Empire Question
#1
Thread Starter
Member
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Toronto
Empire Question
Can anyone explain Luke's episode in the cave during ESB?
Yoda refers to his 'failure' at the cave. I fancy myself a Star Wars geek, but I do not have a clue about this.
Anyone?
No flaming please!!!
Yoda refers to his 'failure' at the cave. I fancy myself a Star Wars geek, but I do not have a clue about this.
Anyone?
No flaming please!!!
#2
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I think you need to look to Jedi for your answer (at least I think it's Jedi). I believe Yoda say something to him along the lines of "You must face Vader before you can become a true Jedi." Having not done so in the cave, it shows two things. 1) I think some foreshadowing is involved. He cuts off the head and sees himself - he already knows on some level that he is Vader's son...??? 2) Knowing this, he knows that in order to become a Jedi he must beat his father, and in turn he'll avoid the path that his father chose. This is what will allow him to beome a Jedi.
Just my thoughts on the subject. While my two part theory may be wrong, I still think Yoda's line is your "simple" answer.
Hope this helps.
Just my thoughts on the subject. While my two part theory may be wrong, I still think Yoda's line is your "simple" answer.
Hope this helps.
#3
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Superman07
I think you need to look to Jedi for your answer (at least I think it's Jedi). I believe Yoda say something to him along the lines of "You must face Vader before you can become a true Jedi." Having not done so in the cave, it shows two things. 1) I think some foreshadowing is involved. He cuts off the head and sees himself - he already knows on some level that he is Vader's son...??? 2) Knowing this, he knows that in order to become a Jedi he must beat his father, and in turn he'll avoid the path that his father chose. This is what will allow him to beome a Jedi.
Just my thoughts on the subject. While my two part theory may be wrong, I still think Yoda's line is your "simple" answer.
Hope this helps.
I think you need to look to Jedi for your answer (at least I think it's Jedi). I believe Yoda say something to him along the lines of "You must face Vader before you can become a true Jedi." Having not done so in the cave, it shows two things. 1) I think some foreshadowing is involved. He cuts off the head and sees himself - he already knows on some level that he is Vader's son...??? 2) Knowing this, he knows that in order to become a Jedi he must beat his father, and in turn he'll avoid the path that his father chose. This is what will allow him to beome a Jedi.
Just my thoughts on the subject. While my two part theory may be wrong, I still think Yoda's line is your "simple" answer.
Hope this helps.
...I can't believe I've analysing SW....




