View Poll Results: What film should have won best picture in 1977?
Annie Hall



129
44.48%
Star Wars



144
49.66%
The Goodbye Girl



5
1.72%
Julia



3
1.03%
The Turning Point



0
0%
Other (please specify below)



9
3.10%
Voters: 290. You may not vote on this poll
STAR WARS vs. ANNIE HALL
#176
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,400
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Near the Great Salt Lake
Re: STAR WARS vs. ANNIE HALL
I had long heard that Malick's first two films were vigorously defended by a handful of critics, while most critics either shrugged or tore the films apart. After doing a little more research, I see that Ash's recollections are correct and that, though there were (as with any highly acclaimed film) some very negative reviews, they were pretty widely acclaimed upon initial release (though they still didn't make much money.) Dave Kehr (who raved about Days of Heaven in 1978) writes:
And I'm going to stop posting here, since we're completely off topic. Sorry.
Adrian, your recollection of the reception accorded “Days of Heaven” is quite different from mine. 1978 was the first year I attended the voting meeting of the National Society of Film Critics, and I flew from Chicago to New York a day early in order to see “Days of Heaven” in 70 millimeter at one of the now-closed Third Avenue theaters. I was, obviously, knocked out by the film and was happy to join the large block of critics voting for it at the meeting the next day. It was neck and neck between “Days” and “The Deer Hunter” (which I did not care for) and the voting went through several ballots before Pauline Kael put her voting bloc behind that immortal classic “Get Out Your Handkerchiefs,” which won the best picture award and went on to the total obscurity it so richly deserves. In any case there was certainly widespread critical support for “Days,” as there had been for “Badlands,” when it first appeared. Not every movie conforms to the romantic myth of the misunderstood masterpiece, and Malick, who has enjoyed the patronage of some very powerful Hollywood figures ever since (and good for him!), is not Vincent Van Gogh.
#177
#178
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,400
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Near the Great Salt Lake
Re: STAR WARS vs. ANNIE HALL
#179
Re: STAR WARS vs. ANNIE HALL
#180
Re: STAR WARS vs. ANNIE HALL
Tree of Life is a beautiful film and if you "let it wash over you," you will see the epic scope of what Malick tried to do. He may have failed at least in the narrative part (the whole Sean Penn thing) but he totally succeeded in making a testament to God or nature or whatever you want to call it.
#181
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Annie Hall won because Academy voters are adults, not children. We all grew up watching Star Wars, and it wowed us from childhood and we still regard it the way we did when we first saw it as excited, wide-eyed kids. But how many adults, seeing Star Wars for the first time, would be as wowed? Have you ever seen a grown-up watch Star Wars for the first time? They generally don't go apeshit for it the way kids do.
Seeing the movie for the first time years later is a completely different experience because many of the things that made Star Wars a phenomenal success had become commonplace and because the notoriety of the movie is bound to bias later viewers. As an example, I've never seen the popular movies E.T. or Jaws. But those movies are so well known that I could never see them "cold" because I've seen and read too many things about them to be unbiased.
#182
Re: STAR WARS vs. ANNIE HALL
I love this film. But obviously that recognition goes to City of God.




