DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Superman Replacement ???? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/278680-superman-replacement.html)

flippo 03-16-03 01:38 AM

Superman Replacement ????
 
Well I just read new article about up coming Superman movie.
The studio having difficulty to cast actor for superman role.
So, who do you think the best actor to play that role ?

Link from EW.com

http://www.ew.com/ew/report/0,6115,4...n--its,00.html

thecrazydude 03-16-03 01:52 AM

Paul Walker might be a good superman.

Trigger 03-16-03 01:53 AM

Nicholas Cage - agree - too old
Jude Law - too skinny
Josh Harnett - too ugly
Ashton Kutcher - hahahaha... get real
Paul Walker - too blonde & dumb surfer
Brendan Fraser - too goofy
Mathew Boomer - who??

I picked Joe Rogan (host of Fear Factor) cuz he's buff and cool and looks like Superman to me.

http://www.joerogan.net/gallery/sm_joelive01.jpg

Maybe he need a little Rogaine, but he could still pull it off.

DumDum 03-16-03 01:59 AM

It's just hard for me to picture anyone other than Reeve playing Superman. Of the availible choices, I would say Josh Hartnett. But since he's decided not to go with the project, another possibility could be Ben Affleck....although I don't know how much he would want to be playing superheroes in every flick he does.

flippo 03-16-03 02:09 AM

Matthew Boomer is a soap actor and he is not really famous yet :)

Kudama 03-16-03 03:41 AM

I voted "other" because I'm too egotistical: ME
dude!
(like Jesus, I would have heat vision!)

MaudlinHarold 03-16-03 05:58 AM

Nicholas Cage - a bit old and a bit awkward looking (not to mention he likes talkin' funny in his films:))
Jude Law - too angular and he always seems to have a devilish smirk
Josh Harnett - moot point, he's out.
Ashton Kutcher - maybe in a Bizarro world [Insert "Dude, where's my ______" joke here].
Paul Walker - looked at his fansite to see who he is. Hard to say.
Brendan Fraser - kind'a goofy and kind'a dough-y.
Mathew Boomer - haven't found anything about him, so duno.

fmian 03-16-03 09:59 AM

Hands down Chrsitian Bale.

He's got the acting talents. He's diverse and can play the nervous goof and then change over totally and play a brute force character, and then flip to someone with fellings and charisma. He's also got the body for it.
http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0144084/1-5.jpg http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0144084/1-8.jpg

PS: I'm not gay. Not that there's anything wrong with it.

Amadeus 03-16-03 11:16 AM


Originally posted by fmian
Hands down Chrsitian Bale.

He's got the acting talents. He's diverse and can play the nervous goof and then change over totally and play a brute force character, and then flip to someone with fellings and charisma. He's also got the body for it.
http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0144084/1-5.jpg http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0144084/1-8.jpg

PS: I'm not gay. Not that there's anything wrong with it.

Very Nice!

:eek: As Superman i mean! :eek:

The Antipodean 03-16-03 11:22 AM

A complete unknown is the only way to go.

MurraySiskind 03-16-03 11:26 AM

It makes me sad that Ashton Kutcher is even in the running.

Amadeus 03-16-03 11:35 AM

Ashton Kutcher! :yack:

edytwinky 03-16-03 11:46 AM

I like Ashton and all but if he's Superman, all I'm going to think about during the movie is, "dude...where's my car?"

greatjedi 03-16-03 12:05 PM

I read that another actor up for consideration is:

Hayden Christensen

:eek: :eek: :eek:

He's fine as Anakin, but. . . no not Superman -ohbfrank-

fumanstan 03-16-03 12:09 PM

According to most of the rumors its down to Bomer and Fraser. Personally, i think Bomer looks the part more than anyone else mentioned.

GuessWho 03-16-03 01:10 PM

my vote:

Dean Cain

http://www.pmpnetwork.com/dean_cain/dean264.jpg



or me
<img src="http://my.core.com/~mguess/clark.jpg" height=250>

lesterlong 03-16-03 02:14 PM

<img src=http://www.thewb.com/THEWB/Images/Dynamic/i0/SM-TWelling-F_2x3_240.jpg>

Dr. DVD 03-16-03 04:20 PM

Some scenes of Fraser in a suit and glasses in The Quite American made me think him a good Clark Kent, but not necessarily Supes. Never heard of Bomer, so he might be the way to go if you want to re-invent it with an unknown like they did with Reeve.

Rypro 525 03-16-03 05:53 PM


Originally posted by greatjedi
I read that another actor up for consideration is:

Hayden Christensen

:eek: :eek: :eek:

He's fine as Anakin, but. . . no not Superman -ohbfrank-

uh, he sucked ass in star wars, he is too stiff as an actor.
I'd go with either a complete unknown, Collin Ferrell, or Crispen Glover.

Frelledup 03-16-03 05:58 PM

I think the unknown guys should get it. As much as I like some of the other actors, I dont think they are right for the role. Go with the soap opera guy, Boomer!
From what I have been reading they are going to re tell the whole story of Kal-El/Superman and I think thats a mistake. They should just go right to the Superman stuff.

Ashton. No
Brendan Frasier. No

Unknown!

Goldberg74 03-16-03 08:44 PM

For the last time....

<font size="+3">JEREMY NORTHAM!!!!</font>

<font size="1">Oh wait, you guys are talking about Superman, not James Bond... my bad!</font>

Dr. DVD 03-16-03 10:47 PM


Originally posted by Frelledup
I think the unknown guys should get it. As much as I like some of the other actors, I dont think they are right for the role. Go with the soap opera guy, Boomer!
From what I have been reading they are going to re tell the whole story of Kal-El/Superman and I think thats a mistake. They should just go right to the Superman stuff.

Ashton. No
Brendan Frasier. No

Unknown!

If you had read the review of the alleged script J.J. Abrahams wrote, you would :yack: It really seemed as if he intended to butcher the mythos for all it was worth. I can only hope this was a false review, as it was posted at Aint It Cool News.

UKingdom 03-16-03 11:11 PM

I think the pics they've shot of Bomer make him look like the prototypical Superman...

No matter who plays the role, they will become famous because of it. Having said that, it's best to cast an unknown since they will bring something new to the table, and fanboys won't complain about how so and so sucks or isn't right for the role.

http://www.aintitcool.com/image/bomer2.jpg
Bomer

This guy looks like he was made for the role.

Chad 03-17-03 12:03 AM

I've always thought Bruce Campbell would make a great Superman, although he's probably too old for the part. He definitely has the look and the chin.

http://www.houseofhorrors.com/bruce.jpg



Or they could reinvent the series, and take it in an entirely different direction...


http://home.earthlink.net/~dvdtalk/images/djqualls.jpg

Fok 03-17-03 12:41 AM

Anyone except for Nicolas Cage. How could they consider a guy with droupy lips and dufus look to be the next Superman.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:24 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.