NCMojo

In other words, when did it all go wrong?

DeputyDave

It's a toss up between "Stop or my Mom..." and "Over the Top".

garmonbozia

Personally I've never cared about Stallone (or any of those big action "stars" that were spawned in the 1980s).....or about most of the crappy films they churned out.

matome

Judge Dredd!

evenflow

What career?

Pants

The movie where he jumped isn't on the list. Since he never made a good film after Rocky, then it is indeed Rocky that was the film where he jumped.

Geofferson

Judge Dredd

The Antipodean

The two movies I'd say played the biggest part in the shark-jumping aren't on this poll -- It started to jump with "Rambo III," which besides being a crap movie was also a rather surprising bomb when it came out. Then I have to say it jumped for good with "Rocky V," an unneeded sequel that wasn't exactly godawful, but it certainly indicated Sly was running out of freseh ideas.

elias

I voted for Judge Dredd. Here's why:

After "Over the Top" he made "Lock UP" and "Tango & Cash" which are enjoyable schlok.

Now while "Rocky V", "Oscar" & Stop! Or My Mom" are all bad movies, "Cliffhanger" & Demolition Man are actually quite good!

I think the real answer might be "The Specialist" but it wasn't on the list. His next film, "Judge Dredd" however was. After that there are some watchable movies but none that I consider "good":

Assassins
Daylight
Cop Land
Get Carter (3 years between this & his last movie, ouch)
Driven
Eye See You (direct to video)
Avenging Angelo (direct to video)
Spy Kids 3-D (stick a fork in him, he's done!)

Buttmunker

Not on the poll, but I'd say that he may have jumped after Nighthawks (1981), but I did enjoy Rocky III (1982), so it would have to be after that.

Cop Land (1997) was his brief return to real movies, but it was all too brief.

MrPeanut

He may be a third rate character actor, but how can anyone really deny that he had a career? He got $20M for a film. That says something even if it isn't about his acting ability.

fumanstan

I'll go with Judge Dredd on this. I loved Stallone in all the Rocky's except for 5... Demolition Man is a guilty pleasure. I think how Dredd bombed was the biggest factor in his career.

Groucho

I would say Bananas.

Rocky_Stallone

Well, considering that the remake of "Get Carter" made:

Opening Weekend
$6.637m (USA) (8 October 2000) (2315 screens)

according to IMDB.com, that is pretty good, then the movie got more successful as time went along:

Weekend Gross
$16,025 (USA) (10 December 2000) (64 screens)
$41,363 (USA) (3 December 2000) (141 screens)
$64,054 (USA) (26 November 2000) (221 screens)
$5,349 (USA) (19 November 2000) (28 screens)
$24,362 (USA) (12 November 2000) (59 screens)
$76,726 (USA) (5 November 2000) (205 screens)
$273,588 (USA) (29 October 2000) (539 screens)
$1.11m (USA) (22 October 2000) (1925 screens)
$2.916m (USA) (15 October 2000) (2315 screens)
$6.637m (USA) (8 October 2000) (2315 screens)

"Eye See You" and "Avenging Angelo" failed and never released because theaters weren't interested in buying the film nationally so they sent them straight to video.

So considering that the remake of "Get Carter" was a success!!!!! And "Eye See You" and "Avenging Angelo" were two straight to video releases, then Sly's career starting going downhill when the movie "Driven" came out. Since "Driven" was such a huge flop/bomb after the successful "Get Carter", "Driven" gets my vote. Sly's career had been dead since the movie "Driven".

*sighs*

It really saddens me that people think "Spy Kids 3-D" is going to fail just because Sly is going to be in it. Spy Kids is a very popular franchise for children. Sly likes kids and he wants to entertain them too. "Spy Kids 3-D" will be very successful and it will help Sly's career.

Why? The reasons are simple:

1. Spy Kids are popular for children
2. Many adults will see "Spy Kids 3-D" just to see the movie in 3-D even if they don't like Sly. There hasn't been a new movie in 3-D in a LONG TIME!!!!!
3. A lot of adults will see "Spy-Kids 3-D" because they may be huge fans of Sly and Antonio Banderas.

"Spy Kids 3-D" will help bring Sly's career back on track again, I garuntee it. Sly needs to get popular and recognized again before he puts out "Rocky VI" and "Rambo IV". If Sly doesn't bring his career back on track, then no one will care to see either "Rocky VI" or "Rambo IV". Spy Kids is the most popular movie franchise for children and it's just laughable as hell to think it's going to fail just because Sly is playing the main villian. :-/

Groucho

Yo, Rocky. You are reading the numbers wrong for Get Carter. Since when is 6 million a good opening weekend? Maybe for a low budget indie showing in a few theaters. Not for a big budget film showing on over 2000 screens. And the movie got LESS successful as time went on, not MORE. It dropped off by 66% in its second week!

jaeufraser

I do agree, Spy Kids 3d will be Stallone's biggest movie since Cliffhanger most likely. Though I can't say it'll make him a star again, it'll help him out.

Regarding Get Carter, I don't know how you can call that movie successful? It made 6 million opening weekend. That's terrible. With an end gross of around 15 million dollars, it's nothing but a big fat bomb. The failure of that movie and Driven is what caused those other two flicks to end up straight to video more than likely. Stallone is just not bankable anymore. Sky Kids will succeed by being what it is. I'd guess around 80 or 90 million gross for it, but you really won't be able to credit Stallone with that. Personally I like Stallone, he can be quite the entertaining guy. But for some reason he just picks bad movies and these days, everybody seems to know that and stays away from his movies. Because seriously, how many good movies has Stallone been in anyway? While I enjoy some of his older flicks, they were far from "good". Only his Rocky series, and really only the first few, were of any quality. At his height of popularity, 1985, he had Rocy IV and Rambo II. While I enjoy the hell out of both movies, I will not deny that they are in fact...not really that good movies. Good entertainment yes, but they are really dumb.

evenflow

Rocky_Stallone

6 million may be bad but better than nothing, it did better as time went along.


Considering this poll has "Judge Dredd" being the most votes, if you truly think "Judge Dredd" hurt Sly's career, then you are all wrong.

Look at IMDB.com budget's of "Judge Dredd"

Budget
$90m (USA)

Gross
£7.023m (UK) (12 September 1995)
£5.734m (UK) (13 August 1995)
$34.694m (USA)

Admissions
1,122,534 (France) (3 October 1995)

Filming Studio Location
Shepperton Studios, Shepperton, Surrey (UK)

Copyright Holder
Cinergi Pictures Entertainment Inc.
Cinergi Productions N.V. Inc.

Now if you think "Judge Dredd" was a flop, then you must be reading the numbers wrong.

"Judge Dredd" was a very successful film since the movie was adapted from a comic book. I find it a very entertaining film.

evenflow

I have absolutely no comments on the above post.
I think I'm going to cry at the state of our posters here at dvdtalk. Later everyone, gotta run to KMart for some tissues.

Rocky_Stallone

Anyone else have anything to add to this discussion?

It is a fact that "Judge Dredd" was a successful movie whether you like it or not.

If I wanted to, I could list the entire filmography of Sly's career and list how much money each movie made, then you can make your judgements on what movies killed Sly's career.

Remember, there is a lesson to be learned when deciding what "movie" killed an actor's career, do your research before posting.

evenflow

If successful means grossing about 40% of the cost of the movie then yeah Judge Dredd was successful.

Rocky_Stallone

The budget was 90 million, that's how much it costed to make.

The movie made 34.69 million in the box office and that's very good.

fumanstan

Uh... where in those numbers is Judge Dredd NOT a flop?

fumanstan

Um... clearly you have a dizzying intellect. It cost 90 million, and made back less then half. Let's see... Total Profit = Revenues - Cost... so we get ~35 - 90 = -55. Wow, it was a success!

Rocky_Stallone

The only reason you guys are disagreeing that it wasn't a success is because it's a Stallone film.

I'm about to do a list of his most successful films right now. I'll start it and post it in this thread when I'm done.