One and Only CLOVERFIELD reviews thread!
#201
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Seeing a movie like this is like Christmas. You wait so long for it, and then as soon as it begins it's over and you're left feeling like "well, that was that."
I fear the same thing will happen for me with The Dark Knight.
The anticipation almost prevents me from liking a movie as much as I should. I should be going apeshit for Cloverfield, and I almost feel bad that I'm not.
I fear the same thing will happen for me with The Dark Knight.
The anticipation almost prevents me from liking a movie as much as I should. I should be going apeshit for Cloverfield, and I almost feel bad that I'm not.
#202
Member
How old are you people on this board? Seriously, the last time I was "excited" about a movie was when I was in high school, maybe. I guess I'm just immune to hype.
#203
DVD Talk Legend
Liked this much more than I thought... Sure you need to let a lot of things go, but a movie with a big monster, thats to be expected. Really the worst part was the audience. High school girls and boys and senior citizens shouldnt really be allowed anywhere near a theatre these days, but I guess I should have been ready for it. Anyways, pretty good action and intense scenes at times. If you can forgive a lot and you're not a new yorker who is going to get upset by the rapid pace at which these people seem to be able to traverse the city in (plus great cell reception in the subway station) pretty enjoyable Saturday matinee movie.
#204
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,732
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
5 Posts
From: A sweaty sauna somewhere in Japan
i just saw it. This movie is going to sweep the Razzies, for a monster with less than one minute of screen time in a 90 minute movie. This movie is a BOMB of Battlefield Earth proportions.
#205
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by Brack
How old are you people on this board? Seriously, the last time I was "excited" about a movie was when I was in high school, maybe. I guess I'm just immune to hype.
Why would you see a movie if you're not excited to see it? I can't understand why someone would spend their precious time and hard earned money on something that doesn't excite them. Maybe there are better entertainment options for you than movies?
27, btw.
#206
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 1,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Some of it was very cool and game like, but overall the characters sucked and acted dumb, they wore too much make-up for DV and were too 'pretty', the insects were contrived, all three of them stepped out of a helecopter crash pretty easily, and the ending was a cliche. I'd probably go 2 out of 5 for its modern attempt at the genre, but it is still very much in the genre.
On another note, I was initially impressed at the willingness of the filmmakers to make it so ambiguous, such as the monster's origins... But then I read some interviews and they explained in detail everything that should've been left to the imagination. Dumb hollywood.
And the title is a new marketing low as well, a title about how the title has nothing to do with the film... except to have people asking what it means, and creating more hype. This whole thing is a very shallow way of mixing business and art, but in the end as I said it's just a genre pic.
On another note, I was initially impressed at the willingness of the filmmakers to make it so ambiguous, such as the monster's origins... But then I read some interviews and they explained in detail everything that should've been left to the imagination. Dumb hollywood.
And the title is a new marketing low as well, a title about how the title has nothing to do with the film... except to have people asking what it means, and creating more hype. This whole thing is a very shallow way of mixing business and art, but in the end as I said it's just a genre pic.
#207
Originally Posted by E. Honda
i just saw it. This movie is going to sweep the Razzies, for a monster with less than one minute of screen time in a 90 minute movie. This movie is a BOMB of Battlefield Earth proportions.
let's see....
Battlefield Earth 3%
Cloverfield 76%
Last edited by covenant; 01-19-08 at 05:50 PM.
#208
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I liked it. At first the "Blair Witch" style kinda bugged me, but by the end I had gotten used to it and thought it was a pretty neat way of showing the chaos and confusion going on. It was pretty neat that the characters and the audience had the exact same level of knowledge...which was zero. Nobody in the movie had any idea what was going on and neither did the audience.
I've heard a couple people complain about the ending and how it was predictable and cliche. Well, first of all you should have been able to figure out how the movie was going to end 30 seconds after the movie started simply by reading the screen.
Secondly,
I've heard a couple people complain about the ending and how it was predictable and cliche. Well, first of all you should have been able to figure out how the movie was going to end 30 seconds after the movie started simply by reading the screen.
Secondly,
Spoiler:
#209
DVD Talk Legend
LOVED it!
This is definately one of those movies I'll always wish I could experience again for the first time.
I've heard a couple people complain about the ending and how it was predictable and cliche. Well, first of all you should have been able to figure out how the movie was going to end 30 seconds after the movie started simply by reading the screen.
Exactly.
This is definately one of those movies I'll always wish I could experience again for the first time.
Originally Posted by whoopdido
I've heard a couple people complain about the ending and how it was predictable and cliche. Well, first of all you should have been able to figure out how the movie was going to end 30 seconds after the movie started simply by reading the screen.
#210
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by whoopdido
I've heard a couple people complain about the ending and how it was predictable and cliche. Well, first of all you should have been able to figure out how the movie was going to end 30 seconds after the movie started simply by reading the screen.
I would also be a little pissed at the liquor store they bought their booze from. That was the most sober I've seen anyone at a party with a free bar.
#211
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 5,512
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I enjoyed it, but felt like it was channeling Blair Witch way too much. I almost expected them to say "F***!!!, we're lost. F***!!!, where are we? F***!!!, where are we going?"
And the ending...
And the ending...
Spoiler:
#212
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,191
Received 1,735 Likes
on
1,422 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Originally Posted by E. Honda
i just saw it. This movie is going to sweep the Razzies, for a monster with less than one minute of screen time in a 90 minute movie. This movie is a BOMB of Battlefield Earth proportions.
considering this was made for around $30 mil and will make almost double that this weekend alone, i would hazard a guess and say it will be anything but a "BOMB of Battlefield Earth proportions".
#213
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by scott1598
i didn't hate it, but i didn't love it. the people at the party must have been the prettiest people at any party anywhere ever. i really didn't get into the characters at all and the rob/beth relationship was unneccesary. also, how the hell could Lily go through the whole movie, running as she did, climbing, etc... in high heels????
i didn't mind the camera work and it worked pretty well. the monster and its' off shoots were pretty cool. as i said i didn't hate it, but it could have been a lot better. really no desire to see this one again anytime soon.
i didn't mind the camera work and it worked pretty well. the monster and its' off shoots were pretty cool. as i said i didn't hate it, but it could have been a lot better. really no desire to see this one again anytime soon.
#214
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by scott1598
wow! such amazing insight from someone who seems to know...oh, so little.
considering this was made for around $30 mil and will make almost double that this weekend alone, i would hazard a guess and say it will be anything but a "BOMB of Battlefield Earth proportions".
considering this was made for around $30 mil and will make almost double that this weekend alone, i would hazard a guess and say it will be anything but a "BOMB of Battlefield Earth proportions".
#215
Member
Originally Posted by JTH182
Why would you see a movie if you're not excited to see it? I can't understand why someone would spend their precious time and hard earned money on something that doesn't excite them. Maybe there are better entertainment options for you than movies?
27, btw.
27, btw.
#216
Senior Member
I liked it but it could have been better, I wouldn't rank it higher than The Host but it was better than Godzilla Final Wars and some of the other recent Godzilla movies. My biggest gripe was the lice creatures, it just seems like I've seen that so many times before...
I would have rather seen more of them dealing with getting through the destruction and the city crumbling around them than fighting off those little beasties with crowbars and axes.
Spoiler:
#217
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by Brack
Don't get me wrong, movies excite me, but I don't get excited to see them. I look forward to them if I see a decent trailer and knowing who's involved, and/or see there are positive reviews, but until the actual date I end up seeing it I really don't think about them that much.
Well fair enough, but I guess you'd have to expect on a movie-lover's website you'd find a lot of people who actually get excited for movies
Last edited by JTH182; 01-19-08 at 06:53 PM.
#218
DVD Talk Gold Edition
A lot of mentions have been made about this movie seeming to attract rowdy teenagers. I'm a little curious as to who you had expected to be at a movie like this? Shit, what mainstream movie nowadays doesn't attract said teenagers?
We had some rowdies in the audience last night, mohawks, piercings and all. Before the movie began, they were loud and extremely rude, letting the gay slurs and expletives flow from their mouths with absolutely no regard. However, I guess we were lucky, because once the movie started they shut right the fuck up and didn't make a peep until the end credits.
We had some rowdies in the audience last night, mohawks, piercings and all. Before the movie began, they were loud and extremely rude, letting the gay slurs and expletives flow from their mouths with absolutely no regard. However, I guess we were lucky, because once the movie started they shut right the fuck up and didn't make a peep until the end credits.
#219
Member
Yeah, well, that's why I almost NEVER go to a movie at night. It costs more and there's more stupid people.
#220
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 5,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Export, PA
Originally Posted by Brack
How old are you people on this board? Seriously, the last time I was "excited" about a movie was when I was in high school, maybe. I guess I'm just immune to hype.
I wanted to chime in on this gem of a comment. I'm 30 and for some of the bigger movies I see each year I get so excited that I will actually be sick to my stomach the night before the movie. It's a weird quirk and far from normal but my friends always know how excited I am about a movie by how truly awful I feel the night before the film opens. I think in a time where the world is just falling to hell around us it's nice to get excited about things. I kinda wish I didn't get sick but it's great to look forward to stuff. I know folks complained about the new Star Trek teaser but it gave me chills and even after that simple teaser I have to say I'm excited.
#221
saw it today and really enjoyed it.
if they make a sequel i think it would be cool to just show someone else's tape and be able to watch the exact same events unfold from someone else's perspective and location.
a lot of different things were going on all at once throughout the city and we only saw a small part of it.
basically a parallel story. kinda like half-life 1 and half-life: opposing force and half-life: blue shift.
if they make a sequel i think it would be cool to just show someone else's tape and be able to watch the exact same events unfold from someone else's perspective and location.
a lot of different things were going on all at once throughout the city and we only saw a small part of it.
basically a parallel story. kinda like half-life 1 and half-life: opposing force and half-life: blue shift.
Last edited by Rubix; 01-19-08 at 07:47 PM.
#222
DVD Talk Limited Edition
LOVED IT. I've been dying to see this since I first saw the teaser trailer last summer, and it lived up to my expectations 100%. I'd really like to go see it once again at a theater, since I'm not sure DVD is going to be able to capture the same atmosphere that the giant screen and huge thumping sound of the theater had (unless you have a seriously kick ass home theater that is). The chaos was magic. Wow.
A!
A!
#223
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by lopper
A lot of mentions have been made about this movie seeming to attract rowdy teenagers. I'm a little curious as to who you had expected to be at a movie like this? Shit, what mainstream movie nowadays doesn't attract said teenagers?
We had some rowdies in the audience last night, mohawks, piercings and all. Before the movie began, they were loud and extremely rude, letting the gay slurs and expletives flow from their mouths with absolutely no regard. However, I guess we were lucky, because once the movie started they shut right the fuck up and didn't make a peep until the end credits.
We had some rowdies in the audience last night, mohawks, piercings and all. Before the movie began, they were loud and extremely rude, letting the gay slurs and expletives flow from their mouths with absolutely no regard. However, I guess we were lucky, because once the movie started they shut right the fuck up and didn't make a peep until the end credits.
#224
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 986
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Harbor City, CA USA
Originally Posted by CloverClover
And the title is a new marketing low as well, a title about how the title has nothing to do with the film...
#225
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by lopper
A lot of mentions have been made about this movie seeming to attract rowdy teenagers. I'm a little curious as to who you had expected to be at a movie like this? Shit, what mainstream movie nowadays doesn't attract said teenagers?
We had some rowdies in the audience last night, mohawks, piercings and all. Before the movie began, they were loud and extremely rude, letting the gay slurs and expletives flow from their mouths with absolutely no regard. However, I guess we were lucky, because once the movie started they shut right the fuck up and didn't make a peep until the end credits.
We had some rowdies in the audience last night, mohawks, piercings and all. Before the movie began, they were loud and extremely rude, letting the gay slurs and expletives flow from their mouths with absolutely no regard. However, I guess we were lucky, because once the movie started they shut right the fuck up and didn't make a peep until the end credits.



