Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
I decided to start this thread after noticing a trend that is a bit unsettling. Recently I have received various brand new disc sets of both bd and 4k discs with scratches on them. Today I bought 6 movies and after inspecting the sets, I noticed that 4 of them had scratches on one or more of the discs. The scratches also seem to be very similar from disc to disc. There are usually three scratches with the one in the middle being the longer one and the one on each side being about half the length of it. Aside from those (raptor) scratches, I'm also seeing more gunk or dirtiness on some discs. I just wanted to post to see if anyone else is seeing this and how you are approaching the issue. We can inspect the outside of our sets for dings, slashes or other damage, but we can't do much ahead of time to know what shape the discs are going to be in.
Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent 4k (The bd had gunk on the readable part around the inner circle. The 4k looks fine.)
The Bad Guys 4k (The 4k disc has the 3 scratches on them. The bd looks fine.)
Red Rocket bd (The disc looks fine.)
Citizen Kane 4k (Aside from the piss poor choice of packaging for the discs, the 4k and bd disc 3 both had scratches.)
Shaft 4k (The 4k appears fine. bd disc 1 has several scratches together from the outer circle inwards. Disc 2 looks fine.)
Pink Flamingos bd (The disc has one scratch in the middle of the readable area running across the disc.)
So, with higher prices and such, this is disappointing.
Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent 4k (The bd had gunk on the readable part around the inner circle. The 4k looks fine.)
The Bad Guys 4k (The 4k disc has the 3 scratches on them. The bd looks fine.)
Red Rocket bd (The disc looks fine.)
Citizen Kane 4k (Aside from the piss poor choice of packaging for the discs, the 4k and bd disc 3 both had scratches.)
Shaft 4k (The 4k appears fine. bd disc 1 has several scratches together from the outer circle inwards. Disc 2 looks fine.)
Pink Flamingos bd (The disc has one scratch in the middle of the readable area running across the disc.)
So, with higher prices and such, this is disappointing.
#2
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Are the scratches etched (deep) or are they merely scuffs and removable? Is playback affected? Concentric, deep radial deep scratches are worrisome, although my experience has been limited to fingerprints and some glue, all of which have been removable. My new copy of SHAFT appears perfect without any scratches, scuffs, or fingerprints, thankfully. Other recent purchases of CAT'S EYE and ESCAPE FROM NEW YORK UHDs were also pristine. Many recent problems have been related to botched transfers and encoding problems (many of which were thankfully fixed by recalls), not on the physical media itself.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Yes, the scratches are deep and not removable. I'm hoping to go through each one as soon as I can, but it is still a nuisance. I'm hoping there are no playback problems.
#4
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Doesn't help matters when they have to be shipped to customers, since stores continue to close and those who still stock them keep reducing their selection.
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (07-05-22)
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
I just complained about that Citizen Kane set on another site. Trying to get a disc out to watch without having to grip the disc itself is impossible. I would have likely not bought the set if I knew how it was. Sometimes cool ideas should stay ideas.
#7
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
This is not a recent thing / botch.
This seem to be a common thing with giant multidisc sets such as tv shows. For example, such as those tv shows released in giant 24+ discs cases released by ViacomCBS, Universal, etc ....
This seem to be a common thing with giant multidisc sets such as tv shows. For example, such as those tv shows released in giant 24+ discs cases released by ViacomCBS, Universal, etc ....
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
I have no idea why some studios do this. I know the All About Eve release by Criterion had awful packaging as well. What's so wrong just having it in their normal clear HD keep case?
The following users liked this post:
John Pannozzi (07-05-22)
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
My Citizen Kane UHD and BDs will not play on my 4K player, The BD will also not play on my PS3 or PS4. I don't see any scratches on either and have wiped them both off with a micro fiber cloth. Still the UHD locks up at a little over four minutes and the BD around three minutes. My 4K player is a piece of junk though. I have a Sony and the only format that it plays flawlessly is SACD. I will keep it for that and plan on getting a Panasonic next month. I have never had a BD not play on the PS3 or PS4 before. I guess the packaging for Citizen Kane is the problem.
#10
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
My Citizen Kane UHD and BDs will not play on my 4K player, The BD will also not play on my PS3 or PS4. I don't see any scratches on either and have wiped them both off with a micro fiber cloth. Still the UHD locks up at a little over four minutes and the BD around three minutes. My 4K player is a piece of junk though. I have a Sony and the only format that it plays flawlessly is SACD. I will keep it for that and plan on getting a Panasonic next month. I have never had a BD not play on the PS3 or PS4 before. I guess the packaging for Citizen Kane is the problem.
#11
Senior Member
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Scratched discs have become a common problem for me for over a year now. I was returning and getting replacements, sometimes 2 or 3 times with the same movie just to get an unscratched copy. I recently downloaded a program called VSO Inspector, it will scan the discs for surface damage and then scan the individual files on the disc to check for errors. It seems to be pretty accurate so far so I'm starting to let it slide as far as returns: if it scans at 100% and I play it with no problems I'll just keep it. It really is ridiculous to have to settle, but I order a lot of discs and having to constantly mail back returns and still getting another scratched disc is just too much of a hassle.
#12
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Just around the corner to the light of day.
Posts: 16,011
Received 1,057 Likes
on
660 Posts
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
My 4K player is a piece of junk though. I have a Sony and the only format that it plays flawlessly is SACD. I will keep it for that and plan on getting a Panasonic next month. I have never had a BD not play on the PS3 or PS4 before. I guess the packaging for Citizen Kane is the problem.
There's a great thread you can google called "4K Players are Junk" that are tracking these player issues.
To be honest, this and vertical banding on 4k TVs really have me holding off jumping into the new format. Well, I say it's new but it has now been a few years with these issues!
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Which SONY? I am about to purchase my first 4k Player and have been reading online about multiple players and brands having freezing issues on BD-100 discs at around the 2 hour mark (which I gather is an issue with the layer changes?).
There's a great thread you can google called "4K Players are Junk" that are tracking these player issues.
To be honest, this and vertical banding on 4k TVs really have me holding off jumping into the new format. Well, I say it's new but it has now been a few years with these issues!
There's a great thread you can google called "4K Players are Junk" that are tracking these player issues.
To be honest, this and vertical banding on 4k TVs really have me holding off jumping into the new format. Well, I say it's new but it has now been a few years with these issues!
#15
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Just around the corner to the light of day.
Posts: 16,011
Received 1,057 Likes
on
660 Posts
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Yeah, I was also reading the one step above 800 has issues. Urgh.
I think I am just purchasing 4k discs now (with their Bluray counterparts included) biding my time.
I purchased 2 4k sets in the past but returned them due to banding.
Now that I am looking to dive back in this whole player freezing shit is turning me off.
Though the Sony A80J 55 inch BRAVIA XR OLED issssss $400 off at the moment and a tempting want for my first 4K set.
I think I am just purchasing 4k discs now (with their Bluray counterparts included) biding my time.
I purchased 2 4k sets in the past but returned them due to banding.
Now that I am looking to dive back in this whole player freezing shit is turning me off.
Though the Sony A80J 55 inch BRAVIA XR OLED issssss $400 off at the moment and a tempting want for my first 4K set.

#16
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Damaged discs straight from the manufacturer.
Sony x700 I think. It is junk. I have never been able to get past the scene in Jaws where Brody receives the call about the girl's body washing up on shore. Each of the three Back To The Future discs pixelate around ten minutes in and all six discs of the LOTR set lock up around ten minutes left. Avoid that player at all costs.