hello,
here's a link to my negative review of episode 3 along with for suggestions of how it could have been a hell of a lot better...

[URL deleted. D-]

i'd love to hear other ideas for how the many problems of episode 3 could have been solved

-akira

And we thought Spam was just meat in a can.

Damn...NOW you say something! If only George Lucas had checked with YOU (BEFORE) ROTS debuted...oh and probably Ep 1 & 2 (cause face it...if one bashes 3, then you ARE a PT hater without a doubt)...if ONLY he checked with YOU.... it ALL could have been so much better!

Hope your childhood wasnt raped and ruined by the creation of the PT and the OBVIOUS diminishing of the OT SOLELY by the making of the PT...or some similar rant... its all the same..

You people crack me up...

I think it could be solved if a lot of people just don't go to see it.

BTW, I REALLY liked Revenge of the Sith. I just don't think it's made for everyone.

No movie is ever made for everyone... there is always someone who wants to say there are problems when deep down they know it was their fav film of all time.

And they'll buy every version of the DVD.

Drama queen much?

What cracks me up is when someone trivializes complaints that have been voiced by legions of people ... just because of the fact that they're voiced by legions of people. It IS socially acceptable to criticize these woefully disappointing films, you know, even though this guy is pretty ham-handed at it.

To paraphrase Obi-Wan...

Who's the bigger trivializer, the trivializer or the trivializer who trivializes him?

Of course it is "acceptable" to criticize the films. It is even acceptable to resort to hyperbole, such as your "legions of people" and "woefully disappointing films" claims. However, it is also acceptable to point out when someone has such an obvious axe to grind as this "reviewer" does.

Well said...

For those wish to bash the PT or the Saga in whole..just create a thread dedicated to THAT alone... and sit and wait...and wait...to see how many of those "Legions" are disapointed.... over $3 Billion dollars worth of disapointed people....

Like I said..cracks me up...

Thanks!

Look, by no means am I defending the guy. I'm just saying you shouldn't so snarkily dismiss the opinions of MANY who feel the prequel trilogy does a disservice to the original trilogy. ("Legion" isn't hyperbole at all. You really don't believe that "a large number of people" are disappointed by the prequels? If you don't, I think you're a bit deluded.)

And the amount of money these things are raking in has very little correlation to how people feel about the prequels.

Though you may not have intended, this post appears to be SPAM promoting your website. If you want to post the review as a topic here, that would be fine.