Audition or Ichi the Killer?
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Audition or Ichi the Killer?
I have a 35 dollar credit at Moviestop, and I want to buy one Asian pulp film with half of that credit. They had Audition and Ichi for 16.99 each. I recently saw Hostel and I want something along those lines. I have heard good things about both movies. Whats the verdict?
#2
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 6,290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you like gore - get Ichi the Killer
If you like scary freaky shit - get Audition
I'm not a gore-horror fan, but if I was, I would think that Ichi the Killer is the more re-watchable movie.
If you like scary freaky shit - get Audition
I'm not a gore-horror fan, but if I was, I would think that Ichi the Killer is the more re-watchable movie.
#4
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by toddly6666
If you like gore - get Ichi the Killer
If you like scary freaky shit - get Audition
I'm not a gore-horror fan, but if I was, I would think that Ichi the Killer is the more re-watchable movie.
If you like scary freaky shit - get Audition
I'm not a gore-horror fan, but if I was, I would think that Ichi the Killer is the more re-watchable movie.
#6
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: NJ
Posts: 3,337
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Honestly, get them both. They are both two very different movies, but are equally good.
Audition probably stays with you longer after watching it though FWIW.
Audition probably stays with you longer after watching it though FWIW.
#7
Banned
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Posts: 794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Groucho
I watched the first 30 minutes of Audition and then turned it off. Turns out it's a boring romance.
"Audition", while a little slow to begin with, picks up, and really digs deep. Pretty unsettling. "Ichi" I have found to be incredibly overrated after having seen it 3 times, to make sure the opinion I share doesn't waiver. Doesn't live up to the gore quotent everyone proclaims, and when it does, it's more manga (a la "Versus") and really hokey. "Ichi himself is a boring character, whereas the Detective, whom many have mistaken for Ichi, is a little more intriguing to watch.
#8
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Groucho
I watched the first 30 minutes of Audition and then turned it off. Turns out it's a boring romance.
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: england
Posts: 977
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
the USA editions for either film arent the ideal ones. for 'audition' the UK 'collectors edition' is the best DVD of the film, for ICHI its the dutch 2-disc. this is for those that have their focus on a complete cut of the film with the best image - extras vary and theyre not really my priority (for example)...
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by RonMexico
Hmm so the consesus is: Audition is a rental and Ichi is a blind buy?
#16
DVD Talk Hero
Loved Audition, Liked Ichi.
Ichi is the more accessible of the two - odds are greater that you'll like it.
Audition is one of my favorite movies now, highly memorable.
Ichi is more rewatchable, Audition is the better movie.
Ichi is the more accessible of the two - odds are greater that you'll like it.
Audition is one of my favorite movies now, highly memorable.
Ichi is more rewatchable, Audition is the better movie.
#17
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Peep
For fans of "Hostel", yes. They are both really good movies, but Ichi will probably be more your cup of tea. "Audition" is more creepy, suspenseful and chilling than actually scary, IMO.
#18
I'd recommend "Audition" first. Like "Hostel", it starts like one kind of movie, and veers into disturbo horror by the end. "Ichi" was mostly campy/jokey -- I don't even fans of it would call it "scary". Though if all you care about is the gore-factor then "Ichi" has more of that.
#19
DVD Talk Hero
I'd recommend "Audition" first. Like "Hostel", it starts like one kind of movie, and veers into disturbo horror by the end. "Ichi" was mostly campy/jokey -- I don't even fans of it would call it "scary". Though if all you care about is the gore-factor then "Ichi" has more of that.
#20
DVD Talk Legend
Ichi the Killer was based on a Manga wasn't it? hence the cartoony nature of it all.
I'm with a lot of other posters, I'd say if you like gore go with Ichi The Killer, if you want to be creeped out get Audition.
I'm with a lot of other posters, I'd say if you like gore go with Ichi The Killer, if you want to be creeped out get Audition.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: True North Strong & Free
Posts: 23,199
Received 2,200 Likes
on
1,505 Posts
Originally Posted by Cinemaddiction
Unless you're kidding, offering a solid assessment, after a mere 30 minutes of viewing, is totally wrong.
As other's have mentioned, AUDITION is a better film with some serious shock moments, (I'll admit I jumped at a couple scenes) but ICHI THE KILLER is a more gory, fun film with definitely more repeat viewing value (and many will need repeat viewings to puzzle out the ending). As logboy says, the best version of the latter film is the Dutch 2 disc set, it looks and sounds great, with terrific extras, but I think it might be out of print now.
#22
Suspended
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ichi - although I like Audition, Ichi has a very different style, cinematography and soundtrack. Throw some humour in there and you have something you never saw before..
Don't take it like a normal movie though, it's a real life manga.
O, and like others said. Audition is a 'scary' movie, Ichi isn't.
But it is (!) http://www.worththepopcorn.com
Don't take it like a normal movie though, it's a real life manga.
O, and like others said. Audition is a 'scary' movie, Ichi isn't.
But it is (!) http://www.worththepopcorn.com
Last edited by Cheek; 01-24-08 at 11:46 PM.
#24
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 2,429
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I love Miike. I own 17 Miike DVDs, and have seen many more (including, I admit, a number of bootlegs).
"Audition" is one of his best. "Ichi" is one of his worst. "Audition" represents Miike at his most carefully calibrated with acute attention to tone, pacing and bizarro psychology not seen again until "Gozu" and "Box". The latter typifies the lazier aspects of Miike's filmmaking, becoming almost a parody of "extreme asian" and going through the motions with the pat, typical genre elements and special effects gross-outs taking the place of the more deeply perverse and transgressive elements of his best films.
That said, Ichi is worth seeing, as are DOA-3, One Missed Call, Full Metal Yakuza, and the other lesser (I hesitate to say "throwaway") films. They are hilarious in their own way, if ultimately disposable ("Ichi" stands up to several viewings whereas the others really don't).
But these are not among the primo Miike, which IMO includes "Audition", "Ley Lines", "Rainy Dog", "Young Thugs: Nostalgia", "Visitor Q", "DOA", ""Bird People in China", "Katakuris", "Gozu", "Box". Any of these would be preferable to "Ichi", and "Audition" perhaps most of all.
"Audition" is one of his best. "Ichi" is one of his worst. "Audition" represents Miike at his most carefully calibrated with acute attention to tone, pacing and bizarro psychology not seen again until "Gozu" and "Box". The latter typifies the lazier aspects of Miike's filmmaking, becoming almost a parody of "extreme asian" and going through the motions with the pat, typical genre elements and special effects gross-outs taking the place of the more deeply perverse and transgressive elements of his best films.
That said, Ichi is worth seeing, as are DOA-3, One Missed Call, Full Metal Yakuza, and the other lesser (I hesitate to say "throwaway") films. They are hilarious in their own way, if ultimately disposable ("Ichi" stands up to several viewings whereas the others really don't).
But these are not among the primo Miike, which IMO includes "Audition", "Ley Lines", "Rainy Dog", "Young Thugs: Nostalgia", "Visitor Q", "DOA", ""Bird People in China", "Katakuris", "Gozu", "Box". Any of these would be preferable to "Ichi", and "Audition" perhaps most of all.
#25
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 2,429
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Shit... all that I just said, everything in my previous post, probably not relevant for a "Hostel" fan. I don't think either film will scratch that itch.
"Audition" will be far too serious a work with, you know, social and psychological implications. It also tries to tickle the cineaste in you by merging the traditional Japanese family melodrama a la Yasujiro Ozu with "Psycho"-era let's-completely-fuck-over-audience-expectations Hitchcock. It's a sucker punch telegraphed only by the viewer's foreknowledge that this is a Miike film.
"Ichi" will simply be too jokey for someone looking for "Hostel" like horror. Understand that "Ichi" isn't a horror film; "Ichi" is a comedy (and not a particularly funny one though it certainly has its moments). I'm not sure how "Ichi" became so notorious among the fanboys as the violence is hammy and played for laughs, and the most transgressive element is rote S&M. For all its scaldings with hot oil, tongue scissoring, and yakuza split in half scenes, it simply lacks the inherent perversity of the best Miike. It's not just inspired by manga; it's all comic book.
"Audition" will be far too serious a work with, you know, social and psychological implications. It also tries to tickle the cineaste in you by merging the traditional Japanese family melodrama a la Yasujiro Ozu with "Psycho"-era let's-completely-fuck-over-audience-expectations Hitchcock. It's a sucker punch telegraphed only by the viewer's foreknowledge that this is a Miike film.
"Ichi" will simply be too jokey for someone looking for "Hostel" like horror. Understand that "Ichi" isn't a horror film; "Ichi" is a comedy (and not a particularly funny one though it certainly has its moments). I'm not sure how "Ichi" became so notorious among the fanboys as the violence is hammy and played for laughs, and the most transgressive element is rote S&M. For all its scaldings with hot oil, tongue scissoring, and yakuza split in half scenes, it simply lacks the inherent perversity of the best Miike. It's not just inspired by manga; it's all comic book.
Last edited by Richard Malloy; 01-30-06 at 11:11 AM.