DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Question about dwarves (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/336446-question-about-dwarves.html)

Geminix 12-18-03 11:07 AM

Question about dwarves
 
This may be a stupid question, so forgive me.. but a friend who saw ROTK with me asked this later, and I didn't know how to answer.

Why don't any other dwarves join in the cause? We got men, we got elves, but no other dwarves. Did they not know everything that was going on? Apparently they're good fighters and could've helped out. Is this explained in the books?

Thanks in advance..

Daytrip 12-18-03 11:08 AM

they care nothing for the outside world, and all from the mines of moria are pretty much toast

Geminix 12-18-03 11:10 AM

well I guess I figured they cared enough to send representatives to Rivendell, so surely they might have done more..

Shannon Nutt 12-18-03 11:17 AM

I've never read the books, but I think the movies give the impression that Gimli is one of the last of his kind (at least in the immediate area) and that most of his people were wiped out in the mines of Moria.

mwdkill 12-18-03 11:49 AM

dwarves are lazy
 
well they didnt join the cause because most of them were already killed in the first one...remember Moria...and also dwarves were too greedy and cared nothing for the problems of men and elves...in other words...theyre damn selfish...good question though

B.A. 12-18-03 12:22 PM

Gimli's folk were probably guarding their hoard/mining at the Lonely Mountain (read The Hobbit). Or mining in the Iron Hlls. But basically they are really far away to the north and care almost nothing for the outside world.

Gimli went on the fellowship, how many other dwarves needed to go? ;)

Daytrip 12-18-03 12:24 PM

agreed, not all Dwarves lived in Dwarrowdelf or the mines of Moria

covenant 12-18-03 12:24 PM

Actually the dwarves at the Lonely mountain and the Men of Dale were being attacked by Sauron's forces at the same time Gondor was being besieged. The same was happening to Lothlorien which was burning.

Snowlarbear 12-18-03 12:34 PM

same can be asked about the rest of the hobbits.

condorito 12-18-03 12:50 PM

yeah there are not only dwarvesin moria
In rotk they help rebuild the outer wall of minas tirith after the battle

Giantrobo 12-18-03 01:09 PM

IIRC, wasn't Gimli and few other dwarves also on a mission to find some certain lost dwarves between the time of The Hobbit and Fellowship???

PalmerJoss 12-18-03 02:42 PM


Originally posted by Snowlarbear
same can be asked about the rest of the hobbits.
Hobbits didn't join the fight because they had no knowledge of it. They didn't say anything to their friends and neighbors about the Ring or the dark lord because they didn't want to put any of them in jeopardy.

wlmowery 12-18-03 03:08 PM


Originally posted by covenant
Actually the dwarves at the Lonely mountain and the Men of Dale were being attacked by Sauron's forces at the same time Gondor was being besieged. The same was happening to Lothlorien which was burning.
This is a good response. But also remember that the Dwarves are diminishing, just like otehr non-human folk. The time of man is approaching and the Dwarvish numbers are lessening rapidly.

But the dwarves did fight in the War of the Ring. They with the men of Dale and the Long Lake fought the wild men of the east who attacked along the shores of the River Running. During the conflict, Dain, king under the Lonely Mountain and many of the rest of the Drawves who remained from Bilbo's adventures in the Hobbit were killed.

Eventually, it is said, that some Dwarves settled in the White Mountains among the Glittering Caves of Helms Deep. Also some were said to re-enter Moria and cleanse it of the orc misuse. More remained in the north, but most faded into memory and myth....

Get Me Coffee 12-18-03 03:18 PM

Hey Thanks Wayne for all your LOTR posts! Very informative!

jim_cook87 12-18-03 04:11 PM

The movie does not delve into it, but what we see is only part of the the larger War going on. Sauron's forces are also attacking the Wood-elves of Mirkwood and the Dwarves of the Lonely Mountain, a number of other battles take place in other locations throughout Middle Earth.

The Dwarves do their part, but the movie excludes mention of the more complex overall picture, which is briefly addressed in the books and expanded on in the appendices and additional writings.

Geminix 12-18-03 06:01 PM

Thanks everyone for the great answers! Good stuff all :D

Giantrobo 12-18-03 10:01 PM


Originally posted by wlmowery
.

But the dwarves did fight in the War of the Ring. They with the men of Dale and the Long Lake fought the wild men of the east who attacked along the shores of the River Running. During the conflict, Dain, king under the Lonely Mountain and many of the rest of the Drawves who remained from Bilbo's adventures in the Hobbit were killed.



I forgot about the Wild Men. :up:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:55 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.