DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/549958-i-am-not-seeing-much-difference-between-blueray-discs-dvds.html)

Ninhydrin 02-15-09 12:49 PM

I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
I am relatively new to blueray and to be honest I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs Im obviously running them through the same player (S350) but Im just not seeing this huge difference in PQ, the only difference I see is the price that I am buying them for is relatively higher than DVD.

jones 02-15-09 01:02 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
What kind of cable are you using? HDMI?
Do you have a TV with 1080p resolution?
Did you set the Sony's reolution to auto or 1080p?

cgray 02-15-09 01:05 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
... or is this thread title unnecessarily vague?

Ninhydrin 02-15-09 01:21 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
Jones:

Using gold plated HDMI
Samsung 46A656 set to 1080p 24 and manual settings
DVD is set to 1080p

Cgray:

Apologies if it upset you in any way

dx23 02-15-09 01:24 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
What blu-ray player you are using?

Ninhydrin 02-15-09 01:26 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
DX23

It is the sony BDP-S350

fumanstan 02-15-09 01:28 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
What movies have you tried? There are a bunch of Blu-ray's that don't look much different from their DVD counterparts, but there are also ones that look far better.

Ninhydrin 02-15-09 01:34 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
Fumanstan:

I dont have a huge collection at the mo but the ones I have:

Transformers
300 (best picture I have seen)
Ironman
Departed
Cloverfield
SpeedRacer
Hancock
Casino Royale
Batman Begins
Dumb and Dumber
Pineapple Express
Mamma Mia

I just feel that the DVDs I have that are upscaled to 1080p are just as good a picture, I know Im not comparing them 1 to 1 as I dont have anything on both formats, maybe I should have done this first!

Bookhouseboy 02-15-09 01:57 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
On my 92" screen, Blu-ray's obviously look better -- but, and there is a big but (no pun intended) -- a poor Blu-ray won't look much better than a DVD.

I'll probably watch 70% Blu-ray in the coming years, but I definitely can understand people who are underwhelmed by this so-called revolutionary technology. Those who expect the same leap between DVD and Blu-ray as the leap between VHS and DVD will be disappointed.

Ninhydrin:
If you have both the DVD and Blu-ray version of a movie, try switching between them, and I'm sure you'll see a difference in PQ. Good luck.

LickTheABCs 02-15-09 02:46 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
Try watching one of those fancy CGI movies people tend to think look all pretty.

djmont 02-15-09 03:08 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
I've watched 10 or so Blu-rays since we got the player last month. The least of them look marginally better than upconverted DVDs, but the best I've seen (The Dark Knight, for example) are breathtaking. (It's possible that your TV isn't calibrated as well as it could be.)

LickTheABCs 02-15-09 03:15 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
First and most importantly, take the TV off Torch mode.

Pizza 02-15-09 03:30 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
Judging by what other posters are saying, I guess it isn't just you. As for me, I see a big difference and I feel it's a bigger jump than VHS to DVD. Nice leap in sound quality too.

bunkaroo 02-15-09 04:21 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 

Originally Posted by LickTheABCs (Post 9268352)
First and most importantly, take the TV off Torch mode.

Artificial sharpening isn't going to help either, and that stuff is almost always on by default in my experience.

Gosh I hate default TV settings. :)

dx23 02-15-09 05:53 PM

re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
There must be something wrong with the settings. With the setup you have, you should see a noticeable difference and improvement from DVD to BD. What films are you watching?

dsa_shea 02-15-09 07:04 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
Another one of these threads already? Can't we sticky a Blu-Ray isn't much better than dvd thread so that these things can go there? I understand that some people don't see "much improvement" in the video quality and it usually comes down to not having the right settings or too high of expectations for what Blu-Ray is supposed to be.

Fielding Mellish 02-15-09 07:06 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
https://www.healthcare.utah.edu/heal...echart-150.jpg

eXcentris 02-15-09 08:22 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
Some people see a big difference, some don't. Personally, I notice the difference in sound much more than the difference in PQ. I just wish people would stop assuming that "there's something wrong with your eyes or your settings or your equipment" when this alleged BIG difference isn't noticed...

SonOfAStu 02-15-09 08:31 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
It's not "alleged". It's there. I have no doubt that some may not notice it, or just don't know what they're looking for, but to say it's "alleged" is borderline retarded.

Robert 02-15-09 09:10 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 

Originally Posted by Ninhydrin (Post 9268206)

I dont have a huge collection at the mo but the ones I have:

Transformers
300 (best picture I have seen)
Ironman
Departed
Cloverfield
SpeedRacer
Hancock
Casino Royale
Batman Begins
Dumb and Dumber
Pineapple Express
Mamma Mia

I just feel that the DVDs I have that are upscaled to 1080p are just as good a picture, I know Im not comparing them 1 to 1 as I dont have anything on both formats, maybe I should have done this first!

Rent <b>The Departed</b> on DVD and compare it to the blu-ray. The SD version(especially the first 30-45 minutes) looks god-awful compared to the blu-ray which is crystal clear.

Snowmaker 02-15-09 09:22 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
When is the last time you've gone to the eye doctor? :D

dsa_shea 02-15-09 09:30 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 

Originally Posted by Ninhydrin (Post 9268206)
Fumanstan:

I dont have a huge collection at the mo but the ones I have:

Transformers
300 (best picture I have seen)
Ironman
Departed
Cloverfield
SpeedRacer
Hancock
Casino Royale
Batman Begins
Dumb and Dumber
Pineapple Express
Mamma Mia

I just feel that the DVDs I have that are upscaled to 1080p are just as good a picture, I know Im not comparing them 1 to 1 as I dont have anything on both formats, maybe I should have done this first!

Consider yourself lucky. Many of the people on here would love to be able to go back and erase that SD purchase now that they own it on BD. At least you haven't fallen victim to the Double Dip. Now you can go out and spend that money you saved on other stuff or even more Blu-Rays. Trust when it is said that Blu-Ray is better in both video and audio than anything you will get in SD.

fumanstan 02-15-09 09:41 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
I think as others have mentioned, that the big difference comes when you watch a DVD and then the Blu-ray after. When I got Pirates of the Caribbean on Blu-ray I popped in the old DVD I had and the difference was remarkable. It was like I didn't realize the DVD looked that bad until I saw how great it was on Blu-ray.

DarthVong 02-15-09 09:48 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
There are some BDs that aren't much better in PQ that an upscaled DVD. However, there is a good difference in audio on most all BDs. I've noticed a huge difference in some Bds PQ and it was enough that now when I watch a SD I noticed the flaws in the PQ.

RobLutter 02-15-09 11:07 PM

Re: I am not seeing much difference between Blueray discs and DVDs
 
If you don't see the difference... don't buy them. It's obviously not for you.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:36 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.