DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Blu-ray Sales Figures Discussion (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/530152-blu-ray-sales-figures-discussion.html)

Mr. Cinema 04-23-08 08:23 AM

Blu-ray Sales Figures Discussion
 
There's no place to put numbers, so I decided to create a specific thread to discuss sales. Let's start off with this article from the Hollywood Reporter.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20080423/tc_nm/bluray_dc_2

"In the first quarter this year, 4.9 million next-gen movies were sold, 3.8 million of which were Blu-ray. That's half of the 9.8 million copies of 536 different titles that have been sold in the U.S. since the inception of Blu-ray and HD DVD."

That's a pretty good start. Q4 should be huge with Iron Man, Dark Knight, Narnia 2, Indy 4 doing well. Not sure how well Q2 is going to be. There doesn't seem to be many marquee titles scheduled the next couple of months. Hopefully Universal and Paramount can provide a boost when their titles show up in Q3.

Adam Tyner 04-23-08 08:38 AM

Q2 sales could be interesting -- April has been pretty sparse, and out of the entirety of May, there are really only two big titles: Rambo and National Treasure 2. I'm only really planning on picking up Butch Cassidy... that entire month, and even then I might hold off for a sale since the master reportedly looks pretty lousy.

Mr. Cinema 04-23-08 09:14 AM


Originally Posted by Adam Tyner
Q2 sales could be interesting -- April has been pretty sparse, and out of the entirety of May, there are really only two big titles: Rambo and National Treasure 2. I'm only really planning on picking up Butch Cassidy... that entire month, and even then I might hold off for a sale since the master reportedly looks pretty lousy.

I completely forgot about National Treasure 2. I think that has a chance to move 150K copies. I think Rambo will do better than expected.

May and June seem to have alot of catalog titles. I'll definitely be buying my share. Master & Commander, National Treasure, Twister, Patton, V for Vendetta, Dirty Harry, Signs, and Men in Black will be definite purchases.

bunkaroo 04-23-08 09:37 AM

I saw the Nielsen numbers for last week were 84:16. Didn't see any individual title numbers though.

Gizmo 04-23-08 09:59 AM


Originally Posted by bunkaroo
I saw the Nielsen numbers for last week were 84:16. Didn't see any individual title numbers though.

I did see them...but can't find them now. I Am Legend was #1 and Over America moved up the number #7 spot. I don't think anyone on this board even owns that title so it must be selling to people that need a quick cheap HD fix to show off to their friends.

Edit: Found it


Top 10 Blu-ray w/e 04/13/08:

1. I Am Legend 100.00
2. Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story 70.69
3. The Water Horse: The Legend of the Deep 60.55
4. Alvin and the Chipmunks 44.08
5. No Country for Old Men 42.60
6. Planet Earth 42.08
7. Over America 35.84
8. 300 25.66
9. Enchanted 25.48
10. Pirates of the Caribbean: AWE 19.87
http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c2.../snap007-1.jpg http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c2.../snap006-2.jpg

Considering Blu-ray once again sold 8:1 over HD DVD...I don't see how that SI has yet to move.

The Bus 04-23-08 10:18 AM

I think you also have to think about when more players will enter homes. The PS3 is going to be the main driver of sales for at least the rest of this year, and it will only sell more once the big titles for it come out (MGS4, GTA4).

kefrank 04-23-08 10:57 AM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
Considering Blu-ray once again sold 8:1 over HD DVD...I don't see how that SI has yet to move.

agreed. especially if the volume numbers in that hollywood reporter article are true. the two just don't jive at all.

kvrdave 04-23-08 11:03 AM

I hope the studios don't screw themselves if they aren't happy with the numbers. There is a lot I would like to buy, but it isn't out. :shrug:

Yavin 04-23-08 11:09 AM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
I completely forgot about National Treasure 2. I think that has a chance to move 150K copies. I think Rambo will do better than expected.

May and June seem to have alot of catalog titles. I'll definitely be buying my share. Master & Commander, National Treasure, Twister, Patton, V for Vendetta, Dirty Harry, Signs, and Men in Black will be definite purchases.

I'm definitely looking forward to National Treasure, National Treasure: Book of Secrets, Batman Begins, Gotham Knight, and Starship Troopers (with a new Profile 1.1 PiP track, I believe); as well as Knocked Up, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, The Dark Knight, Iron Man, Hellboy: The Golden Army, Cloverfield, and Hancock, all of which I am assuming will be streeting in Q4 and should move a fair number of units each.

Mr. Cinema 04-23-08 12:17 PM

Got these numbers from Grubert:

Q4 2007 BD sales: 3.1 million

Q1 2007 BD sales: 830,000

Gizmo 04-23-08 03:21 PM


Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Got these numbers from Grubert:

Q4 2007 BD sales: 3.1 million

Q1 2007 BD sales: 830,000


Keep in mind its been a year and that's a couple extra million PS3s sold as well, even at the new lower $400 price. Its almost a duhh that sales would be higher.

Adam Tyner 04-23-08 03:37 PM

Still, that's a pretty dramatic increase.

Gizmo 04-23-08 05:39 PM

Holidays typically will have a huge raise in sales anyway. We had many big titles come out in Q4 then Q1. But a few million extras players sold also help. Q4 also had weekly BOGOs as well. I know I personally bought at least 50 movies in Q4.

chanster 04-23-08 05:47 PM

I would like to know if they included the Spiderman bundled in with the PS3. Sometimes thats done.

kefrank 04-23-08 06:07 PM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
Holidays typically will have a huge raise in sales anyway. We had many big titles come out in Q4 then Q1. But a few million extras players sold also help. Q4 also had weekly BOGOs as well. I know I personally bought at least 50 movies in Q4.

It would be interesting to see the revenue numbers for comparison, but I suppose the subsidies that made those BOGOs possible can be fudged in the numbers.

All in all, I'd say the 1Q volume is encouraging, though not overwhelmingly so, for the future of BD. It's certainly more encouraging than what I had estimated based on the weekly percentages vs. HD DVD. I'm pretty shocked that HD DVD sold over 1 million units in 1Q 2008. I know some people have scrambled to pick up titles while they can, but the general consensus has been that the disc firesale opportunities have been underwhelming.

True_Story1011 04-23-08 10:01 PM

I was pretty impressed with the amount of HD DVD stuff that was sold in the Q1'08.

Too bad its ramping down - I have a ton of titles that I still need! :(

Gizmo 04-23-08 10:59 PM


Originally Posted by kefrank
It would be interesting to see the revenue numbers for comparison, but I suppose the subsidies that made those BOGOs possible can be fudged in the numbers.

All in all, I'd say the 1Q volume is encouraging, though not overwhelmingly so, for the future of BD. It's certainly more encouraging than what I had estimated based on the weekly percentages vs. HD DVD. I'm pretty shocked that HD DVD sold over 1 million units in 1Q 2008. I know some people have scrambled to pick up titles while they can, but the general consensus has been that the disc firesale opportunities have been underwhelming.

Q1 still had a handful of big titles for HD DVD. American Gangster comes to mind...and thats it, lol.

speedyray 04-23-08 11:12 PM

The pie graph I am watching is the vs DVD one. To say that BD and HDM in general really matters, it needs to be over 10% week in and week out IMHO. I am a few issues behind so I have a whole stack of those charts laying around the house and I think the best week was like 8%. If they want volume in Q2 they need some major sales - the economy is tight and $25+ titles don't fit in mine or lots of others budgets, $20 for titles I really want happens sometimes - but really I need $15 disc wether from sales or BOGO deals.

Grubert 04-24-08 02:57 AM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
Holidays typically will have a huge raise in sales anyway. We had many big titles come out in Q4 then Q1. But a few million extras players sold also help. Q4 also had weekly BOGOs as well. I know I personally bought at least 50 movies in Q4.

Exactly. What with the hot DVD titles released in Q4 and the general holiday buying season, the following Q1 is usually slower.

However, in this case, BD sales in Q1 2008 were 22% bigger than BD sales in Q4 2007. That's impressive.

DVD Polizei 04-24-08 05:21 AM

Are these actual consumer sales or "sales" included such as Netflix receiving a buttload of Blu-ray discs for rentals.

Grubert 04-24-08 07:10 AM


Originally Posted by DVD Polizei
Are these actual consumer sales or "sales" included such as Netflix receiving a buttload of Blu-ray discs for rentals.

Consumer sales, per previous lengthy discussion at avsforum.

Not that Netflix is receiving anything like a buttload of Blu-ray discs, judging from the inordinate wait times subscribers enjoy. ;)

Michael Corvin 04-24-08 07:53 AM


Originally Posted by Adam Tyner
Q2 sales could be interesting -- April has been pretty sparse, and out of the entirety of May, there are really only two big titles: Rambo and National Treasure 2.

I'd have to say The Lion the Witch & the Wardrobe will be pretty huge. That also comes out in May. Especially with Prince Caspian releasing a few days later.

Gizmo 04-24-08 08:09 AM


Originally Posted by Grubert
Exactly. What with the hot DVD titles released in Q4 and the general holiday buying season, the following Q1 is usually slower.

However, in this case, BD sales in Q1 2008 were 22% bigger than BD sales in Q4 2007. That's impressive.

Yes, and the PS3 selling better in Q4 of 2007 rather then any other quarter helped those sales as well (for Q1 2008). I imagine it may be a long time before we get numbers instead of %s. 22% increase can be an additional 50k-100k titles sold, and lets be honest, its not that impressive.

Grubert 04-24-08 08:26 AM


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
I imagine it may be a long time before we get numbers instead of %s. 22% increase can be an additional 50k-100k titles sold, and lets be honest, its not that impressive.

Uhh... We do have numbers. Mr. Cinema reposted them above.

And not only did you see them - you quoted them!


Originally Posted by GizmoDVD

Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Got these numbers from Grubert:

Q4 2007 BD sales: 3.1 million

Q1 2007 BD sales: 830,000


Keep in mind its been a year and that's a couple extra million PS3s sold as well, even at the new lower $400 price. Its almost a duhh that sales would be higher.

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...2&postcount=11

Thanks for giving me the surreal moment of the day. :D

Qui Gon Jim 04-24-08 08:28 AM


Originally Posted by speedyray
The pie graph I am watching is the vs DVD one. To say that BD and HDM in general really matters, it needs to be over 10% week in and week out IMHO. I am a few issues behind so I have a whole stack of those charts laying around the house and I think the best week was like 8%. If they want volume in Q2 they need some major sales - the economy is tight and $25+ titles don't fit in mine or lots of others budgets, $20 for titles I really want happens sometimes - but really I need $15 disc wether from sales or BOGO deals.

That chart is very deceptive. The number seems cherry-picked to look good for the BD format. Comparing the top ten selling titles in one format to the other doesn't tell the story. The 500th best selling DVD likely sells more than that top BD on any given week.

Said it before, and I'll say it again:
Without numbers, these percentages are meaningless.

Gizmo 04-24-08 08:51 AM


Originally Posted by Grubert
Uhh... We do have numbers. Mr. Cinema reposted them above.

And not only did you see them - you quoted them!


http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...2&postcount=11

Thanks for giving me the surreal moment of the day. :D

That's what I get for posting at 6am right when I wake up. :lol:

Do we have numbers for Q1 2008? Individual titles? Most of the time we only get %'s out of 100 and then people guessing at how many each copy sold by a press release some studio made about 1 Blu-ray (i.e. I Am Legend sold 100k copies this week, and since it sold 80% of BLANK movie, then BLANK movie sold 120k. Therefore we can determine Over American sold 6.2k copies). But besides the odd press release here and there, we typically get %'s for everything surrounding Blu-ray.

Gizmo 04-24-08 08:54 AM


Originally Posted by Qui Gon Jim
That chart is very deceptive. The number seems cherry-picked to look good for the BD format. Comparing the top ten selling titles in one format to the other doesn't tell the story. The 500th best selling DVD likely sells more than that top BD on any given week.

Said it before, and I'll say it again:
Without numbers, these percentages are meaningless.

Thats exactly why we get the Top 20 Blu-ray vs the Top 20 DVD....if they did ALL of Blu-ray vs. ALL of DVD each week the Pie graph would be .40 BR/90.60 DVD. I can only imagine how many copies that direct to DVD crap film Day of the Dead sold on DVD last week compared to Blu-ray :shudder:

speedyray 04-24-08 09:25 AM


Originally Posted by Qui Gon Jim
That chart is very deceptive. The number seems cherry-picked to look good for the BD format. Comparing the top ten selling titles in one format to the other doesn't tell the story. The 500th best selling DVD likely sells more than that top BD on any given week.

Said it before, and I'll say it again:
Without numbers, these percentages are meaningless.

Yeah, I know the chart is only a piece of the story, but for the most part it is a comparison of the new releases (gets the day and date titles) and the bestselling recent releases - so I view it as a reasonable way to watch buying trends. If BD is going to grow, catalog is probably less important at this point than generating large numbers with the new releases. Hence why it was news when No Country for Old Men did so well on BD in its first week.

Gizmo 04-24-08 09:48 AM

No Country only did well when you took its DVD sales into account. I Am Legend sold 3x more copies on Blu on its release week but the % was still lower then No Country compared to I AM Legends DVD sales. Its a very tricky sitution.

Josh Z 04-24-08 12:31 PM

Here's a new MSN article about Blu-ray's sales (or lack thereof):

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24274078/wid/11915829/

Mr. Cinema 04-24-08 12:51 PM


Originally Posted by Josh Z
Here's a new MSN article about Blu-ray's sales (or lack thereof):

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24274078/wid/11915829/

That didn't take long. I would've expected this sooner.

Were you able to read my response to your last post in the Universal thread before Adam deleted it?

applesandrice 04-24-08 12:58 PM

Come on, guys -- please keep things civil and constructive.

BuckNaked2k 04-24-08 01:00 PM


Originally Posted by Josh Z
Here's a new MSN article about Blu-ray's sales (or lack thereof):

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24274078/wid/11915829/

Thanks for posting that. It's a good article with some very interesting numbers in there.

Despite the title of the article, (and it's premise) they predict that Blu-ray sales will be in excess of $4 Billion a year 3-4 years from now.

Also noteworthy, was the extremely small predicted drop in average BD price during that same time.

kefrank 04-24-08 01:13 PM


Originally Posted by Josh Z
Here's a new MSN article about Blu-ray's sales (or lack thereof):

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24274078/wid/11915829/

um...that's the exact same Reuters article as the one Mr. Cinema linked in the original post, just with a different headline.

Josh Z 04-24-08 04:10 PM


Originally Posted by kefrank
um...that's the exact same Reuters article as the one Mr. Cinema linked in the original post, just with a different headline.

Point taken. He's gone onto my Ignore List, so I didn't see his link.

bunkaroo 04-24-08 04:22 PM

Ahh, less than 48 hours, and we're back to business as usual.

speedyray 04-24-08 05:59 PM

The article says average pricing will be 24.XX in 2011 - not if they want BD to succeed it won't. I don't buy anything over $20. Haven't so far and will not - I rent if I cannot get it under $20.

applesandrice 04-24-08 07:50 PM


Originally Posted by speedyray
The article says average pricing will be 24.XX in 2011 - not if they want BD to succeed it won't. I don't buy anything over $20. Haven't so far and will not - I rent if I cannot get it under $20.


They're talking average MSRP, though, right?

Mr. Cinema 04-24-08 09:09 PM


Originally Posted by kefrank
um...that's the exact same Reuters article as the one Mr. Cinema linked in the original post, just with a different headline.

The difference, of course, is one had a positive point of view of the article and the other predictably had a negative one. I will always be as positive as I can for the BD format because I want it to succeed. So I'll take any increase in sales as good news.

True_Story1011 04-24-08 09:28 PM

my cats breath smells like cat food. :)












its just a forum guys.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:34 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.