Notes on a Scandal - quick review
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Notes on a Scandal - quick review
An older, lonely, high school teacher, Barbara Covett (Judi Dench), befriends a new teacher, Sheba Hart (Cate Blanchette), who is married with children. Barbara lives up to her last name. Before you know it, Barbara becomes a confidant of Sheba's, but Sheba has her own scandalous dalliance with a 15 year old at school, and Barbara uses this information to keep Sheba in her good graces for as long as it was tenable.
It sounds like one of those Lifetime movie of the week, and frankly, it ends up like one of them as well, but the performances by Dench and Blanchette elevate the material, which has a few dark laughs at the predicament the characters find themselves in the last act. Dench earns her Best Actress nomination, but Blanchette's character is slightly underwritten, but she does get to light up the screen in the last act of the film. Bill Nighy (playing Sheba's much older husband) also cracked me up in a couple of scenes as things spiral out of control for Sheba with Barbara's persistent presence in their lives.
I give it 3 stars, or a grade of B (mainly for the acting performances, not the story).
(Corrected Nighy's name)
It sounds like one of those Lifetime movie of the week, and frankly, it ends up like one of them as well, but the performances by Dench and Blanchette elevate the material, which has a few dark laughs at the predicament the characters find themselves in the last act. Dench earns her Best Actress nomination, but Blanchette's character is slightly underwritten, but she does get to light up the screen in the last act of the film. Bill Nighy (playing Sheba's much older husband) also cracked me up in a couple of scenes as things spiral out of control for Sheba with Barbara's persistent presence in their lives.
I give it 3 stars, or a grade of B (mainly for the acting performances, not the story).
(Corrected Nighy's name)
Last edited by Patman; 01-28-07 at 09:12 AM.
#2
Member
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 237
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Columbus, OH
Originally Posted by Patman
Bill Nye (playing Sheba's much older husband) also cracked me up in a couple of scenes as things spiral out of control for Sheba with Barbara's persistent presences in their lives.
Though I imagine the Science Guy would have been interesting as well.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Just got around to seeing this, and really enjoyed it. The two main performances were fantastic, and definitely worthy of the Oscar nominations that they garnered. Although the plot was rather predictable, I would rank this movie ahead of some of the pictures that got nominated for Best Picture.
#6
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,981
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Berkeley, CA
Notes On A Scandal (**/*****). Terrific, terrific performances and a mostly sharp screenplay can't make up for the implosion of the plot at the end. Aside from the acting -- Blanchett's exceptionally nuanced and subtle (bar one major, bone-shattering outburst) Sheba and Dench's calculating, cold and creepy sexual predator -- the film did nothing for me except trap me in 90 minutes of moral discomfort. Maybe I expected to like the film too much, given Blanchett is probably my favourite actress; or at least one of them. But it's hard to like or enjoy a film that makes you so uneasy and offers such a bleak view into solitary life and how it can twist people.




