DVD on SDTV vs. DVD on HDTV
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
DVD on SDTV vs. DVD on HDTV
Am I the only one who thinks that DVDs look better on a SD Tube TV compared to "upscaled" dvd on an HDTV?
I never understood why people keep saying that "upscaled" dvds on HDTV look so good...when honestly, they look a bit sharper on an SDTV. Similar to how non-HD tv programming looks worse on an HDTV vs. a sd tv, I think the same applies to DVD.
Not that DVD looks bad on an HDTV, but an SDTV tube seems to hide the flaws of DVD better.
I never understood why people keep saying that "upscaled" dvds on HDTV look so good...when honestly, they look a bit sharper on an SDTV. Similar to how non-HD tv programming looks worse on an HDTV vs. a sd tv, I think the same applies to DVD.
Not that DVD looks bad on an HDTV, but an SDTV tube seems to hide the flaws of DVD better.
#2
DVD Talk Legend
PArt of that equation is that the tube or SDTVs tend to be smaller than HDTVs. Tubes would go up to 36" where the majority of primary TVs in the household are now much larger usually 42" and up. I remember when I had a 27" TV and considered it a big screen TV. The larger the TV, the worse inferior material will look. I remember when I got my 48" RPTV up from 27" how crappy cable looked. It's one of the pitfalls of the larger TV.
#3
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 1,169
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Also, DVDs were engineered for tube television sets. Just like Blu-ray was engineered for HDTVs. DVDs should look better on SD TVs, but you have to sacrifice size, and if you sit far enough, a DVD will tend to look pretty good on an HDTV.
#4
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
True, and watching older TV shows on DVD (such as the Star Trek shows, as they are often the most popular example of this) look fantastic on a CRT TV, as that is what they were (likely) viewed on when in the post-production phase and what audiences saw them on when broadcast for many years. On an LCD they look disgusting, and on a Plasma they look the slightest bit better than LCD, but not much.
I looked at a few episodes of DS9 upscaled on an LCD and Plasma using a PS3 and the results were more film-like and grainy, and hid the compression artifacts and aliasing better. Still not as good as on a tube TV, but an improvement nonetheless.
I looked at a few episodes of DS9 upscaled on an LCD and Plasma using a PS3 and the results were more film-like and grainy, and hid the compression artifacts and aliasing better. Still not as good as on a tube TV, but an improvement nonetheless.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Am I the only one who thinks that DVDs look better on a SD Tube TV compared to "upscaled" dvd on an HDTV?
I never understood why people keep saying that "upscaled" dvds on HDTV look so good...when honestly, they look a bit sharper on an SDTV. Similar to how non-HD tv programming looks worse on an HDTV vs. a sd tv, I think the same applies to DVD.
Not that DVD looks bad on an HDTV, but an SDTV tube seems to hide the flaws of DVD better.
I never understood why people keep saying that "upscaled" dvds on HDTV look so good...when honestly, they look a bit sharper on an SDTV. Similar to how non-HD tv programming looks worse on an HDTV vs. a sd tv, I think the same applies to DVD.
Not that DVD looks bad on an HDTV, but an SDTV tube seems to hide the flaws of DVD better.
I have an Oppo player connected to a 50-inch Sony SXRD HDTV via HDMI. DVDs look very, very good.
#6
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's going to be partly dependent on the equipment used. Not all upconverting DVD players are created equally, and people who think they're going to get great quality out of a $40 player will sometimes be disappointed.
I have an Oppo player connected to a 50-inch Sony SXRD HDTV via HDMI. DVDs look very, very good.
I have an Oppo player connected to a 50-inch Sony SXRD HDTV via HDMI. DVDs look very, very good.
Is this common, for DVDs to look better on rear projection compared to LCD?
Both played on a ps3, upscaled.
#7
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't know about what they look like on rear projection TVs, but LCDs reveal each and every flaw in the image, which is why some standard DVDs and most definitely standard cable TV looks so poor, compression artifacts everywhere...the image is simply too sharp and that has little to do with the sharpness settings on the LCD being watched.
#8
DVD Talk Hero
True, and watching older TV shows on DVD (such as the Star Trek shows, as they are often the most popular example of this) look fantastic on a CRT TV, as that is what they were (likely) viewed on when in the post-production phase and what audiences saw them on when broadcast for many years. On an LCD they look disgusting, and on a Plasma they look the slightest bit better than LCD, but not much.
I looked at a few episodes of DS9 upscaled on an LCD and Plasma using a PS3 and the results were more film-like and grainy, and hid the compression artifacts and aliasing better. Still not as good as on a tube TV, but an improvement nonetheless.
I looked at a few episodes of DS9 upscaled on an LCD and Plasma using a PS3 and the results were more film-like and grainy, and hid the compression artifacts and aliasing better. Still not as good as on a tube TV, but an improvement nonetheless.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Quality of the TVs factors into this. What kind of DLP? What kind of LCD? I mean hell, DVDs look better on my 106" DLP FP setup than they do on my friends 32" Poloroid LCD due to just how horrible Poloroid LCDs are.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
I think DVDs look fantastic on my 52" Sharp Aquos. Its black levels also hold up fairly well to my old Sony 36" tube TV. I definitely prefer them upscaled on my larger HDTV.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
I'm oversimplifying however I think you'll get the point. Rear Projection will not be as accurate as your LCD therefore, your LCD will actually show more of the bad stuff. Also settings come in to play. Were either TV set up? Are the settings still on factory torch mode? Your LCD was set with the contrast and sharpness jacked all the way up. That will make even the best HiDef disc look like a blocky mess once the TV is in a small room instread of a showroom.