DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Red Cliff Blu ray which edition? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/570537-red-cliff-blu-ray-edition.html)

whotony 03-22-10 12:40 AM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
^ that should say 2 hrs and 25 minutes, and it is in sd and looks pretty crappy.(almost 2 and a half hours)

I just watched all 5 hours and it was great.
this is the US release, unrated uncut.
Looked fine to me but I'm sure someone will be able to find something wrong.

RocShemp 03-22-10 12:59 AM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by whotony (Post 10062734)
^ that should say 2 hrs and 25 minutes, and it is in sd and looks pretty crappy.(almost 2 and a half hours)

I just watched all 5 hours and it was great.
this is the US release.
Looked fine to me but I'm sure someone will be able to find something wrong.

Too bad the doc's not in HD and place on a separate disc.

I liked the screenshots I saw for the US theatrical cut so, if the international cut looks just as good, I'm not worried about the transfer.

How's the audio?

whotony 03-22-10 01:05 AM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
Audio was very good.
Plenty of rumble and subtle sounds throughout.

RocShemp 03-22-10 01:23 AM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by whotony (Post 10062758)
Audio was very good.
Plenty of rumble and subtle sounds throughout.

Great to read that it caters to the quiet and loud ends of the spectrum. :up:

I can't wait for my copy to arrive. :D

truelies 03-22-10 01:51 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
Good to hear this. Waiting for my copy from Amazon.


Originally Posted by whotony (Post 10062734)
^ that should say 2 hrs and 25 minutes, and it is in sd and looks pretty crappy.(almost 2 and a half hours)

I just watched all 5 hours and it was great.
this is the US release.
Looked fine to me but I'm sure someone will be able to find something wrong.


jjcool 03-22-10 02:56 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by truelies (Post 10060132)
I UK one is out of order for international. The "in stock" means only for UK. I am wondering if the US one is same as UK, since the publisher of the US has a bad reputation.

Interesting. Too bad I didnt see your message sooner, as my preorder for the american release has shipped, and the UK edition has shipped as well. We'll see what reviews say before I determine which one to keep.

RocShemp 03-22-10 03:20 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
Mine hasn't shipped yet. :(

RocShemp 03-22-10 04:06 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
So Magnolia is releasing four versions? There's an International Version and a Theatrical Version in addition to their releasing Part I and Part II separately.

Yeah, that wont confuse people. :rolleyes:

BuckNaked2k 03-22-10 07:27 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
Has anyone seen a better price on the international version than Amazon's $25+?

Thanks.

RocShemp 03-22-10 07:34 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
The UK version is cheaper. Though I don't think $25.49 is too much to ask for a nigh 5 hour movie.

Solid Snake 03-22-10 07:41 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
Can anyone fully confirm if the international cut has that feature length "making of" Doc that the Theatrical has?

RocShemp 03-22-10 11:23 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
My copy just shipped! :banana:

truelies 03-23-10 08:17 AM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10064400)
The UK version is cheaper. Though I don't think $25.49 is too much to ask for a nigh 5 hour movie.

I agree, the $25.49 actually for two movies. In china it was released part 1 first, after 6 months came out part 2.

scarface983 03-23-10 12:09 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
got mine today :) will watch tonight

jjcool 03-23-10 12:27 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
My copy from Amazon.com is sitting on my doorstep right now. Anyone see any comparisons between the UK international version, and the US international version? Thsi one: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Cliff-Specia...9365185&sr=8-1 and this one: http://www.amazon.com/Red-Cliff-Inte...9365247&sr=8-1

truelies 03-23-10 12:46 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by scarface983 (Post 10065761)
got mine today :) will watch tonight

Mine will be in tomorrow. You are lucky than me.

slop101 03-23-10 01:17 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
Fry's had one copy of the Int.cut (and one copy of the edited version), and it was unwrapped - it had the sticker-seal on top, but no plastic wrap. The discs were still in there though. I picked it up, it was only $24.

RocShemp 03-23-10 01:52 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
You guys are lucky Amazon says I should get mine by the 27th which means I'll get it by the 28th at the soonest. :sad:

jjcool 03-23-10 02:15 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 10065972)
Fry's had one copy of the Int.cut (and one copy of the edited version), and it was unwrapped - it had the sticker-seal on top, but no plastic wrap. The discs were still in there though. I picked it up, it was only $24.

My preordered copy from Amazon came the same way. No wrap, but stickers on the front and across the top.

scarface983 03-23-10 04:23 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by jjcool (Post 10066100)
My preordered copy from Amazon came the same way. No wrap, but stickers on the front and across the top.

Mine too, i thought it was mine only.

truelies 03-23-10 08:35 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
I checked the case, the international one includes all the features of theatre edition. But the theatrical one has English audio.

Solid Snake 03-23-10 08:49 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
badass...it's soooo mine.

Joe Molotov 03-23-10 09:55 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 

Originally Posted by scarface983 (Post 10066456)
Mine too, i thought it was mine only.

From Amazon.com:

Please note: This product may not be shrink wrapped.

Steve 03-23-10 10:03 PM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
I was surprised that on Best Buy's site Both the SD and BD versions cost the exact same $.

Isn't unusual? Don't BR normally cost at least a LITTLE more than SD?

Solid Snake 03-24-10 11:02 AM

Re: Red Cliff Blu ray which edition?
 
On amazon..BR cost less than the SD sometimes...which is a great selling point.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:53 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.