And Travolta brought it down a few notches for me. I thought he was horrible.

Giantrobo

Well Divine was doing what Divine did both in life and while performing. John Travolta, to the best of my knowledge, though I've heard rumors for years , was simply playing a role. If they had cast him as a pilot, I'm sure he would've rocked it.

I didn't like the weird voice Travolta chose, but overall he was ok in the role.

Zen Peckinpah

So true.

LiquidSky

The original is the best. The Broadway version is fun, though.

macnorton

I am a Waters fan and I have seen the original quite a few times. And HBO has been running the musical non-stop lately, which I have seen now 4 times.

But, I feel it is comparing apples and oranges. But the message that both have (similar, not the same) is fantastic.

However I am slightly inclined to choose the musical because the visuals are amazing and the songs are fantastic. I found myself getting sucked in each time I watched it...and that is what usually makes a good movie great.

Giles

that's what edged the remake over the original for me.

'Good morning Baltimoooooore'

macnorton

Yup, the songs won me over. The dance numbers that go with them are very good to, but the songs really do stand out. In fact I may buy the soundtrack...which I normally never do (sans scores, but that is a different animal).

OldBoy

i have the soundtrack and it is just as awesome as the movie. but, the visuals do make it come alive.

wait...wait...John Waters version is not a musical??? i think i maybe disappointed now.

Ginwen

It has lots of music (since it's about a dance show, they have to dance to something) but it is not a musical. The play is a musical based on the original movie, the new movie is based on the play.

I prefer the original, but the new one was ok.

OldBoy

wow! i really had no idea. and it's not even racy as John Waters goes given the PG rating. but still, i am going to get it just so i can compare. i was hoping this was an extension of the new one with musical #'s galore to enjoy as i just wanted more of the 2007, but it will be fun to compare and contrast nonetheless.

davidh777

That's a good point. All the songs ("Welcome to the '60s" etc.) were written for the Broadway stage version, which became the basis of the new movie.

dhmac

I like a lot of John Waters movies, but I think the original Hairspray is too much of a disjointed mess. More Divine in the movie would've helped, and I do think it has a great soundtrack of some early '60s gems. But I have no desire to sit through it again.

However, I think the musical Hairspray (which I've never seen on stage) is great! It really improved the structure of the storyline and the cast was pretty strong - even Travolta surprised me on how well he did in his role. (Contrast that to the original, where except for Divine, I thought the cast was pretty weak.)

So the musical version all the way for me!

Cool Ghoul

Love the John Waters film, hate the new one. Just a really terrible film. Besides the fact that the original is a great movie it has a killer soundtrack! Any movie that plays a Bunker Hill song is cool by me.

Giles

the movie 'musical' version improves on the Broadway version by deleting the whole prison scene which seems to go on forever - the movie I dare say is much better paced.

TomOpus

I liked the '88 version.

But I'm biased because I used to know one of the dancers that shows up at The Corny Collins Show. Look for the cute blonde in the blue dress with white poka dots. She was also a Baltimore Orioles ballgirl.

Okay, even without the bias, I still like John Waters' version. Less polished, more fun. And Travolta can't out-Divine Divine.

davidh777

I wasn't knocked out by Travolta but he was fine. He was a safe mainstream choice unlike Divine or Harvey Fierstein, and they could market the movie by making people feel nostalgic about Grease.

Giles

I love the songs from Grease, but the movie featuring actors who looked nothing like the teenagers they were supposed to be, really annoyed me