DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/526686-wrestler-d-daron-aronofsky-w-mickey-rourke.html)

OldBoy 05-03-09 11:26 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by Groucho (Post 9422635)
Very good film. I could have done without the

Spoiler:
"Sopranos" approach to the ending


But that's a minor quibble.

there was no "The Sopranos" ending in anyway. i don't understand why, now, because we don't have a definitive happy or sad ending and is somewhat ambiguous that we equate it to bad or lazy film making or "Made in America" which was still an excellent series finale. many movies prior have gone this route, many.

dpz301 05-03-09 03:29 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
just watched this since it was a rain day here. really enjoyed it. in reference to the end, i kind of expected, but i did still like it. very good movie all around, IMO. and marisa tomei looked great as i am sure others have said. :up: :up:

fumanstan 05-03-09 03:51 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9422683)
there was no "The Sopranos" ending in anyway. i don't understand why, now, because we don't have a definitive happy or sad ending and is somewhat ambiguous that we equate it to bad or lazy film making or "Made in America" which was still an excellent series finale. many movies prior have gone this route, many.

That doesn't mean everyone has to like it.

mickey65 05-03-09 08:05 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
Well, it was obvious what was going on during that last fight...

****SPOILER***


The "ringing" noises - which happened during his first heart attack. He knew he was going to die and went out doing what he loved. He had no one. His daughter told him to fuck off, his (supposed) girlfriend (altho she really never was) walking out like that - after telling him to fuck off also. He just said "fuck it" - knowing if he fought again, it would kill him.

I thought it was pretty good movie too. Altho I'm not a wrestling fan and didn't realize they beat each other bloody like that with barbed wire and glass in the fights.

I guess I'm just used to "old school" wrestling where they just pin each other to the mat to win.

benh911 05-03-09 10:30 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
Mickey65,

Spoiler:
I wouldn't say she told him to fuck off. She said, "I'm really here", and if anything, he more or less told her to fuck off, choosing wrestling over her. I think she just walked away because she couldn't stand to see him do what he was about to do.

Jack Straw 05-03-09 11:08 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
I watched this (1st time) with my gf and overall thought it was an okay movie. I was pretty shocked at how graphic the wrestling scenes were. The other thing was that I was just taken aback at how different Rourke's look had changed (not in a good way). I also didn't feel that this character was a big acting stretch for him based on his real life experience. That being said, I definitely felt the acting was good, and seeing Tomei dancing topless was a huge plus. I think I may appreciate this movie more on a 2nd viewing.

arminius 05-04-09 10:02 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by benh911 (Post 9423452)
Mickey65,

Spoiler:
I wouldn't say she told him to fuck off. She said, "I'm really here", and if anything, he more or less told her to fuck off, choosing wrestling over her. I think she just walked away because she couldn't stand to see him do what he was about to do.

I agree with this but.
Spoiler:
He was a dead man climbing the ropes. Like the poster above says, he was feeling all the stuff like in his heart attack. He just kept pushing to go out literally on top.


Graet great movie.

OldBoy 05-04-09 10:05 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by benh911 (Post 9423452)
Mickey65,

Spoiler:
I wouldn't say she told him to fuck off. She said, "I'm really here", and if anything, he more or less told her to fuck off, choosing wrestling over her. I think she just walked away because she couldn't stand to see him do what he was about to do.

that is how i read it. he might have wished he could have both, but he had to go with his true love in the end.

sauce07 05-04-09 01:17 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9423983)
that is how i read it. he might have wished he could have both, but he had to go with his true love in the end.

Same. Most people i've talked to see it this way as well.

jeffbase34 05-04-09 01:26 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by mickey65 (Post 9423275)
Well, it was obvious what was going on during that last fight...

****SPOILER***


The "ringing" noises - which happened during his first heart attack. He knew he was going to die and went out doing what he loved. He had no one. His daughter told him to fuck off, his (supposed) girlfriend (altho she really never was) walking out like that - after telling him to fuck off also. He just said "fuck it" - knowing if he fought again, it would kill him.

I thought it was pretty good movie too. Altho I'm not a wrestling fan and didn't realize they beat each other bloody like that with barbed wire and glass in the fights.

I guess I'm just used to "old school" wrestling where they just pin each other to the mat to win.


One technique that the movie showed was blading. A lot of people don't know about blading. The wrestler will hide a razor blade and then cut their forehead to make themselves look beaten bloody. It's a dangerous practice as some wrestlers have cut too deep, and it leaves scars.

I get very annoyed when people say wrestling is fake. Yeah, the outcomes are predetermined, but the pain is real, and these people do it because they love it even though they are wrecking their bodies. The Wrestler reminded me a lot of Jake the Snake Roberts, once a huge star, now hooked on drugs and doing backwater wrestling shows. Wrestling was the only place where he felt like he had a family.

Real life wrestlers like Roddy Piper were moved to tears by this realistic film.

OldBoy 05-04-09 04:39 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by jeffbase34 (Post 9424423)
One technique that the movie showed was blading. A lot of people don't know about blading. The wrestler will hide a razor blade and then cut their forehead to make themselves look beaten bloody. It's a dangerous practice as some wrestlers have cut too deep, and it leaves scars.

I get very annoyed when people say wrestling is fake. Yeah, the outcomes are predetermined, but the pain is real, and these people do it because they love it even though they are wrecking their bodies. The Wrestler reminded me a lot of Jake the Snake Roberts, once a huge star, now hooked on drugs and doing backwater wrestling shows. Wrestling was the only place where he felt like he had a family.

Real life wrestlers like Roddy Piper were moved to tears by this realistic film.

well, you can't really call it a sport if outcomes are predetermined. sure they take abuse and some injuries are quite real, but "The Wrestler" certainly proved it is for the most part fake. it is merely entertainment, a staged production in every sense of the word. matches are indeed real if you think in terms that they are fictional plays, but the last time i checked fiction = not reality.

fumanstan 05-04-09 04:59 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
Personally, I think "fake" is just an inaccurate word to use to describe it. Pro Wrestling is what it is, and pre-determined outcomes are a part of it and that aspect of it isn't a secret (anymore, at least), nor does anyone even argue that it's a sport. It would be akin to describing any other TV show as being fake because the people on there aren't real doctors or cops.

jeffbase34 05-05-09 07:49 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9424816)
well, you can't really call it a sport if outcomes are predetermined. sure they take abuse and some injuries are quite real, but "The Wrestler" certainly proved it is for the most part fake. it is merely entertainment, a staged production in every sense of the word. matches are indeed real if you think in terms that they are fictional plays, but the last time i checked fiction = not reality.

It is a sport in the sense that these wrestlers have to be in amazing physical shape to pull off their stunts, and it requires a lot of training and pain endurance. Honestly, there is no way wrestling could not be predetermined. Guys would get killed in the ring.

The wrestlers have to protect each other to a certain degree. Several years ago, D Lo Brown botched a tombstone move and he broke the neck of Droz who is paralyzed for life.

I guess where the line gets blurry for me is when wrestlers feel like they accomplished something by winning belts and getting inducted into the hall of fame.

Goat3001 05-05-09 08:45 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by fumanstan (Post 9424859)
Personally, I think "fake" is just an inaccurate word to use to describe it. Pro Wrestling is what it is, and pre-determined outcomes are a part of it and that aspect of it isn't a secret (anymore, at least), nor does anyone even argue that it's a sport. It would be akin to describing any other TV show as being fake because the people on there aren't real doctors or cops.

Exactly. This discussion comes up every so often and it's always the same. Everyone agrees on the important things: The outcome is predetermined, that these guys work their asses off in the ring and in the gym and while they do their best to protect themselves and their partner they're still getting banged up doing so.

Then the rest of the discussion is simply if the word "fake" applies. But as you said, pro-wrestling just is what it is.

OldBoy 05-05-09 11:47 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by jeffbase34 (Post 9425613)
It is a sport in the sense that these wrestlers have to be in amazing physical shape to pull off their stunts, and it requires a lot of training and pain endurance.

you can make up your own definition of "sport", i guess. but in no way is "pro wrestling" recognized as a legitimate sport lumped in with the basketballs, footballs, baseballs, tennis, etc... i do agree that "fake" would be inaccurate as fuman pointed out.

jeffbase34 05-05-09 01:13 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9426029)
you can make up your own definition of "sport", i guess. but in no way is "pro wrestling" recognized as a legitimate sport lumped in with the basketballs, footballs, baseballs, tennis, etc... i do agree that "fake" would be inaccurate as fuman pointed out.

Ugh, your avatar always gives me a headache lol

CaptainMarvel 05-05-09 01:24 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9426029)
you can make up your own definition of "sport", i guess. but in no way is "pro wrestling" recognized as a legitimate sport lumped in with the basketballs, footballs, baseballs, tennis, etc... i do agree that "fake" would be inaccurate as fuman pointed out.

I wouldn't call it a competitive sport, but I would definitely consider it sport, in much the same way that I would consider exhibition (non-competitive) figure skating a sport.

arminius 05-05-09 03:28 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by CaptainMarvel (Post 9426262)
I wouldn't call it a competitive sport, but I would definitely consider it sport, in much the same way that I would consider exhibition (non-competitive) figure skating a sport.

Do you like gladiator movies?

Solid Snake 05-05-09 04:51 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
I don't consider Wrestling a sport. It's entertainment at it's basis of existing. I don't count Nascar as a sport either, though I respect the endurance of driving fast but...uhm...you're sitting down the whole time going in a circle or oval.

wirefan 05-06-09 07:05 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by scott1598 (Post 9424816)
well, you can't really call it a sport if outcomes are predetermined. sure they take abuse and some injuries are quite real, but "The Wrestler" certainly proved it is for the most part fake. it is merely entertainment, a staged production in every sense of the word. matches are indeed real if you think in terms that they are fictional plays, but the last time i checked fiction = not reality.

I'm sorry, a movie was 'the proof' that wrestling is fake? Couple things:
1) Movies aren't real, I would not use a work of fiction as proof of anything.To use your own words "the last time I checked fiction = not reality"... I guess unless you are using fiction to disprove other fiction? :) Do you not see the irony in your statement above? If not, let me spell it out - The Wrestler is also a staged production!
2) Did you not realize what wrestling is before you saw this movie? :)

RagingBull80 05-06-09 07:51 PM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by jeffbase34 (Post 9424423)
I get very annoyed when people say wrestling is fake.

Wrestling is fake. Now, the pain that these guys feel is very real. Yes, they work very hard at it and it's very dangerous but it's still fake. I just can't see how something that's essentially choreographed isn't fake.

Wrestling is pretty much ballet.

Tarantino 05-07-09 12:25 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by RagingBull80 (Post 9429205)
Wrestling is fake. Now, the pain that these guys feel is very real. Yes, they work very hard at it and it's very dangerous but it's still fake. I just can't see how something that's essentially choreographed isn't fake.

Wrestling is pretty much ballet.

It's a "show". It's not fake. It's a show. If you go in thinking that these guys really want to kill each other, I guess I can see how you would consider it fake after finding out they probably hang out after the show for the first time. But realize that it's just entertainment, it's a show that they put on for the audience.

Would you call a ballet "fake"?

= J

jeffbase34 05-07-09 08:23 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 

Originally Posted by Tarantino (Post 9429657)
It's a "show". It's not fake. It's a show. If you go in thinking that these guys really want to kill each other, I guess I can see how you would consider it fake after finding out they probably hang out after the show for the first time. But realize that it's just entertainment, it's a show that they put on for the audience.

Would you call a ballet "fake"?

= J


Wrestling was very popular in the 90s though because the storylines blurred reality with fiction. For example when paramedics came out and carried an injured wrestler off, was this fake or real? When Owen Hart fell from the rafters to his death, many people in the audience that it was part of the show.

The Montreal Screwjob with Bret Hart was mostly real. Mick Foley and Ric Flair had a real life feud.

Wrestling is perhaps the most dangerous sport of them all. So many wrestlers including Edge and Stone Cold have suffered broken necks. Hogan limps around with an artificial hip, and Shawn Michaels still manages to wrestle despite having several herniated discs in his back. I really don't see how these guys do it.

RichC2 05-07-09 08:26 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
Pro-Wrestling is fake refers to its status as a competitive sport. The competition aspect is non-existent, the match winners are pre-decided, it's a soap opera for guys. As such, yes, it's fake and scripted.

Doesn't mean people aren't getting injured.

Tarantino 05-07-09 10:41 AM

Re: 'The Wrestler' D:Daron Aronofsky, w/Mickey Rourke
 
I believe most here are in agreement that it is not a sport, but rather an entertainment show.

= J


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:15 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.