DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Most Overrated Actor/Actress? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/436892-most-overrated-actor-actress.html)

smirnoff 09-07-05 10:45 AM

Bill Murray
He's Good, but not That good.

edit: Sean Penn too.

SINGLE104 09-07-05 01:28 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
pics of her in the news rags make her look awful without her makeup.

Not just her, but every female celebrity. Makeup does wonders for women, vastly enhances their facial features. Their natural looks are just ordinary, no difference from regular people, but are just in the public eye. Some of them would be unrecognizable without their makeup.
They hire the best professional makeup artist to do their work for them.

ToddSm66 09-07-05 02:40 PM

I'm going to have to go with Adam Sandler. The guy just isn't funny at all. I don't understand why people still flock to his movies.

tdilia 09-07-05 04:02 PM

Julia Roberts
Rene Zellwegger
Reese Witherspoon
J. Lo, I can't beleive people even consider her an actress, she is terrible.

I have to agree with ToddSm66, Adam Sandler is not that funny.

calhoun07 09-07-05 04:12 PM

William Hurt. The man plays the exact same way in every movie no matter what character he plays. Does he have any acting skills at all?

Agree with Julia Roberts, for the same reasons as William Hurt.

NatrlBornThrllr 09-07-05 04:47 PM

Wow, two votes for Sean Penn? The Assassination of Richard Nixon, Mystic River, 21 Grams, I Am Sam, Sweet and Lowdown...the guy's come on strong since the turn of the century.

-JP

wendersfan 09-07-05 05:09 PM


Originally Posted by calhoun07
William Hurt. The man plays the exact same way in every movie no matter what character he plays. Does he have any acting skills at all?

Yeah, his character in <b>Kiss of the Spider Woman</b> was exactly the same as his characters in <b>The Big Chill</b> and <b>Body Heat</b>. :rolleyes:

DRG 09-07-05 10:49 PM

Colin Farrell. I remember that huge batch of overhype after Tigerland, which he followed up with... American Outlaws. While I like some of the movies he's been in, most of his roles (SWAT, The Recruit) could have just as easily been played by Paul Walker.

bballing 09-08-05 12:02 AM

Samual L Jackson

RichC2 09-08-05 12:23 AM


Originally Posted by ToddSm66
I'm going to have to go with Adam Sandler. The guy just isn't funny at all. I don't understand why people still flock to his movies.

I dunno, I couldn't picture anyone else playing his role in Punch-Drunk Love.

peon73 09-08-05 07:35 AM

Cuba Gooding Jr. (and this is an oscar winner???)

JoeySeven 06-15-19 12:09 AM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 

Jennifer Lawrence : While being decent actress, she definitely is the most overrated actress of this decade. I did like Silver Linings Playbook

Yes I just bumped a 10+ year old thread. :lol:

I still need to finish Red Sparrow .Have not watch Joy,Mother and Serena yet,not high on my must see list.

Norm de Plume 06-15-19 12:55 AM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 

Originally Posted by wendersfan (Post 6359309)
Not that I think he's a bad actor, but I hate to think that, 50 years from now, people will see the Oscars that Tom Hanks has won, and assume he was the best dramatic actor of his generation... -ohbfrank-

A "Hell, yes!", 15 years late. Hanks, who is by all accounts one of the nicest people in Hollywood, is the acting equivalent of pablum.

Mike86 06-15-19 09:39 AM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
I’ve really never understood why so many people love Johnny Depp. He was always liked by some and I think that his Jack Sparrow role really catapulted him over the top for some people. I’ve always thought he was kind of bland and don’t really like most of the films he’s in. Actually one of his only performances I like is in a film that I don’t think was that popular (Black Mass).

melasnus 06-15-19 01:34 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
This is an easy one: Seth Rogen.

GoldenJCJ 06-15-19 01:44 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 13565642)
I’ve really never understood why so many people love Johnny Depp. He was always liked by some and I think that his Jack Sparrow role really catapulted him over the top for some people. I’ve always thought he was kind of bland and don’t really like most of the films he’s in. Actually one of his only performances I like is in a film that I don’t think was that popular (Black Mass).

There’s a strange change in acting roles Depp has made since the first PotC. He used to be a heartthrob who would take on romantic and dramatic roles, most of which were actually pretty enjoyable movies. Then after Curse of the Black Pearl, Depp decides that he just liked to play dress-up and started making movies where his character could look as goofy as possible (Jack Sparrow, Willy Wonka, Sweeney Todd, Mad Hatter, Barnabus Collins,Tonto, etc.)

Drexl 06-15-19 02:43 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 

Originally Posted by melasnus (Post 13565691)
This is an easy one: Seth Rogen.

Is he really overrated though? He's done a lot of stuff, including writing and producing. But he's not a big box office draw and he doesn't seem to be loved by critics. The only major award nomination he has received was an Emmy nod for being part of a writing ensemble for Da Ali G show back in 2003. And it's not as if he gets coveted roles or anything; maybe the most prestigious thing he's done is playing Steve Wozniak in Jobs. He's not Jonah Hill with his 2 Oscar nominations.

Unless your angle was that merely getting to have a good career makes him overrated enough.

Dan1boy 06-15-19 05:03 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
This.

Dan1boy 06-15-19 05:05 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
Adam Sandler and Jack Black

JeffTheAlpaca 06-15-19 05:24 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
George Clooney

He had maybe 1 or 2 good movies but he is not that entertaining to watch.

JeffTheAlpaca 06-15-19 05:26 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
I agree with Julia Roberts and Jennifer Lawrence

Mike86 06-15-19 05:57 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 

Originally Posted by JeffTheAlpaca (Post 13565762)
George Clooney

He had maybe 1 or 2 good movies but he is not that entertaining to watch.

Clooney hasn’t had a good film in a while, but I think he has a pretty good track record if you ask me. A lot more that one or two good movies.

Ash Ketchum 06-15-19 06:07 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
Pretty much every actor mentioned in this thread plus every Oscar winner of the last 20 years under the age of 70, except for Christoph Waltz.

movieguru 06-15-19 07:29 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 
how can this thread have 48 posts and no one has yet brought up Tom Cruise?

tanman 06-15-19 09:40 PM

Re: Most Overrated Actor/Actress?
 

Originally Posted by movieguru (Post 13565794)
how can this thread have 48 posts and no one has yet brought up Tom Cruise?

He's pretty much evolved into an action only star to which he is still doing an incredible job. He's a great entertainer and I don't really think he pretends to be more than that.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:06 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.