DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Taxi Driver or Apocalypse Now Redux? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/469018-taxi-driver-apocalypse-now-redux.html)

hardercore 06-18-06 04:57 AM


Originally Posted by astrochimp
Martin Sheen was actually dead the whole time.

Thanks for raping my first experience of the movie.

Apone 06-18-06 05:02 AM


Originally Posted by hardercore
Thanks for raping my first experience of the movie.

That wasn't a spoiler so don't worry... Or was it?

DUN DUN DUN

Filmmaker 06-18-06 07:55 AM


Originally Posted by hardercore
Thanks for raping my first experience of the movie.

It was a joke--one in very bad taste, but a joke nonetheless; nothing has been spoiled.

astrochimp 06-18-06 10:48 AM


Originally Posted by hardercore
Thanks for raping my first experience of the movie.

It was my sixth sense of humor.Hope you see the film,its a good one :)

daniel18 06-19-06 10:43 AM

Taxi Driver first, two disc Apocalypse Now later.

wm lopez 06-19-06 10:31 PM

If you smoke weed buy Ap. Now, it's the perfect movie for that.
And if they are able to get a good dvd with sound ,because this movie does have excellent sound at lest it did on laserdisc and I think it won an Oscar for sound.

FRwL 06-20-06 12:22 AM

Apocalypse Now starts getting weird after Kilgore, but then again Coppola said "my movie isn't about Vietnam, it IS Vietnam". Definitely the best nam movie.

hardercore 06-20-06 12:29 AM

I just ordered Apocalypse Now Redux, but only because recommendations were pretty much even, I couldn't find the theatrical version, and Apocalypse Now Redux cost half the price of Taxi Driver Collector's Edition so I was also able to pick up Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World as well

Joe Molotov 06-20-06 01:25 AM

I hated the Redux. :(

FRwL 06-20-06 03:06 AM

Redux is a step down from the original, the pacing is wiped out in the unecessary cut from Kilgore's iconic napalm speech to comical surf board stealing, and then the French plantation seemed like a different movie all together.

RyoHazuki 06-20-06 04:48 AM

Yeah the Redux sucked some of the life out of it.

Taxi Driver is the better film.

hardercore 06-20-06 05:29 AM

Only now, after I've made the order, do any people speak out who'd not recommend it. I guess I'll just take a look and decide for myself, Redux got a score of 90 at metacritic.

Joe Molotov 06-20-06 11:45 AM


Originally Posted by hardercore
Only now, after I've made the order, do any people speak out who'd not recommend it.

...


Originally Posted by Joe Molotov
Get Apocalypse Now non-reduxed.


hardercore 06-20-06 03:59 PM


Originally Posted by Joe Molotov
...

Couldn't find the theatrical version. I'm in a region 4 country, remember. I think the Redux is the only version of the film currently in print.

lxl 06-21-06 09:36 PM

your tastes seem more inline with TD

Spiral Staircase 06-21-06 10:15 PM

The theatrical version of Apocalyse Now and Taxi Driver are both essential, but I would give the edge to Taxi Driver.

Mordred 06-21-06 11:16 PM

Well not that it matters anymore (and I haven't seen the Redux) but Taxi Driver is a great film. Apocalypse Now is an experience. It's my second favorite film behind The Godfather. Hopefully your enjoyment of the movie will be the same.

brainee 06-22-06 11:37 AM

I would not make the "Redux" version of AN your first experience with the movie. It is a step-down, overlong, and the pacing is thrown off. The extra scenes are interesting for the viewer already familiar with the movie, but they would've been better in a "deleted scenes" part of a DVD. Not spliced back into the original with no option for seeing the first cut. There's a double-dip coming of the original. You've gone your whole life without seeing AN -- what's a few more months.

TD looks to be the best choice for you -- it currently has a good relatively cheap DVD edition. If you have access (or know someone with access) to Mark Cuban's HDNet family of channels, it's been getting airtime in beautiful HD transfer.

hardercore 06-22-06 04:08 PM


Originally Posted by brainee
I would not make the "Redux" version of AN your first experience with the movie. It is a step-down, overlong, and the pacing is thrown off. The extra scenes are interesting for the viewer already familiar with the movie, but they would've been better in a "deleted scenes" part of a DVD. Not spliced back into the original with no option for seeing the first cut. There's a double-dip coming of the original. You've gone your whole life without seeing AN -- what's a few more months.

TD looks to be the best choice for you -- it currently has a good relatively cheap DVD edition. If you have access (or know someone with access) to Mark Cuban's HDNet family of channels, it's been getting airtime in beautiful HD transfer.

Thanks, but I live in New Zealand. Taxi Driver CE is currently US$24.76, Where Apocalypse Now Redux was only US$12.37, so since at the time I ordered both were equally recommended I went for the cheaper option and was able to purchase another DVD alongside Apocalypse Now.

Filmmaker 06-22-06 04:18 PM

Let's be fair--if he hates AN: Redux, chances are pretty good he wouldn't have cared for the theatrrical version much either.

FRwL 06-22-06 05:40 PM

There's only one "1st time experience" and with a movie like Apocalypse Now you do not want to ruin it, just like from one of those redux scenes "it's gonna ruin it! the waves!" hold off that cheapo redux dvd, at least rent the original if you really can't wait to watch it, and then buy the release a few months from now.

hardercore 07-05-06 03:04 AM

I just sat through my first 194 minute viewing of Apocalypse Now Redux and I absolutely loved it. I had never seen the theatrical cut so Redux was my first experience of the picture. It was funny (Lt. Kilgore, and the american photographer in the end, Chef, etc) and terrifying at once. Absolutely beautiful cinematography too -- one of the best video transfers from a film of around that time (mid-late 70's) I've seen.

Filmmaker 07-05-06 09:26 AM


Originally Posted by hardercore
I just sat through my first 194 minute viewing of Apocalypse Now Redux and I absolutely loved it. I had never seen the theatrical cut so Redux was my first experience of the picture. It was funny (Lt. Kilgore, and the american photographer in the end, Chef, etc) and terrifying at once. Absolutely beautiful cinematography too -- one of the best video transfers from a film of around that time (mid-late 70's) I've seen.

I'm proud of you; don't listen to the naysayers--REDUX has plenty of virtues, and you may find that REDUX's evocative sense of "travelling back in time" the further down the river Martin Sheen goes is diluted in the theatrical cut.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:19 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.