DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/377015-pierce-brosnan-wont-back-james-bond.html)

Michael Corvin 10-06-05 10:49 PM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Well, if Brosnan is out, then I'd also go with Worthington. Craig and Visnjic look like they should be playing villains and Cavill looks like Bond's son.

Craig definitely looks like a villain. I like Visnjic, but I bet he is disregarded because they want someone bankable. Someone with an easy to pronounce and spell name.

Worthington looks the best to me as well.

RocShemp 10-09-05 10:03 PM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Well, if Brosnan is out, then I'd also go with Worthington. Craig and Visnjic look like they should be playing villains and Cavill looks like Bond's son.

Lookswise I agree (although I think Craig would be a nice departure from the norm) but I'd rather actually see Worthington in something (never heard of him before this thread) before I actually consider him a worthy candidate for Bond. And, as others have mentioned, equal (if not more) attention should be placed on the script itself and not just the actor who will portray Bond.

duff beer 12-30-13 04:42 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
To get back to this little topic, i still find that Brosnan could have just continued onward.

islandclaws 12-30-13 04:50 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
rotfl at people suggesting Worthington would've been a good fit for the role.

Why So Blu? 12-30-13 05:21 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by duff beer (Post 11961786)
To get back to this little topic, i still find that Brosnan could have just continued onward.

He could have but all of his Bond's were atrocious aside from Goldeneye.

Guru Askew 12-30-13 05:31 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
I've seen atrocious movies. TND and TWINE aren't atrocious movies. I don't know if I could sincerely say DAD was atrocious either.

And Brosnan was never bad in any of them. Lumping the Bond films together by actor is easy and obvious but the idea falls apart if you pay any attention. Look at how different From Russia with Love, Goldfinger and You Only Live Twice are. Or Live and Let Die, The Spy Who Loved Me and For Your Eyes Only for that matter. Roger Moore isn't the one saying "we gotta reign this in after Moonraker!" and similarly I can assure you Brosnan wasn't behind all the "atrocious" things in Bonds 17-20.

I'm a big fan of the three Daniel Craig Bonds so I have no complaints but I believe Brosnan was up to the task of playing Bond in a well-written, well-directed film.

Why So Blu? 12-30-13 05:38 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by Guru Askew (Post 11961820)
I've seen atrocious movies. TND and TWINE aren't atrocious movies. I don't know if I could sincerely say DAD was atrocious either.

And Brosnan was never bad in any of them. Lumping the Bond films together by actor is easy and obvious but the idea falls apart if you pay any attention. Look at how different From Russia with Love, Goldfinger and You Only Live Twice are. Or Live and Let Die, The Spy Who Loved Me and For Your Eyes Only for that matter. Roger Moore isn't the one saying "we gotta reign this in after Moonraker!" and similarly I can assure you Brosnan wasn't behind all the "atrocious" things I'm Bonds 17-20.

I'm a big fan of the three Daniel Craig Bonds so I have no complaints but I believe Brosnan was up to the task of playing Bond in a well-written, well-directed film.


I'll take Moore's "worst" over Brosnan's non-Godeneye features anyday.

Decker 12-30-13 11:26 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by Why So Blu? (Post 11961828)
I'll take Moore's "worst" over Brosnan's non-Godeneye features anyday.

I think Moore's work in A View To A Kill is the worst Bond performance in any official Bond title -- so lazy and lethargic. They didn't even use a stuntman with the same color hair - in scenes where Bond was just driving a car arounnd.

Honestly, Octopussy isn't much better. At least Brosnan was trying.

O/T but it's impossible to convince your daughter that Brosnan was once the pinnacle of cool once she's seen him wail like a dying cat during musical numbers in Mamma Mia.

Groucho 12-30-13 11:27 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by Groucho
Never heard of that Cavill guy, but he looks more like Superman than James Bond to me. :shrug:

Whoa.

Decker 12-30-13 11:28 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
You might have been onto something there Groucho!

Hazel Motes 12-30-13 11:31 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
*closes eyes tightly* Jennifer Lawrence looks more like my sex slave than Katniss Everdeen to me.:shrug:

Why So Blu? 12-30-13 11:31 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
That was awesome Groucho.


BTW, to all the naysayers that couldn't believe Craig would get the role all you had to do was watch Layer Cake to see that he would be the clear winner.

Decker 12-30-13 11:38 PM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
We've been Grouchoed! That last post was his only one in this thread.

Well played, sir.

Abob Teff 12-31-13 01:07 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
That is ... scary. Very scary.

wearetheborg 12-31-13 05:29 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
Damn, Groucho!!!!!!!!!!!!

Michael Corvin 12-31-13 07:00 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
I've only seen Casino Royale thus far and based on that, I'd still rather have Brosnan in the suit.

mattysemo247 12-31-13 08:05 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 11962195)
I've only seen Casino Royale thus far and based on that, I'd still rather have Brosnan in the suit.

You need to watch Skyfall ASAP

Drexl 12-31-13 08:05 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by islandclaws (Post 11961794)
rotfl at people suggesting Worthington would've been a good fit for the role.

Yeah, I was backtracking through the thread a bit, saw the mentions of "Worthington" and was curious about the first name. I figured it couldn't possibly be Sam.

He wasn't really known at the time, although maybe that help explains why he was suggested.

RichC2 12-31-13 09:06 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
Worthington would be the most forgettable Bond ever.

Solid Snake 12-31-13 09:41 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
If it wasn't for Skyfall stamping that Bond has a history, I'd still argue that Idris Elba would be awesome.

Brack 12-31-13 10:20 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by mattysemo247 (Post 11962232)
You need to watch Skyfall ASAP

Skyfall is great, but Casino Royale still holds up well and is just as good. I guess I didn't think Javier Bardem was that great of a Bond villain.

Solid Snake 12-31-13 10:37 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
My main issue with casino Royale is that it could have been condensed a bit more. Either way I love it.

Hokeyboy 12-31-13 10:41 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake (Post 11962341)
If it wasn't for Skyfall stamping that Bond has a history, I'd still argue that Idris Elba would be awesome.

Yeah but there's no continuity between the different Bonds (or sometimes, amid Bond movies of the same Bond actor) so it doesn't really matter.

hanshotfirst1138 12-31-13 10:46 AM

Trying to figure out the continuity even between individual movies is usually a futile exercise. CR and QOS lead directly into one another, but trying to figure out the timeline is usually just going to drive you nuts.

Hokeyboy 12-31-13 11:18 AM

Re: Pierce Brosnan won't be back as James Bond
 
To wit: Bond & Blofeld come face-to-face in "You Only Live Twice". In the next movie ("On Her Majesty's Secret Service"), Bond goes undercover at Blofeld's secret lab/base/whatever, and Blofeld doesn't recognize him.

There's really no continuity. Despite the pleas of many to the contrary...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:54 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.