AvP Requiem BD missing unrated footage!
#1
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
AvP Requiem BD missing unrated footage!
Check out this thread in the AVS forum
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...6#post13653826
Another screw up from Fox!
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...6#post13653826
Another screw up from Fox!
#5
No kidding. If it's any fault HD will come to a hault, it will be because of idiots like this studio.
I personally can't believe the kind of treatment HD has been getting by the studios. Warner has done a pretty good job, even though I absolutely despise their company (btw, before they announced they were going Blu-ray).
I'm gonna be really picky when I buy my Blu-ray titles in the future. And this might be just me, but I see a lot of poor ratings for Blu-ray releases. More than usual. I mean seriously, if the studios know the release is going to look like shit...then DON'T FUCKING RELEASE IT and move on to something else we've been asking for. Jesus Christ in HD, already.
I personally can't believe the kind of treatment HD has been getting by the studios. Warner has done a pretty good job, even though I absolutely despise their company (btw, before they announced they were going Blu-ray).
I'm gonna be really picky when I buy my Blu-ray titles in the future. And this might be just me, but I see a lot of poor ratings for Blu-ray releases. More than usual. I mean seriously, if the studios know the release is going to look like shit...then DON'T FUCKING RELEASE IT and move on to something else we've been asking for. Jesus Christ in HD, already.
#6
Suspended
As far as 'quality' goes I would rank them...
Disney/Buena Vista
Sony
Universal
Warner/Newlines
Lionsgate
Paramount
...
...
...
Fox
So far it looks like several seconds are cut from the BD as well as it being darker in certain areas.
Disney/Buena Vista
Sony
Universal
Warner/Newlines
Lionsgate
Paramount
...
...
...
Fox
So far it looks like several seconds are cut from the BD as well as it being darker in certain areas.
#7
Banned by request
The missing footage is a few seconds, not all of the unrated footage. Just a single shot. And I had no problems with black crush or the film being too dark.
#8
Suspended
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
The missing footage is a few seconds, not all of the unrated footage. Just a single shot. And I had no problems with black crush or the film being too dark.
#9
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: May 2007
Location: The Phantom Zone
Posts: 2,656
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I guess this gives me a reason not to buy this title yet. I've been spending too much on HD DVD and Blu-ray lately anyway. My guess is that either Fox will not address this or will issue replacements through a mail-in program (as with the Star Wars OT DVD) and possibly quietly replace discs in upcoming production runs (as with the PoTC:CotBP Blu-ray)
#10
I'll be watching it this weekend. I don't care about the missing footage. I prefer what was shown in theaters most of the time, since that is the official release. I just hope it's not too dark for my eyes. DVD Talk and HD Digest both gave the video high marks, so I'm not worried.
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 1,055
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Artman
. . .this got near perfect marks by reviewers . . .
So did the first "Pirates of the Caribbean".
Boo!! Down with the reviewers! They're all on the take!! Everyone -- rise up and cast off the shackles of reviewer oppression! To arms, men! Burn, gouge, poke and noogie!!!
Holy crap -- I've gotta switch to decaf.
#13
DVD Talk Special Edition
I'm highly doubting 20th Century is going to take care of this - But I guess time will only tell.
Has anyone tried contacting them to see what they have planned for this goof?
Has anyone tried contacting them to see what they have planned for this goof?
#14
DVD Talk Hero
The disc provides both the unrated and theatrical cuts of the movie, though some claim one short scene involving gore has been left out of the unrated cut on the Blu-ray. The disc itself is pure reference all the way through. Anyone that has problems with black levels from this disc doesn't have their display properly calibrated to pass blacker than black data. There is not one moment of black crush in the entire film.
#16
Suspended
Originally Posted by dx23
what's wrong with Die Hard? And which Die Hard by the way?
#17
Originally Posted by Suprmallet
The missing footage is a few seconds, not all of the unrated footage. Just a single shot. And I had no problems with black crush or the film being too dark.
#19
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: AUSTIN - Land of Mexican Coke
Posts: 3,921
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
So is the digital copy actually on the disc? The reason I ask is that it shows up in itunes in the "purchased" folder. I wondered if it just unlocked an itunes version and downloaded from the store
#21
DVD Talk God
Can anyone confirm there's an audio pop about 12:20 in? Very loud and sounded like a gunshot in my house.
Luckily this is a rental.
Luckily this is a rental.
#22
Senior Member
I watched most of it the other night. It takes alot for me to stop watching a disc, especially a Blu-ray disc that I waited to get/BB Online. Crappy PQ, it was way too dark. My wife kept on asking me what was going on, I told her I couldn't tell half of the time either. We both agreed to turn it off.
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Deftones
Can anyone confirm there's an audio pop about 12:20 in? Very loud and sounded like a gunshot in my house.
Luckily this is a rental.
Luckily this is a rental.
#24
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Los Angeles,CA, U.S.A.
Posts: 646
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by trubiet
I watched most of it the other night. It takes alot for me to stop watching a disc, especially a Blu-ray disc that I waited to get/BB Online. Crappy PQ, it was way too dark. My wife kept on asking me what was going on, I told her I couldn't tell half of the time either. We both agreed to turn it off.
Yep. Aside from the film being nearly incomprehensible what with the film being way too dark for it's own good, the fact that that alien walks around sporting dreadlocks makes fights between it and the Predator, also sporting dreadlocks, impossible to follow.
And don't even get me started on the menus. I have to rate these by far the WORST menu's I have ever seen on ANY DVD. Bar none.
and finally.. What? Is 29.99 now the "sale" price rather than the average cost?? Way to kill off any interest in HD media.
I'd say that this was a waste of money. Because of the film being too dark, I really don't see any benefit in the BD version from the standard DVD version. You'll still get a crappy dark hard to follow picture regardless.
don't better films just do night scenes with blue light to represent darkness. It's "darkness" you can actually see what's going on !
Last edited by whomod; 04-27-08 at 04:37 PM.
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Artman
This is actually an existing problem with many of the master audio formated discs (fox's). It doesn't appear to be a disc problem (they're likely all the same) but a hardware issue. A couple yrs into the format and you'd hope we'd be past things like this...sigh...
To be accurate there are a total of 12 titles (including AvP 2) with this confirmed, 2 of which are HD DVD's, and several others are imports.
Make no mistake, this is a serious issue, but I would not call this many of the discs. it also only affects those who are bitstreaming, so those using the PS3 or other players to decode internally are not at risk.
I encourage everyone to check the linked thread, as it provides a wealth of knowledge on the subject including how to update several kinds of receiver to eliminate the issue. I updated my Onkyo 605 with no issues and the problem disappeared.