HELP! Philips 727 vs. Toshiba 3900
#26
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by badlieut
I looked at the Philips website and it mentioned something about a 4x video upsampling on the 727, but not on the 726. The 726 does not have a fiber optic out, only coax--not sure on the 727.
I looked at the Philips website and it mentioned something about a 4x video upsampling on the 727, but not on the 726. The 726 does not have a fiber optic out, only coax--not sure on the 727.
Got the 727 delivered today and it is SWEET! Plays everything I've got, great picture, surround, picture controls, etc. It isthe one to get. And no mod needed. I love it.
----------------
Noel
My Collection
#27
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Charleston, SC
Posts: 1,620
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by fnordboy
Just an FYI, my girlfriend has a 724 so I tryed the hack on it last night. While it hacks the region (1+1+1+1+0) and will do PAL to NTSC conversion...it can not handle anamorphic widescreen PAL discs, it will play them fullscreen. Otherwise the hack seems to work perfectly. Not that I needed another region free player anyway.
Just an FYI, my girlfriend has a 724 so I tryed the hack on it last night. While it hacks the region (1+1+1+1+0) and will do PAL to NTSC conversion...it can not handle anamorphic widescreen PAL discs, it will play them fullscreen. Otherwise the hack seems to work perfectly. Not that I needed another region free player anyway.
Originally posted by jblackie
Got the 727 delivered today and it is SWEET! Plays everything I've got, great picture, surround, picture controls, etc. It isthe one to get. And no mod needed. I love it.
Got the 727 delivered today and it is SWEET! Plays everything I've got, great picture, surround, picture controls, etc. It isthe one to get. And no mod needed. I love it.
#28
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by DVDude!
Thanks for the update jblackie. Just to make absolutely sure: the 727 (unlike the 724 mentioned by fnordboy above--thanks!) will handle anamorphic PAL discs correctly? Can you verify? Thanks!
Thanks for the update jblackie. Just to make absolutely sure: the 727 (unlike the 724 mentioned by fnordboy above--thanks!) will handle anamorphic PAL discs correctly? Can you verify? Thanks!
#29
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Just to make absolutely sure: the 727 (unlike the 724 mentioned by fnordboy above--thanks!) will handle anamorphic PAL discs correctly? Can you verify? Thanks!
#31
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Charleston, SC
Posts: 1,620
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by hellboyy
I tested the 727 on a Sony 27" 4x3 and anamorphic discs were letterboxed correctly. Have you ordered one yet, DVDude? Or are you still sitting on the fence?
I tested the 727 on a Sony 27" 4x3 and anamorphic discs were letterboxed correctly. Have you ordered one yet, DVDude? Or are you still sitting on the fence?
Originally posted by Franchot
Another affirmative on the anamorphic DVDs. I played "Dazed & Confused" from England (Region 2) which according to the back is 16x9 letterboxed and it played with no problems.
Another affirmative on the anamorphic DVDs. I played "Dazed & Confused" from England (Region 2) which according to the back is 16x9 letterboxed and it played with no problems.
Originally posted by Arthas76
is the 727 available at amazon the region free one still (i ask cuz this thread is so old)? if so what is the remote hack for it?
is the 727 available at amazon the region free one still (i ask cuz this thread is so old)? if so what is the remote hack for it?
Power on the unit, push the open/close button, via remote enter the code very slowly (9, 9, 9, 9, 0), push the open/close button, and then power off. Voila! You will change the player to play all DVDs (all regions).
I'm assuming that if you encounter an RCE disc that won't play due to the player being set for all regions, you can simply use 9, 9, 9, 9, 1 (or whatever region you need--0 will make it region-free, 2 will make it an R2 player, and so on).
I'm assuming that if you encounter an RCE disc that won't play due to the player being set for all regions, you can simply use 9, 9, 9, 9, 1 (or whatever region you need--0 will make it region-free, 2 will make it an R2 player, and so on).
Last edited by DVDude!; 09-12-03 at 03:18 AM.
#32
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Northern Virginia
Posts: 773
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by DVDude!
Thanks for the update jblackie. Just to make absolutely sure: the 727 (unlike the 724 mentioned by fnordboy above--thanks!) will handle anamorphic PAL discs correctly? Can you verify? Thanks!
Thanks for the update jblackie. Just to make absolutely sure: the 727 (unlike the 724 mentioned by fnordboy above--thanks!) will handle anamorphic PAL discs correctly? Can you verify? Thanks!
#34
Guest
Posts: n/a
The 727 has a zoom button to make the image two, three or four times larger. I have not tested this since virtually all of my DVD's are anamorphic and my Sony set has a zoom feature (which I choose to use instead).
According to the manual, zooming will not work on PAL DVD's.
According to the manual, zooming will not work on PAL DVD's.
#36
New Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Those of you in this thread have pretty much sold me on the 727. So now that I am ready to place an order, anyone care to "share the love" as it was put?
Thanks!
Thanks!
Originally posted by DVDude!
BTW, if anyone is buying the Philips from Amazon and wants to share the love with me, please do. I've almost decided that's the one to get. Almost.
Likewise, if anyone is planning on purchasing it soon, I'll share the love too.
BTW, if anyone is buying the Philips from Amazon and wants to share the love with me, please do. I've almost decided that's the one to get. Almost.
Likewise, if anyone is planning on purchasing it soon, I'll share the love too.
#38
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Charleston, SC
Posts: 1,620
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Arthas76
STL doesnt work for dvd players i think...
"Only products from Amazon.com through our book, music, video, and dvd stores are currently eligible for the Share the Love program"
STL doesnt work for dvd players i think...
"Only products from Amazon.com through our book, music, video, and dvd stores are currently eligible for the Share the Love program"
#39
New Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for the reply. Figured I would ask anyway.
According to Amazon, Office Depot has it, and there are always coupons for office depot floating around. However, when I went to OD's site I didn't see it listed there. This might help someone who might have it in their local store.
Thanks again for all the insight!
According to Amazon, Office Depot has it, and there are always coupons for office depot floating around. However, when I went to OD's site I didn't see it listed there. This might help someone who might have it in their local store.
Thanks again for all the insight!
Originally posted by Arthas76
STL doesnt work for dvd players i think...
"Only products from Amazon.com through our book, music, video, and dvd stores are currently eligible for the Share the Love program"
STL doesnt work for dvd players i think...
"Only products from Amazon.com through our book, music, video, and dvd stores are currently eligible for the Share the Love program"
#40
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by tashayar
Thanks for the reply. Figured I would ask anyway.
According to Amazon, Office Depot has it, and there are always coupons for office depot floating around. However, when I went to OD's site I didn't see it listed there. This might help someone who might have it in their local store.
Thanks again for all the insight!
Thanks for the reply. Figured I would ask anyway.
According to Amazon, Office Depot has it, and there are always coupons for office depot floating around. However, when I went to OD's site I didn't see it listed there. This might help someone who might have it in their local store.
Thanks again for all the insight!
http://www.thatscheap.com/office_depot_coupons.html
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Charleston, SC
Posts: 1,620
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well, my birthday isn't until next week (September 26), but last night my girlfriend surprised me with the Philips 727 sitting on our bed.
However, I immediately wondered why the Target sticker was torn (it explicitly states to check contents if the sticker is broken). She said that the Target guy said that someone had opened the box in the store and security had to check it and then reseal it. Okay, sounded good. So she bought it.
I opened it up and discovered that everything had been opened. The batteries were loose in the box. The twist-ties on the cords had been removed and put back. The manual had obviously been read. There was even a scuff on the front of the player. It was pretty apparent that this was a return.
Normally, I guess I wouldn't have minded--IF they had given her money off because it was an open box. In fact, she asked them to open it in the store, but they said that it was fine. It was the last one in stock, so she took a chance.
Well, it's going back to Target today and she's going to try to find another Target in the area that has one. (She wanted to get it locally instead of at Amazon.com in case it needs to be returned due to a defect.) Worst case scenario: I'll get it after my b-day 'cause it'll ship from Amazon.
However, I immediately wondered why the Target sticker was torn (it explicitly states to check contents if the sticker is broken). She said that the Target guy said that someone had opened the box in the store and security had to check it and then reseal it. Okay, sounded good. So she bought it.
I opened it up and discovered that everything had been opened. The batteries were loose in the box. The twist-ties on the cords had been removed and put back. The manual had obviously been read. There was even a scuff on the front of the player. It was pretty apparent that this was a return.
Normally, I guess I wouldn't have minded--IF they had given her money off because it was an open box. In fact, she asked them to open it in the store, but they said that it was fine. It was the last one in stock, so she took a chance.
Well, it's going back to Target today and she's going to try to find another Target in the area that has one. (She wanted to get it locally instead of at Amazon.com in case it needs to be returned due to a defect.) Worst case scenario: I'll get it after my b-day 'cause it'll ship from Amazon.
#42
Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just picked up the Philips 727 at Target for $80 (wife's employee discount) this past weekend. Am very happy with it overall with a few minor nitpicks - don't care for the red light on the front panel that constantly glows. Also, something really bizarre - there are no remote codes to control the Philips for my Sony remote on my 24" Vega (bizarre considering that Sony & Philips codeveloped the dvd).
Outside of those minor issues, the PQ is outstanding (seems on par with the SD3900). And while I never had issue with inputting the remote hack each time I played a non-R1 disc, it is very nice not to have to do this anymore with the Philips. Each of my non-R1 discs (all European R2 + PAL) play like their native. While all played on my SD3900, not only did I have to enter in the remote hack, I usually had to go through a myriad of hacks to get a couple of problem discs to play.
I big plus the Philips has over the SD3900 is that the 727 shows time remaining for films. All you need to do is hit 'Display', scroll down until you find 'Time Disp.' and change the setting to 'Title Remain'. It will now show the time remaining from then on.
So I'm very happy to have switched to the 727, even though I thought I preferred the quality of the Toshiba. But when I was at Target, I was given pause when I saw that Toshiba now released the SD-3950. Plus, the SD3950 lists for $79.99. So anyone who wants to take a risk (virtually none) can try to see if the 3950 corrects some of the 3900 problems.
Outside of those minor issues, the PQ is outstanding (seems on par with the SD3900). And while I never had issue with inputting the remote hack each time I played a non-R1 disc, it is very nice not to have to do this anymore with the Philips. Each of my non-R1 discs (all European R2 + PAL) play like their native. While all played on my SD3900, not only did I have to enter in the remote hack, I usually had to go through a myriad of hacks to get a couple of problem discs to play.
I big plus the Philips has over the SD3900 is that the 727 shows time remaining for films. All you need to do is hit 'Display', scroll down until you find 'Time Disp.' and change the setting to 'Title Remain'. It will now show the time remaining from then on.
So I'm very happy to have switched to the 727, even though I thought I preferred the quality of the Toshiba. But when I was at Target, I was given pause when I saw that Toshiba now released the SD-3950. Plus, the SD3950 lists for $79.99. So anyone who wants to take a risk (virtually none) can try to see if the 3950 corrects some of the 3900 problems.
#44
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Ok - this thread postively sent chills down my spine as I read it.
Get this: My birthday's the 25th. I will be 34 tomorrow and gee - guess what I was contemplating purchasing for my birthday?
A Toshiba 3900 - purely for the region-free capabilities.
But now that I've read through this thread, I'm considering the Phillips 727 player.
Does anyone know how this player handled the "Lord of the Rings: Two Towers" Ch. 51 bug? Does it play through that spot with no problems?
Thanks, much.
Get this: My birthday's the 25th. I will be 34 tomorrow and gee - guess what I was contemplating purchasing for my birthday?
A Toshiba 3900 - purely for the region-free capabilities.
But now that I've read through this thread, I'm considering the Phillips 727 player.
Does anyone know how this player handled the "Lord of the Rings: Two Towers" Ch. 51 bug? Does it play through that spot with no problems?
Thanks, much.
#45
Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
grunter,
played through ch. 51 twice last night to see if I could reproduce any problems...played absolutely fine.
Also, from what I've read about where the layer change is supposed to be, it was completely transparent on the 727 - no hiccup or noticeable at all. And with respect to a purported red flicker...none on the 727.
BTW...welcome to the 34 Club! Also remember that Target carries the 727 for $89.99 (price cut from $99.99...even BB carries the older 726 for $89.99). The Targets in the Twin Cities area seem to have been restocked with a fresh supply. So, if you're not entirely happy with the 727, you've got 3 months to return or exchange.
P.S. If you do ultimately choose the Toshiba over the Philips (I cannot think of any reason why...even though I really like the Tosh brand better), you might want to check out the updated SD3950, now sold at Target.
At the time I picked up the 727, I saw the new 3950 and was tempted. However, given its 'newness' (no info on its region-free capability on either DVDRHelp or Nerd-Out), you may not want to be the guinea pig.
played through ch. 51 twice last night to see if I could reproduce any problems...played absolutely fine.
Also, from what I've read about where the layer change is supposed to be, it was completely transparent on the 727 - no hiccup or noticeable at all. And with respect to a purported red flicker...none on the 727.
BTW...welcome to the 34 Club! Also remember that Target carries the 727 for $89.99 (price cut from $99.99...even BB carries the older 726 for $89.99). The Targets in the Twin Cities area seem to have been restocked with a fresh supply. So, if you're not entirely happy with the 727, you've got 3 months to return or exchange.
P.S. If you do ultimately choose the Toshiba over the Philips (I cannot think of any reason why...even though I really like the Tosh brand better), you might want to check out the updated SD3950, now sold at Target.
At the time I picked up the 727, I saw the new 3950 and was tempted. However, given its 'newness' (no info on its region-free capability on either DVDRHelp or Nerd-Out), you may not want to be the guinea pig.
Last edited by duofold; 09-25-03 at 07:58 AM.
#46
Senior Member
I bought a Toshiba 3900 as a second DVD player for the multi region capabliities. I then read about the 727. I returned the 3900, paid about $12 more for the philips (at Targer for $89+tax -didn't want to wait for amazon) and spun my region four DVDs without a problem. The best thing about this player is that it does not require multiple hackings, one is all it takes to make it region free. It does anamorphic beautifully and is one heck of a sweet deal!
#47
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Indy, IN
Posts: 578
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm really starting to love this player.
The interlaced output is significantly better than the JVCs. I noticed the box of the Philips mentions 3:2 pulldown. I couldn't find any info in the manual about this. I was curious if it was cadence reading or flag reading. The 2:3 motion test in DVE looks identical to my RP91. I tried to find some improperly flagged dvds to play on the 727. I want to see if it combs as this would suggest its a flag reader. The only one that came to mind was the R2 NTSC Tartan version of Battle Royale. Not combing at all. I'd like to test this more. Can anyone suggest other improperly flagged dics or other tests from discs. I've got all the DVE and Avia discs.
The interlaced output is significantly better than the JVCs. I noticed the box of the Philips mentions 3:2 pulldown. I couldn't find any info in the manual about this. I was curious if it was cadence reading or flag reading. The 2:3 motion test in DVE looks identical to my RP91. I tried to find some improperly flagged dvds to play on the 727. I want to see if it combs as this would suggest its a flag reader. The only one that came to mind was the R2 NTSC Tartan version of Battle Royale. Not combing at all. I'd like to test this more. Can anyone suggest other improperly flagged dics or other tests from discs. I've got all the DVE and Avia discs.
#48
Member
Join Date: Dec 2000
Posts: 140
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Incase some were wondering.... the philips 727 doesn't play DVD-R/-RW but does play DVD+R/+RW.
Edit: I was trying to be helpful and found this on another review. I guess it's wrong and the palyer plays this type too.
Edit: I was trying to be helpful and found this on another review. I guess it's wrong and the palyer plays this type too.
Last edited by ashegam; 10-07-03 at 01:31 PM.