Blu-ray titles missing extras from DVD
03-08-08 | 03:48 PM
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 3,422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Pacific Northwest
Blu-ray titles missing extras from DVD
I'd like to track all the Blu-ray titles that fail to carry over the full slate of bonus materials from their standard DVD counterparts. Hopefully this will help a lot of us who want to avoid falling prey to potentially pre-planned double-dips by the studios and also let us know which DVD's we may want to hang on to for the time being.
So please post any that you know of so I can add them to my list. To keep things simple, I guess we can say it's okay if the only missing stuff is relatively inconsequential (like a missing foreign language track, or talent bios or something), but nothing substantial - no missing documentaries, featurettes, commentary tracks, deleted scenes, alternate cuts, original trailers, etc.
Blu-ray titles that are MISSING extras found on DVD's:
Black Hawk Down
The Departed
Die Hard
Die Hard 2
Die Hard with a Vengeance
Donnie Brasco (Extended Cut)
The Patriot (Extended Cut)
Planet Earth
The Terminator
Terminator 2: Judgment Day
Top Gun
Total Recall
So please post any that you know of so I can add them to my list. To keep things simple, I guess we can say it's okay if the only missing stuff is relatively inconsequential (like a missing foreign language track, or talent bios or something), but nothing substantial - no missing documentaries, featurettes, commentary tracks, deleted scenes, alternate cuts, original trailers, etc.
Blu-ray titles that are MISSING extras found on DVD's:
Black Hawk Down
The Departed
Die Hard
Die Hard 2
Die Hard with a Vengeance
Donnie Brasco (Extended Cut)
The Patriot (Extended Cut)
Planet Earth
The Terminator
Terminator 2: Judgment Day
Top Gun
Total Recall
Last edited by joliom; 03-14-08 at 04:54 AM.
03-08-08 | 05:24 PM
#4
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally Posted by steelpotato
The Road Warrior has the trailer that the sd had, + commentary for HD/Blu.
03-09-08 | 09:20 AM
#6
DVD Talk Legend
I think there are just too many to list. Warner has probably released around 150-200 titles, and most of them carry over the extras or even add more. Probably 85% or more of Universal's titles port them over, and most or all of Disney's titles from the past year have them too. The only Paramount titles I can think of that dropped extras are Top Gun and the aborted Jack Ryan Collection, but at least they have fewer titles to track down and list. Sony and Lionsgate have gotten much better about including them after those initial waves of MPEG-2 single-layer discs in 2006. New Line has included everything AFAIK. It's really only Fox (and by extension, MGM) at this point that continues to be bad about it, though there are exceptions here and there.
That's just the major (and almost major) studios. Who knows how many smaller labels carry over their extras? We probably would have to count those that were barebones on DVD, as those wouldn't actually be missing anything.
You'd probably be better off coming up with a list of titles that don't have all of the extras, with asterisks for titles like Serenity that had a SE on DVD after the HD DVD was already out.
That's just the major (and almost major) studios. Who knows how many smaller labels carry over their extras? We probably would have to count those that were barebones on DVD, as those wouldn't actually be missing anything.
You'd probably be better off coming up with a list of titles that don't have all of the extras, with asterisks for titles like Serenity that had a SE on DVD after the HD DVD was already out.
03-09-08 | 01:45 PM
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Someone hasn't mentioned Cars and Ratatouille yets.
03-10-08 | 06:00 AM
#8
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 3,422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Pacific Northwest
Originally Posted by Drexl
I think there are just too many to list. Warner has probably released around 150-200 titles, and most of them carry over the extras or even add more. Probably 85% or more of Universal's titles port them over, and most or all of Disney's titles from the past year have them too. The only Paramount titles I can think of that dropped extras are Top Gun and the aborted Jack Ryan Collection, but at least they have fewer titles to track down and list. Sony and Lionsgate have gotten much better about including them after those initial waves of MPEG-2 single-layer discs in 2006. New Line has included everything AFAIK. It's really only Fox (and by extension, MGM) at this point that continues to be bad about it, though there are exceptions here and there.
That's just the major (and almost major) studios. Who knows how many smaller labels carry over their extras? We probably would have to count those that were barebones on DVD, as those wouldn't actually be missing anything.
You'd probably be better off coming up with a list of titles that don't have all of the extras, with asterisks for titles like Serenity that had a SE on DVD after the HD DVD was already out.
That's just the major (and almost major) studios. Who knows how many smaller labels carry over their extras? We probably would have to count those that were barebones on DVD, as those wouldn't actually be missing anything.
You'd probably be better off coming up with a list of titles that don't have all of the extras, with asterisks for titles like Serenity that had a SE on DVD after the HD DVD was already out.
03-11-08 | 08:05 AM
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Just started watching the Blu-ray version of Planet Earth and was STUNNED to discover that the extra "Planet Earth Diaries" (a 10-minute how-we-did-it video relating to each specific episode) were NOT included on this set. At 110 minutes total combined, that is QUITE a large omission of extras from the SD set. (And IMHO those diaries are almost if not more rivetting than the episodes themselves in some cases!)
