I know that there is a "sticky" for Blu Ray recommendations, but I'm curious as to what you guys have in your collection and what you deem to be your best Blu Rays overall (sound, picture etc)?

The Dark Knight
Star Trek 2009
Red Cliff Pts. 1 & 2
30 days of night (Visuals)
North by Northwest
Pirates of the Caribbean (all 3 films)
Moon

These are the titles I can think of at the moment. I'll repost when I've done a more extensive review of my discs.

2001: A Space Odyssey
Baraka
Planet Earth
Star Trek

Band of Brothers (I don't know, maybe its just me so far)
Rome - The Complete Series
Red Cliff I & II
Battlestar Gallactica - Complete Series
Once Upon A Time in the West
Wall-E (at least visually & sound, not so much content)

I'm not sure really, someone else would have to tell me.

Baraka
Watchmen

all the Pixar BDs
007
Close Encounters of the Third Kind- great movie and the a/v is great for a 30+ year old movie

To add:
UP
The Wizard of Oz
Amadeus
Transformers: Revenge of The Fallen

Crank
The Fall
Watchmen
Up
The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight
Underworld (First One) Extended
Monsters, Inc
Band of Brothers
Cars

I have Up but haven't got around to watching it yet.

(I really need to get Band of Brothers...saw an episode of it when it came out only to love it and for some fucking reason I've yet to get it)

Enter The Dragon
The Dark Knight
Any Pixar flick
Disney flicks
The Third Man (OOP but Criterion had it perfected for sure w/ this)
Leon
Star Trek
District 9
Watchmen (in whatever Blu form)
Heat

Lost S1-S5

Perfection!

How has Blade Runner NOT been mentioned, seriously?

I love that movie to death, but I was not impressed by the Blu Ray quality. The sound did nothing for me and the picture lacked the film look that it should have had.

The Dark Knight (IMAX scenes)
Blade Runner
Anything Pixar
The Incredible Hulk
District 9 (this is the first movie in which the Red One really impressed me)
Indiana Jones 4
Snatch
Hellboy II

LOST S1-5
Ratatouille
Zodiac
Star Trek: TOS: S1
Gone With the Wind UCE
Hot Fuzz
North by Northwest
Mad Men S1-2
Sleeping Beauty
Planet of the Apes Collection

Agree with every single title. And it must be noted that "The Incredible Hulk" is the loudest movie I've ever experienced. In the theater and at home. Which makes it THE "go to" Blu-Ray I demo to friends for the sound alone! Love the film too.

Wow. Ok, I know there was a whole heap of blather about the "lens flare" fest in Trek but, this is the first I've heard about the audio/video on the BD not being up to par. I've cranked this film on at least 3 occasions and my HT has yet to underwhelm me! Obviously, I thought the film was stellar in every department but to each his own. I do however, agree with the balance of your assertions and will add, Watchmen to my list as well. Its been a while since I watched Blade Runner on BD though. I can remember it being an incredible presentation but I'd have to re-watch it to see how it rates next to the other titles I've listed.

Apoclypto (still remains near the top)
300
Sleeping Beauty (for some nice 2D art)
Wall-e (for some nice 3D art)
Planet Earth

Well, yes, the lens flares bother me, but that doesn't have anything to do with the Blu Ray presentation. I've watched it once on Blu Ray, maybe my opinion will change with a second viewing. I just wasn't impressed by the Blu Ray quality. It's not demo material like Pixar movies, Blade Runner, and The Dark Knight (IMAX).