DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   International DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/international-dvd-talk-12/)
-   -   Hero DVD China Release question (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/international-dvd-talk/275244-hero-dvd-china-release-question.html)

Jay G. 03-22-03 09:21 AM


Originally posted by chucky7
For those of you who are interest in a higher quality transfer of the movie, look no further than the just released R3 Hong Kong edition. In here, http://avbuzz.htfriends.net/so/hkhero/hkhero.htm
Ha! I like how they have printed on the disc the contents of the Hidden Menu.

chucky7 03-22-03 12:23 PM


Originally posted by Rex
Anyone know if there's going to be a version of the Hero DVD with a Cantonese audio track?
Why do you want Hero with a Cantonese audio track?
This is a Chinese movie!!!

axolotls return 03-22-03 01:01 PM

Cantonese is a Chinese dialect.... ho hum...

I wouldn't mind a cantonese dub on it. But, as people have pointed out to me the original language/dub is Mandarin.

Even so, Tony Leung's voice is dubbed into Mandarin for the movie.

Blah Blah Blah.. Whatever...

Rex 03-22-03 02:40 PM


Originally posted by chucky7
Why do you want Hero with a Cantonese audio track?
This is a Chinese movie!!!

So I can watch the movie without reading the subtitles. Not everyone understands Mandarin.

Jay G. 03-22-03 03:07 PM


Originally posted by Rex
So I can watch the movie without reading the subtitles. Not everyone understands Mandarin.
Why not ask for a English track? A dub's a dub.

If the HK disc doesn't have a Cantonese track, it's doubtful any of them will. However, Miramax will most likely provide an English dub when they release the R1 DVD.

Rex 03-22-03 06:02 PM


Originally posted by Jay G.
Why not ask for a English track? A dub's a dub.

Because the Miramax version is months away from being released and I'm looking for an HK version with a Cantonese audio track that's available now.

Jay G. 03-22-03 09:24 PM


Originally posted by Rex
Because the Miramax version is months away from being released and I'm looking for an HK version with a Cantonese audio track that's available now.
I take it your not an original soundtrack purist then. I also take it you wouldn't mind an English dub, as long as you don't have to read subtitles.

An English dub on a HK disc is not unheard of. The original CTHD R3 DVD has both Cantonese and English dubs.

However, in the case of HERO, it appears that neither are on the HK DVD. www.dddhouse.com , www.dvdshelf.com , www.hivizone.com , and www.sensasian.com all show Mandarin as the only language track on the recently released R3 2-disc version.

Gunde 03-25-03 01:44 AM

If anyone's interested the 2-disk edition is available at www.cd-wow.com

tinlunlau 03-26-03 08:01 PM

there's an english dub on Megastar's "Iron Monkey" dvd.

dleedlee 03-27-03 07:39 AM


Originally posted by axolotls return
Cantonese is a Chinese dialect.... ho hum...

I wouldn't mind a cantonese dub on it. But, as people have pointed out to me the original language/dub is Mandarin.

Even so, Tony Leung's voice is dubbed into Mandarin for the movie.

Blah Blah Blah.. Whatever...

I think Maggie Cheung's voice was dubbed too.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:05 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.