DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Dakota Fanning Rape Scene (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/472519-dakota-fanning-rape-scene.html)

Identify 07-24-06 03:23 PM

Dakota Fanning Rape Scene
 
Dakota does disturbing role

(KP International) Hounddog sounds like an innocent enough title but apparently the film shows 12-year-old Dakota Fanning in her most disturbing role yet.

The dark film features such themes as violence, abuse and the music of Elvis Presley. Filming brought new challenges for Fanning, who will apparently appear nude for the first time and also had to film a rape scene.

"The two taboos in Hollywood are child abuse and the killing of animals. In this movie, both things happen," said a source to the New York Daily News. "The subject matter is very tough," said Lawrence Robins, an entertainment entrepreneur who had to search for investors once money fell through due to the controversial content. "I was attracted to it because in the end it's a story about human understanding, about a little girl who's dealt a very bad deck of cards, but finds solace in the music of Elvis and survives."

But controversy often sparks Oscar buzz, which is what Fanning's mother, Joy, and agent, Cindy Osbrink, are supposedly hoping for. "It's not just the rape scene the whole story is challenging Dakota as an actress," Osbrink said. "And I've never been so proud of her in my life. I've seen the dailies, and in every scene she gets better and better."

Discuss...

Giles 07-24-06 03:29 PM

reaction 'ewwww'

Rogue588 07-24-06 03:32 PM

Aren't there laws against this sort of thing..? -ohbfrank-

Obey The D 07-24-06 03:36 PM

You've got to be kidding me. Whats next, a toddler getting raped on screen?

Also, I can't believe a parent would want their child in a movie where they're getting raped. I guess her mom is your typical hollywood parent who sees her child as nothing more than a meal ticket. I don't care if it's fake or not, that's the kind of thing that could fuck someone up if they don't know how to handle it.

shaun3000 07-24-06 03:38 PM

Based on her performance in War of the Worlds, I think she's perfect for the role.

William Fuld 07-24-06 03:40 PM

Too soon.

Dr. DVD 07-24-06 03:42 PM

Are they kidding? Can they legally do this?

lordwow 07-24-06 03:45 PM

legal answer: They can do this if and only if there is no nudity. You can't show minors nude as far as I know.

Giles 07-24-06 03:50 PM


Originally Posted by lordwow
You can't show minors nude as far as I know.

just not in the US or the UK (in sexual content) for that matter.

Drexl 07-24-06 03:58 PM

Thora Birch was 17 when she appeared nude in American Beauty. Her parents had to be on set along with child labor representatives.

There is quite a difference between 12 and 17 though, and Birch's scene didn't involve simulated rape.

joeblow69 07-24-06 03:59 PM

Are you sure about that? I thought it was ok as long as it had artistic merit?

Joe Molotov 07-24-06 04:01 PM

Good for her! Too many young actresses are having to wait until they turn 18 to be exploited in graphic sex scenes. Hopefully this will break down another barrier of discrimmination in Hollywood.

maxfisher 07-24-06 04:05 PM

I thought this thread was going to be about her rumored casting in The Lovely Bones. Kind of strange that she'd be doing two movies where she plays a little raped girl.

JumpCutz 07-24-06 04:05 PM

Hey, anything to generate a little oscar buzz. -ohbfrank-

Dr. Henry Jones, Jr. 07-24-06 04:07 PM

pics?

Groucho 07-24-06 04:08 PM

Brooke Shields appeared nude on screen at about the same age in Pretty Baby, so who knows?

I'll pass, thank you very much.

McHawkson 07-24-06 04:13 PM


Filming brought new challenges for Fanning, who will apparently appear nude for the first time and also had to film a rape scene.
Apparently.... It's possible double body or ??

Groucho 07-24-06 04:15 PM


Originally Posted by McHawkson
Apparently.... It's possible double body or ??

Paging Keira Knightly...

devilshalo 07-24-06 04:16 PM

Great.. more screaming and crying from this girl. Had enough of that with WotW. :mad:

BravesMG 07-24-06 04:22 PM

I love how proud her parents are, way to exploit your 12 year old. There's no way a 12 year old is ready for a simulated rape scene, that's fucking insane and actual child abuse in my opinion.

lordwow 07-24-06 04:26 PM


Originally Posted by Drexl
Thora Birch was 17 when she appeared nude in American Beauty. Her parents had to be on set along with child labor representatives.

There is quite a difference between 12 and 17 though, and Birch's scene didn't involve simulated rape.

There are some really strange rules when you do that though. You do need TONS of clearance from a TON of groups to do it (all the labor unions involved, the parties involved, and the studios and their censors). I recall that it was even illegal to post the video of that scene online (as in the websites that specialize in nude scenes in movies wouldn't show it until she turned 18).

I honestly don't know, I'll talk to some people tomorrow and see what our production people think.

MASAMUNE2 07-24-06 04:30 PM

Neo: "Whoaaa."

Daytripper 07-24-06 04:31 PM


Originally Posted by bravesmg
I love how proud her parents are, way to exploit your 12 year old. There's no way a 12 year old is ready for a simulated rape scene, that's fucking insane and actual child abuse in my opinion.

Are these the same parents who threatened to sue Kathy Griffin after the comments she made at some awards show? During her on the carpet gig where she was asking other celebrities how they felt about Dakota being in rehab. Obviously it was a joke. But they claimed it devastated the child. And this won't!?

Numanoid 07-24-06 04:49 PM

It's called "acting", people. Geez.

McHawkson 07-24-06 05:04 PM


Originally Posted by lordwow
There are some really strange rules when you do that though. You do need TONS of clearance from a TON of groups to do it (all the labor unions involved, the parties involved, and the studios and their censors). I recall that it was even illegal to post the video of that scene online (as in the websites that specialize in nude scenes in movies wouldn't show it until she turned 18).

I honestly don't know, I'll talk to some people tomorrow and see what our production people think.

That's true...

Mr. Skin refused to show Brooke Shield's nudes when she was little.

dpz301 07-24-06 05:12 PM

seems a little crazy to be doing, but who knows.

Iron_Giant 07-24-06 05:18 PM


Originally Posted by Numanoid
It's called "acting", people. Geez.

It is called Gross and Wrong, no way around it.

This will kill her career and will change laws, just like the Superbowl Malfunction.

BravesMG 07-24-06 05:25 PM


Originally Posted by Numanoid
It's called "acting", people. Geez.

I wholeheartedly disagree with that notion. It's acting for those that can separate fact from fiction, and I just don't believe that a 12 year old girl, no matter how "mature" or "experienced in Hollywood" she is, that she can separate what an adult is doing to her sexually as 'acting.'

PixyJunket 07-24-06 05:28 PM

I think people are confusing 12 years old with 5 years old. :lol:

wergo 07-24-06 05:30 PM

How old was Jena Malone when she filmed 'Bastard Out Of Carolina'?

JarJar Fett 07-24-06 05:39 PM

What is the source for the article? It kinda reads like something from The Onion....

But if it is genuine, eeewww!!

Mr. Cinema 07-24-06 05:52 PM

I guess she's really trying to be the next Jodie Foster.

Slayer2005 07-24-06 06:32 PM


Originally Posted by PixyJunket
I think people are confusing 12 years old with 5 years old. :lol:


Yeah, true. When I was young we had girls that were sluts by the time they were 13 and some were hooking up with older guys in their late teens. No kidding. Hell, my first sexual experience happened when I was 11 and it was a 13 year old girl who came on to me. :lol:

She is smart enough and matured beyond her years. I think she can handle it, otherwise I doubt she would've accepted the role. Should they be doing it? Probably not. Still, I seriously doubt this will scar her for life, because as you said, she's 12, not 5. She knows what she's doing is acting. I'm just surrpised her parents ok'd it. I hope they had at least had a long and serious talk with her to make sure she was really up for such a demanding role.

I'll tell you what though this girl really wants to be known as a serious actress; That's for sure. Maybe they're banking on the controversial scene to help get her an Oscar. Worked for Halle Berry. :)

I'd honestly be surprised if this scene actually sees the light of day and if it does I get the feeling it won't be as bad as we all imagine. They'll probably have a body double do parts and use clever editing and camera tricks.

RocShemp 07-24-06 06:55 PM

I agree with those that say she can probably handle it but I also agree with those that say the scene should never be. Unless the whole nudity issue is BS and the rape will be mostly offscreen. Adult actors have appeared in carefully shot/edited rape scenes before. The same could be true for this scene.

Daytripper 07-24-06 07:11 PM

How old was Linda Blair when she did "The Exorcist". 12, no? Even she admits that movie fucked her up.

xage 07-24-06 07:22 PM


Originally Posted by McHawkson
That's true...

Mr. Skin refused to show Brooke Shield's nudes when she was little.

But its available to be seen on DVD...

Bugg 07-24-06 07:32 PM

So who is she raping in this movie?

mike7162 07-24-06 07:34 PM

Wrong, wrong, wrong. Apparantly, the criteria for winning an Oscar have gone way downhill. I don't want to see a nude 12 year old, faked, body doubled or tastefully shot. It's just pure exploitation, regardless of the film's subject matter.

Eric D. 07-24-06 07:35 PM

WTF? Who would want to watch something like this? I'm not going to see it and the best part is, her parents are proud and are hoping for an oscar! Jesus, no wonder why so many child actors turn to drugs and end up killing themsleves.

Numanoid 07-24-06 07:36 PM


Originally Posted by PixyJunket
I think people are confusing 12 years old with 5 years old. :lol:

Seriously. I think everyone in this thread has forgotten just how worldly a 12 year-old is. I'm sure they've also never filmed a scene for a movie either. It's not a freakin' hidden camera thing where a guy comes in and actually pretends to rape her for ten minutes. It's lights, and makeup, and a director and a million people standing around watching, and each shot lasts about 5 seconds, then you break and get a doughnut while they set up the next shot.

I think she'll be alright. But it's nice that the morality police and armchair foster parents are looking out for her.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:03 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.