I am trying to decide whether to pick up the R0 Tartan Oldboy or buy the R1 box set from Amazon. The main difference seems to be the documentary. Is this really worth the extra $20?

The set you want is the Tartan Tin, not sure if that is the boxset you're referring to.

The tin is awesome and its OOP, so get it asap.

http://www.amazon.com/Oldboy-Three-D...4467523&sr=8-3

If your a big fan of the movie its worth it

Yes, the tin is the one I was referring to. Thanks for the info!

Yeah, what haley said.

Worst case .. you buy the Tartan release, hate it and sell it for probably half of that (unless you got a really good deal). If you go with the tin and you hate it, you'll probably at least make the majority of your dinero back on the aftermarket. I've seen used pull in $30.

The most sensible solution .. rent it first then decide

I really enjoyed the film .. haven't heard the commentary yet .. but I hear it's fantastic.

nuf said, more later...

you can get more info here:

Oldboy Tin Set

Thanks for the comments and suggestions. I decided to pull the trigger and grab the tin from Amazon for $31.99 My gut is telling me I'll probably love it and would regret not getting the tin with the book and lengthy documentary. My only concern is that I have heard a lot of good things about it, which means I'll go into it with high expectations and get disappointed.

And even still, I'll bet five bucks you will still feel overwhelmed after seeing it .... it's that solid!!!

... if not, I have no faith in your existence

By the way, after you watch it .. please post up on your impression .........

... for I, we, need to validate the recommendation!!!


... alright, I do.

lol...ok, no problem...I am hoping to be blown away, and will post my impressions.

Oldboy is one of my top ten favorites. I own three different copies of it (original Tartan release, the LE tin, and the R2 Vengeance Trilogy box set). The Blu-Ray should be arriving within the next few weeks (I can't wait to watch it in HD!).

I think you made a great choice with the tin. I don't think you'll be disappointed.

Item is about to ship...and is now listed at $29.99 (from 31.99) if anyone else is thinking about ordering it.

Ok, here goes. Right from the start, I was riveted. I thought it was well directed, and visually stunning. The story was not predictable at all and I really didn't see the end coming in the least. I definitely appreciate and respect the recommendation. Can't wait to watch the extras and the documentary. Thanks again!

Glad you enjoyed it. It is a great film. I was riveted the first time I saw it as well.