DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Predators in Predator 1 and 2 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/527501-predators-predator-1-2-a.html)

FRwL 03-16-08 08:41 PM

Predators in Predator 1 and 2
 
I always wondered about the differences between these two, The Predator from 1 seemed more of a hunter-type while the one from 2 was more of a warrior, but they showed qualities of both.

Predator 2 was obviously a young buck who brought all his cool gear with him, as opposed to the grizzled veteran who was "toughing it" in the original. Whattya think?

Nesbit 03-16-08 08:45 PM

Sounds about right to me.

thelwig14 03-16-08 09:08 PM


Originally Posted by FRwL
I always wondered about the differences between these two, The Predator from 1 seemed more of a hunter-type while the one from 2 was more of a warrior, but they showed qualities of both.

Predator 2 was obviously a young buck who brought all his cool gear with him, as opposed to the grizzled veteran who was "toughing it" in the original. Whattya think?


Agreed.

Predator 1=Kobe
Predator 2=LeBron

PopcornTreeCt 03-16-08 09:16 PM


Originally Posted by thelwig14
Agreed.

Predator 1=Kobe
Predator 2=LeBron

So, the predator from the sequel could take the first predator any day of the week? :)

thelwig14 03-16-08 09:22 PM


Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
So, the predator from the sequel could take the first predator any day of the week? :)


Hmmm, I thought I made it clear the first was far superior though the second could possibly get there....though it did struggle with Gary Busey and Danny Glover.

Predator 1=Peyton Manning
Predator 2=Eli

The Antipodean 03-16-08 09:42 PM


Originally Posted by thelwig14
Hmmm, I thought I made it clear the first was far superior though the second could possibly get there....though it did struggle with Gary Busey and Danny Glover.

To be fair, Gary Busey would give anybody a tough time.

I would kill to see a remake of Predator with Busey in the Schwarzenegger role.

UAIOE 03-17-08 04:18 AM

Going on tangent here:

I don't understand how a Alien born from a Predator (Predalien) can retain so many characteristics of a Predator, but aliens born from humans don't really have that much as far as human characteristics.

Giantrobo 03-17-08 06:58 AM


Originally Posted by FRwL
I always wondered about the differences between these two, The Predator from 1 seemed more of a hunter-type while the one from 2 was more of a warrior, but they showed qualities of both.

Predator 2 was obviously a young buck who brought all his cool gear with him, as opposed to the grizzled veteran who was "toughing it" in the original. Whattya think?


If I remember right that's pretty much how the film makers presented it. Pred 2 brought different items with him and he was younger than Pred 1.

Giantrobo 03-17-08 07:16 AM


Originally Posted by UAIOE
Going on tangent here:

I don't understand how a Alien born from a Predator (Predalien) can retain so many characteristics of a Predator, but aliens born from humans don't really have that much as far as human characteristics.

Yeah the designers of the Predalien in AVP2 went too far in the design. I've seen much better versions of PredAliens.

killershark 03-17-08 09:20 AM

IMO there hasn't been a decent Alien re design since the dog alien.

rennervision 03-17-08 01:44 PM

Predator 2 seemed smarter than Predator 1. While in hiding, he could apparently follow a police investigation even though English was not his native language. And he was so "street smart", he was always one step ahead of Danny Glover.

TylerDurden_73 03-17-08 01:57 PM

The Predator from the first one would have wiped the floor with Danny Glover. When I saw predator 2 at the movies, I kept waiting for Mel Gibson to come around the corner, like Murtaugh was having a bad dream. I think we learned watching predator 2 that Danny Glover is No Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Giantrobo 03-17-08 03:02 PM


Originally Posted by TylerDurden_73
The Predator from the first one would have wiped the floor with Danny Glover. When I saw predator 2 at the movies, I kept waiting for Mel Gibson to come around the corner, like Murtaugh was having a bad dream. I think we learned watching predator 2 that Danny Glover is No Arnold Schwarzenegger.

What?

Lt Ripley 03-17-08 04:31 PM


Originally Posted by UAIOE
Going on tangent here:

I don't understand how a Alien born from a Predator (Predalien) can retain so many characteristics of a Predator, but aliens born from humans don't really have that much as far as human characteristics.


Because the makers of AVP:R looked at the comic books instead of using their brains. Plus they also new that all the little kiddies would think it was KEWL!!!

Drop 03-17-08 05:57 PM


Originally Posted by TylerDurden_73
I think we learned watching predator 2 that Danny Glover is No Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Well he wasn't supposed to even be the Arnold type, and I'm glad they went in that direction, a straight remake was more likely with Arnold. I love both films, I hope one day they make another Predator film, without the aliens.

UAIOE 03-18-08 04:13 AM


Originally Posted by Lt Ripley
Because the makers of AVP:R looked at the comic books instead of using their brains. Plus they also new that all the little kiddies would think it was KEWL!!!

I ask because I've seen these thing mentioned, not because I've bothered with the AvP movies.

There was a PS2/XBOX game "Predator: Concrete Jungle" that wasn't as bad as I thought it was going to be with the Predator universe. Weyland-Yutani is mentioned in passing and there are aliens, but nobody knows them. It was cool to kill people Predator-style, but the levels were limited and there wasn't much replay value.

I think the most interesting idea someone had for a Predator-related storyline (which I believe was for a Duke3D total conversion) was someone time traveling to the 1600-1700's to fight a Predator but be limited to weapons of that era (until later in the game when futuristic weapons would be "sent back").

The idea is less interesting about the time travel aspect and more interesting in the idea of trying to fight the Predator with weapons less sophisticated than modern weapons, even thought the modern guns pretty much useless against him anyway.

lotsofdvds 03-18-08 08:41 AM


Originally Posted by TylerDurden_73
The Predator from the first one would have wiped the floor with Danny Glover. When I saw predator 2 at the movies, I kept waiting for Mel Gibson to come around the corner, like Murtaugh was having a bad dream. I think we learned watching predator 2 that Danny Glover is No Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Danny Glover was a last minute replacement for Patrick Swayze.

whoopdido 03-18-08 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by Drop
Well he wasn't supposed to even be the Arnold type, and I'm glad they went in that direction, a straight remake was more likely with Arnold. I love both films, I hope one day they make another Predator film, without the aliens.

Right, Danny Glover was just a cop. He may have been a really good cop, but he was still just a cop.

Arnold was a highly trained covert military guy. I guess I don't know exactly what outfit those guys were--maybe Delta Force, but I have no idea.

Anyway, his team were as tough as could be and he was the toughest of them all and even he almost got dusted by the Predator, so yeah it shouldn't be a knock on Danny Glover that Glover couldn't have taken the first Predator.

islandclaws 03-18-08 11:56 AM

I think the most bad ass Predator to date might the The Wolf from AVP:R. Sure, the movie was shit but that guy was the Winston Wolf of the series. He came and kicked ass while cleaning up his shit. It's a toss up between that one and the hunter from P1.

This flow chart should help:

Arnold > The Wolf > (or =) P1 > Danny Glover > P2 > Gary Busey

FRwL 03-25-08 01:29 AM


Originally Posted by KillerCannibal

Arnold > The Wolf > (or =) P1 > Danny Glover > P2 > Gary Busey

Bill Paxton > the rest.

He took on an Alien, Predator, Terminator and even though lost he gained varied experience.

Giantrobo 03-25-08 02:20 AM


Originally Posted by FRwL
Bill Paxton > the rest.

He took on an Alien, Predator, Terminator and even though lost he gained varied experience.

So did Lance Henriksen

EDIT: Slight advantage to Lance because he "took on" a Queen no less.

UAIOE 03-25-08 03:42 AM

I forgot Lance was in one of the newer movies.

Lance is cool and all, but I don't count the AVP movies or the last two "Alien" movies.

Giantrobo 03-25-08 04:28 AM


Originally Posted by UAIOE
I forgot Lance was in one of the newer movies.

Lance is cool and all, but I don't count the AVP movies or the last two "Alien" movies.


:lol: I hear you but your personal tastes aside, they still count. :lol:

dugan 03-25-08 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by FRwL
Bill Paxton > the rest.

He took on an Alien, Predator, Terminator and even though lost he gained varied experience.

The tagline I've seen points out that Bill Paxton is the only guy to have been KILLED BY an Alien, a Predator and a Terminator.

I would add that he was the only VAMPIRE to have been killed by an Alien, a Predator and a Terminator.

candyrocket786 03-25-08 09:55 AM


Originally Posted by KillerCannibal
I think the most bad ass Predator to date might the The Wolf from AVP:R. Sure, the movie was shit but that guy was the Winston Wolf of the series. He came and kicked ass while cleaning up his shit. It's a toss up between that one and the hunter from P1.

This flow chart should help:

Arnold > The Wolf > (or =) P1 > Danny Glover > P2 > Gary Busey


:up: AVR:R Predator.

Complete Ultimate Badass.

Giantrobo 03-25-08 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by dugan
The tagline I've seen points out that Bill Paxton is the only guy to have been KILLED BY an Alien, a Predator and a Terminator.

I would add that he was the only VAMPIRE to have been killed by an Alien, a Predator and a Terminator.

So has Lance. Wasn't he one of the Vamps in Near Dark?

Terminator 1(Police station) Aliens(Killed by A Queen**), AVP (killed by a Predator)

:p AND since we're talking Vamps....Vasquez(Jenette Goldstein)...was also in Near Dark with Lance and Bill and although she wasn't killed by an Alien, she died trying to get away from them(suicide explosion in the vent). Hell she's probably the only Vamp to go down on The Titanic(Irish Mother with kids). :lol: Don't forget Paxton was in Titanic too.



**I guess one could argue that he wasn't really "killed" since he was an Android and he was revived for a short time by Ripley in Alien3. Wait...hang on....Lance has been killed by an Alien, a Predator, a Terminator AND...A Ripley. :lol:

FRwL 03-25-08 05:00 PM

Ok so the ultimate showdown would be Bill Paxton vs. Lance Henriksen. Match of the titans!

MasteroDisaster 03-25-08 05:57 PM

If I had to choose the biggest bad-ass, I'm giving it to the Predator in AVP:R. Young Predator in Predator 2 couldn't even kill Danny Glover... In AVP:R, the Predator took down humans AND Aliens AND the Predalien! That is the very definition of bad-assery!

Plus you got to see him living on the Predator homeworld in AVP:R; that's just bonus points, in my book... :eyebrow:

UAIOE 03-25-08 11:23 PM


Originally Posted by Giantrobo
**I guess one could argue that he wasn't really "killed" since he was an Android and he was revived for a short time by Ripley in Alien3. Wait...hang on....Lance has been killed by an Alien, a Predator, a Terminator AND...A Ripley. :lol:

My interpretation of Bishop at the end of "Aliens" was that he was damaged but still "alive". The crash in (that dream sequence that is commonly called) "Alien 3" is what finally did him in.

I still think Bill Paxton is the winner as he was killed by Aliens, Predators, Terminators...and the killer combo of Pat Benatar and Judge Reinhold!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66aqcOsnP2E

In related Bill Paxton news: Bill Paxton and Bill Pullman were in a movie together...actually in the same scene!

Giantrobo 03-26-08 12:18 AM


Originally Posted by UAIOE
My interpretation of Bishop at the end of "Aliens" was that he was damaged but still "alive". The crash in (that dream sequence that is commonly called) "Alien 3" is what finally did him in.

I still think Bill Paxton is the winner as he was killed by Aliens, Predators, Terminators...and the killer combo of Pat Benatar and Judge Reinhold!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66aqcOsnP2E

In related Bill Paxton news: Bill Paxton and Bill Pullman were in a movie together...actually in the same scene!

You're right. He was cut in half but not dead and was even able to catch Newt when Ripley opened the bay doors to outer space. In Alien 3, the prisoners assumed he was trashed since he was such bad shape and threw him into the garbage bin.

MasteroDisaster 03-26-08 02:21 PM


Originally Posted by UAIOE
My interpretation of Bishop at the end of "Aliens" was that he was damaged but still "alive". The crash in (that dream sequence that is commonly called) "Alien 3" is what finally did him in.

I still think Bill Paxton is the winner as he was killed by Aliens, Predators, Terminators...and the killer combo of Pat Benatar and Judge Reinhold!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66aqcOsnP2E

In related Bill Paxton news: Bill Paxton and Bill Pullman were in a movie together...actually in the same scene!

Ok, I'm officially petitioning for it - I wanna see the Predalien from AVP:R kill Bill Paxton in AVP3! He can continue his streak of being killed by cool aliens! Better yet, have the Predalien kill both Bill Paxton AND Bill Pullman - 2 for 1!

I also think they should have Bill Paxton do a commentary on the AVP:R DVD coming out next month... even though he's not in the movie. It would be hilarious - he could just sit there and every time an Alien or the Predator comes on the screen, he could reminisce about all the times he's been killed... :D

Kudama 03-26-08 03:17 PM


Originally Posted by FRwL
Ok so the ultimate showdown would be Bill Paxton vs. Lance Henriksen. Match of the titans!

Lance would win. In addition to Bill's rogues gallery, Lance has taken on Pumkinhead and Jean Claude Van Damme.

bhk 03-26-08 03:32 PM

As others have pointed out, the Predator in the first movie, took out a group of Green Beret's, and all but one of Arnold's team. The one in AVP requiem didn't seem as smart as the one in the first movie.

UAIOE 03-26-08 11:02 PM

I think that most "Predator" stories nowadays have easier to kill Predators.


Originally Posted by MasteroDisaster
Ok, I'm officially petitioning for it - I wanna see the Predalien from AVP:R kill Bill Paxton in AVP3! He can continue his streak of being killed by cool aliens! Better yet, have the Predalien kill both Bill Paxton AND Bill Pullman - 2 for 1!

I also think they should have Bill Paxton do a commentary on the AVP:R DVD coming out next month... even though he's not in the movie. It would be hilarious - he could just sit there and every time an Alien or the Predator comes on the screen, he could reminisce about all the times he's been killed... :D

To truly be ultimate, it should be Bill Paxton vs. Bill Paxton in a movie. Then he can discuss all the things that have killed him, including himself, then talk about turning into that thing in "Weird Science".


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:51 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.